HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

win311fwg

188 karma · joined December 18, 2025

submissionscomments
win311fwg··on I'm not convinced the AI bubble exists
Anthropic/OpenAI and the investors are the same thing. A company name is just a title for the people who own it.

Maybe you mean that you could see the employees of those companies (although I imagine they also own it, so that's a wrinkle) staging a coup to seize the army for themselves? That's certainly possible. They'd be in a good position to do so. Predicting the future is impossible, but if you want to be on the "right side" of that future army, owning its foundation today is still a reasonable bet.

win311fwg··on I'm not convinced the AI bubble exists
You're right that Google has been greatly helped by having what has been considered the most powerful army (the US army) backing them. They wouldn't have had a hope in hell of surpassing the "mom and pop" stage without that.

But I am not sure you are right that it is powerful enough to secure all. I search daily, but cannot remember the last time I used Google. The other AI companies do it better. And I'm not alone in that sentiment. Google's stock price recently took a nosedive because investors have grown quite worried about the competition. Without a sufficiently powerful army stopping them, there will always be someone else ready to try to outdo you.

win311fwg··on I'm not convinced the AI bubble exists
> AI can understand human language.

It is a bit comical how the HN crowd spent the last number of decades trying to convince the audience that a programmer's value was actually in their system thinking, not their arcane knowledge of a particular language, but now that the language barrier is removed it turns out it was just the arcane language knowledge after all...

Although I'd posit that the old school HNers were the ones actually right. From what I see in the average Joes is that, while they can communicate with AI, they don't really see how to leverage it. Granted, the younger generations grew up in a school system that tried to promote system thinking more so than in the past, so that gap will likely shrink over time.

win311fwg··on I'm not convinced the AI bubble exists
> and can just charge whatever you want for your magic beans.

'Winner take all' doesn't mean convincing others to buy your product. If others have something to buy your product with, you've not taken all, fundamentally.

'Winner take all' means having the most powerful army. The assumption is that once AI crosses a certain threshold then there won't be anything the rest of us can do to stop the machine of whomever gets there first, so they will truly be able to take all. Hence why the AI labs sometimes hint about the risk of human destruction.

win311fwg··on RIP Cybertruck
Exactly why the power source being the truck I already own anyway is far more appealing, at least it would be if the aforementioned problems were solved. Special tools come with special costs that don't really make sense most of the time.
win311fwg··on RIP Cybertruck
The power being delivered on wheels that go with you is the whole point. A permanently affixed generator doesn't help get power out into the middle of the field when I need to do things like weld farm equipment. There are plenty of solutions out there, but the power source and truck carrying the tools being one and the same would be quite attractive if the aforementioned problems were solved.
win311fwg··on Tesla to wind down Cybertruck production
Compared to other pickups on the road, he's not wrong. It wasn't a good design, but the competition isn't very fierce.
win311fwg··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
Not understanding my own comments is a wild take. You might want to slow down between posts.
win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
The fake posting aspect would be off-topic, so it would be far more worrying if comments were being made about something not even being discussed.

I think you are right that some people didn't bother to read the entire discussion and then started throwing shit out at random. That is the HN way.

win311fwg··on A new Go API for JSON
And there was plenty of effort given by others who also weren't experts. There was no lack of trying within a sea of incapable people. Unfortunately, that wasn't what the project needed. It already had a team full of blub developers, it being a language for them.
win311fwg··on A new Go API for JSON
The same people who were working on generics in Go prior to v1 were also still there to help out when it eventually landed, so whatever stones, clubs, and pitchforks you saw weren't compelling enough to scare one away from making it happen. Not that anyone would expect them to. Meaningless distractions don't get in the way when doing something is worthwhile.

But obviously "go doesn't have generics lol" comments on HN were even more important. Just think of what would have happened if that wasn't repeated multiple times daily for years and that effort was put into getting Go generics into place much sooner. Count your lucky stars or something.

win311fwg··on A new Go API for JSON
Nobody is keen about language features. Each new one adds complexity. That isn't the same as failing to recognize a need, though. And we know the Go team recognized the need as they clearly kept working on generics all the way from the very beginnings up until the Haskell muscle showed up. The receipts are there. The results just weren't good, as one would expect from a team who weren't shy to say that they didn't have the expertise necessary.

