HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

willoremus

18 karma · joined January 23, 2013

submissionscomments
willoremus··on Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
Facebook doesn't share your personal info with third parties--at least, not with advertisers. The fact that it allowed you to hand over that information to third-party developers (not advertisers) is the root of the Cambridge Analytica scandal.
willoremus··on Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
This is a good analogy. Near the bottom of my piece I propose, "If you're not paying for it with money, you're paying for it in some other way." Admittedly that's fairly clunky.

In a critique of my piece on Twitter, NY Magazine's Max Read suggests, more succinctly: "There's no such thing as a free lunch" https://twitter.com/max_read/status/989893433639755776

That bit of folk wisdom isn't going to wow anybody in a TED Talk, but I think it's more apt than "you're the product."

willoremus··on Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
Yes, I agree with all of this. I guess I was writing my explanation above at the same time you were writing this.
willoremus··on Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
You're right, I probably could have done a better job citing sources on these claims. You can read about Larry Page and Sergey Brin's early anti-ads stance in any number of books about Google, or in their own published paper that first introduced the idea for Google: http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html

I summarized a lot of the literature in this article a while back about how Google landed on its business model: http://www.slate.com/articles/business/when_big_businesses_w...

See in particular John Battelle's "The Search" (2005), Steven Levy's "In the Plex" (2011), and Doug Edwards' "I'm Feeling Lucky" (2011).

As for Facebook, there's probably less public documentation but I have been following/covering it from very early on and personally know a few of its earliest employees. Ads have never been Zuck's focus.

Again, as I say in this piece, the fact that these companies didn't set out to become advertising/surveillance juggernauts doesn't excuse anything. They absolutely are. But I raised this point about their mission and origins to help explain why it seems obvious to those companies' leaders that customers' data is not their primary product.