You'd think one of the HN experts would have shown up to offer that expertise, but I guess there was a lot of "go doesn't have generics lol" needing to get out.

win311fwg··on A new Go API for JSON
> instead of hand-waving it away as needless fluff.

If you go back and watch the original Go announcement it was made abundantly clear that they believed Go did need generics but that they didn't have the expertise to do it. Yes it is true that the book was already written on it, but that doesn't mean anyone on the Go team was familiar with it or had the time to become familiar with it. Programming languages do not require gods to design them. Imperfect humans can too.

The experts on HN who know all the ins and outs of generics could have contributed but, you know, shitposting "go doesn't have generics lol" was a better use of their time. There are so many hours in the day.

win311fwg··on A new Go API for JSON
> generics (something that I still haven't used beyond the tutorials) took an age as well

Only about a year from when the Haskell guys lent their expertise in designing it and it landing in a release. That's actually fairly quick given that it was a pretty significant change under the hood and constrained by only two releases annually.

The Go team was always clear that they didn't have the necessary capabilities internally, despite a lot of failed efforts trying anyway, and were relying on the open source community to lend a hand. Unfortunately, open source doesn't mean open willingness to contribute. It turns out that for all the experts on HN, posting "go doesn't have generics lol" was preferable to helping out.

win311fwg··on AI is forcing us to pay off 40 years of technical debt
Ish. I remember when the earliest versions of Rails used a CGI runner. Development didn't carry on long before application startup time became so horrendously slow that it was no longer viable. That is when it started to become popular to add a server in the application.

Now that people are back to writing their applications in languages that aren't as slow as Ruby they've, in many cases, taken the server back out of their application and have returned to the CGI model again; what is often marketed as "serverless".

win311fwg··on AI isn't replacing SREs, it's deskilling them
I believe it is more than you've missed the forest for the trees. You haven't accurately explained what understanding means. One might not rigorously understand x÷x=1 but still 'naturally' see that having two apples and taking one leaves one. And that's the thing: The genie, as in LLMs, are analogy machines so you can approach problems without a formal understanding as long as you can grasp the analogies. We have real world proof with 'vibe coders' producing incredibly complex math without much formal understanding of it. They know how to describe the input and interpret the output using words that relate to everyday things that they are familiar with, much like the apples on the table, and it accomplishes their goal.

Perhaps there is a limit, sure, but I suppose that's where you lead with a concrete example to explain where that line is.

win311fwg··on AI isn't replacing SREs, it's deskilling them
Is basic arithmetic something that can be forgotten? Studies have suggested that even infants have an understanding of basic arithmetic. There is a reasonable likelihood that it is something innate.

As we're only imagining anyway, let's ignore the genie for a moment. If we did lose our sense of basic arithmetic all of a sudden what would life at its core even be like? If there were two apples on a table you wouldn't be able to comprehend what happens if you took one. Would we even be able to function like that?

win311fwg··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
> It still requires a government to keep people from stealing, defrauding, and murdering each other.

Under a free market one voluntarily buys protection, negotiates with relevant parties how arbitration is to be conducted, and so on. These are all part of the market just the same. A "free market" that isn't free continues, despite your insistence, to be nonsensical.

When was the last time you made an offer to your police force? Under your free market definition it is necessary for you to express your demand position, else supply and demand cannot be determined. Yet, I suspect your answer is never. There isn't a free market for you to express that in. It is not something you have to think about as the single desk has already sorted it for you.

What you are thinking of, again, is a mixed economy, where the government has taken control and regulates some submarkets. That is how our world functions. A market having unconstrained submarkets that see prices determined by supply and demand isn't the same as a free market. What to call the submarkets within a mixed economy that are based on supply and demand isn't generally accepted as there isn't usually much reason to need to talk about it, but I posit "unregulated market" remains the leading contender for what shows up most often when one is trying to single it out. "free market" is a non-starter as it already means something else in the same context, as seen in the very definition you gave us.

You are, of course, revealing one of the reasons why we've never seen a free market. The concept is full of unresolved problems that make the whole thing untenable in practice. I think we can agree it is almost certain that people wouldn't be able to handle themselves if there wasn't a government automatically providing those things for them. But that's the nature of a thought experiment—It doesn't have to be realistic.

win311fwg··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
You are mixing up different ideas again. It is true that anarchy is necessary for a free market. The way we understand how to take us away from anarchy is to place restrictions on possible markets! But anarchy can also exist without a free market. Anarchy isn't another point on the so-called continuum. Like socialism, it is looking at something else entirely.

A "free market" where the market isn't free doesn't make sense linguistically or within what "free market" is defined as. Of course a situation where some submarkets are unconstrained and others restricted can exist — not only can, that's how we already live — but when that occurs we call it a mixed economy. Our current world exists under a mixed economy.

I suspect your confusion stems from trying to apply the ideas of free market, which refers to a broad market economy, onto only the submarkets that are unconstrained. If you could magically ignore all the restricted markets then your logic would be reasonable, but in the real world we cannot ignore the rest of the world around us. It exists whether you like it or not. Unfortunately there is no generally accepted term for this, which is no doubt why you've wanted to use "free market" to fill the void, despite it already having a different meaning, but "unregulated market" is the one I have seen used most often in that context. You might consider using that going forward. I expect most will understand what you are trying to say without confusing them into thinking you are talking about free market in the proper sense and will allow you to converse with those who already made it clear that they were talking about free market in the proper sense.

win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
> Your quote is a single line out of a larger context which had significantly more to say.

The larger context is a completely different discussion, and one that isn't particularly interesting to have, at least on my side. It wasn't narrowed arbitrarily. I can appreciate that you might find that other topic interesting, but there are plenty of other parallel discussions taking place about that. You don't need to shit up this one with more of the same in order to engage with it. Let's leave the bad faith at the door.

win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
> You have either accidentally misinterpreted or deliberately misrepresented the expression "using AI to fake posting activity" to mean

The original comment asserted: "Using AI to fake posting activity is bad." So, yes, I agree that "bad" is ill-defined, but our discussion, aside from your ridiculous diversions, has been about trying to break down what that really means. If it was already well understood there wouldn't be a discussion to have here.

Now, we don't know what you think it means since you don't seem to want to participate in good faith, but what it doesn't mean is some idea of 'taking over accounts', as the comment in question goes on to talk about that later as a separate idea.

> Then you kept doubling down on there being nothing wrong with passing off AI activity as human activity.

I'm not sure what you're getting at here. Not only does it not seem to have any relevance to the discussion, we currently lack the technology to make AI look human, so, while that may become a future problem, there is currently not a concern. Currently we only ever see AI in places where one is able to see, without ambiguity, that they are looking at the product of software.

Whether or not that hypothetical future needs to see passing AI activity off as being human as being "wrong" is really for the future to decide. We cannot realistically imagine what other conditions might exist in that time to consider the full picture. AI being able to appear human, if we ever get there, will not be the only evolution in technology and society to take place. It won't be today's world with one variable tweaked. Looking at it through today's lens is foolish at best.

win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
> This is not what I'm saying!

It is not what you said, but it is the context that defines what we're talking about. I reiterated it to remind you of what the original reply isolated from a bunch of other ideas that were also thrown around as it was starting to look like you had forgotten what we were discussing, perhaps confused by parallel discussions that branched off in different directions. This seems to confirm that you had forgotten, although perhaps that is a misinterpretation on my part. So that we're clear, are you implying here that you've been trying to change the subject in bad faith?

win311fwg··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
> There's a continuum between free markets and socialism.

Uh, what? That's like saying there is a continuum between cold and far. Your comparison points are not in the same realm. Consider a free market where all actors decide to form cooperatives. That, however unlikely in practice, would result in both free markets and socialism at the same time. A free market does not care about how the people decide to divvy up capital. The people deciding to share ownership in the capital is perfectly valid within a free market. If "free market" was prescriptive about how people must trade then it would be completely contradictory.

> Also, a free market requires a government. The role of government is to protect life, liberty, and property.

Absolutely not. In a free market, one negotiates with private vendors to offer these services. A government is the antithesis of a free market, being a monopolistic vendor that you don't get to opt out of. A voluntary organization could emerge in a free market to provide those services to those who wish to join without having to individually negotiate, which would closely resemble the governments we know, but key is that it membership is optional. What makes a government more than an association is that you don't get to choose. The market cannot be free if you cannot choose who to buy from.

You could more reasonably say that there is a continuum between free markets and planned economies. It is still flawed as none of this is one-dimensional, but for the sake of simplification we can run with it. The space between is referred to as mixed economy, not free market.

win311fwg··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
Never in recorded human history has there been a free market, so naturally you've never seen one. Kingdoms, governments, etc. emerged out of the old kinship economies long before the idea of free markets was conceived of and they never went away.
win311fwg··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
We obviously cannot know.

However, what we do know is that a free market requires management people today aren't accustomed to. Suddenly you are fully responsible to negotiate protection, transit, etc. That is a burden many would find off-putting and, in many cases, something beyond their capabilities.

If we were magically dropped into a free market tomorrow it is likely we would quickly attach ourselves to whomever is willing to give us those things without needing extra thought, just like the monopoly does today, and – tada – we're right back to the way things are right now.

If we were born into a free market and didn't know anything else then monopolies might be harder to pull off. That said, while the initial conditions were a bit different, we've been in a similar situation before and the monopoly won in the end.

win311fwg··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
> I'd argue that in a pure free market without intervention, monopolies would be disappointingly common

How? If a monopoly were to emerge in what was a pure free market, it would become the government, and its rules would become regulation on the market. And thus the pure free market could no longer exist. Monopolies and free markets cannot coexist.

win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
> For me, the whole concept of online forums is interacting with semi-anonymous humans

This is where things break down for me. You want to take humans out of the equation by making any humans that may exist in the process anonymous, to disassociate their involvement, but then worry that the anonymous computer avatars may not be human?

I could at least have a bit more appreciation if you were talking about Facebook Groups, where there is greater effort to make those computer avatars appear human (real names, photos, etc.), but PhysicsForum, HN, and the like chose, seemingly on purpose, to not go in that direction.

If you really want to have discussions with humans, which is valid, why not go outside and meet them where they are found?

> but also the slogan is "science by humans"

If an automotive forum's slogan was "All About Cars" you would disavow any human who uses it? Science by humans can be discussed by non-humans, no? Something and the discussion of something are logically not the same thing.

> Why would anybody make an account on an "expert discussion" site to be misrepresented?

What do you believe is being misrepresented when AI content is posted on a forum? There is no promise of human activity on the typical online forum. To return us to the top, since maybe you've lost sight of what we were talking about, "Using AI to fake posting activity is bad." — but it remains unclear to me why it is bad. I can see how it might end up being low quality "slop", but that is for the users to decide. There is the possibility that users don't find it to be of poor quality and actually enjoy it.

win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
As the one who isolated the context out of the OP the carried forward into the remainder of this discussion, I can confirm 9rx has it right. Any bad faith attempts to bring in points unrelated to the discussion that was taking place are rightfully ignored.
win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
> In my mind this destroys the core value proposition of the site: reputation.

The question was: Where is anything on PhysicsForum presented as human activity? Because I don't see it. It is modelled like most other online message forums, including HN, which explicitly remove any suggestion that there could be humans involved behind the scenes. Which is the whole point! Online forums are for when you want something other than the human experience. When one wants the human experience they go where humans are found.

> If this is a clever pivot than I could use some help understanding the intended direction.

Allegedly the site was effectively dead and this was the operator's attempt to resurrect it. Was it clever? Probably not, but if the operator was clever it wouldn't have reached the point of near death in the first place. What are we expecting here? A miracle worker to come along and give the operator supernatural powers to abate his natural limitations? Not everyone is going to be as smart or capable as you are.

win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
> The "fake" aspect is the fact that it's presented as human activity.

Where? I admittedly hadn't heard of PhysicsForum before this, so I don't know what it looked liked before, but at time of writing it seems to be structured a lot like HN or most other online forums where there is no semblance of human activity, just computer avatars. Last time I checked human activity comes with humans. Anthropomorphizing software does not make it human.

> Are you excited to generate an account and communicate with experts such as the ones in the article today?

If it is interesting and enjoyable, why not? I don't care about how the software works. I know HN accounts tend to get caught up in comments expressing things like nobody will use software unless it is written in Rust and stuff like that, but interested parties of a product don't think like that. They evaluate a product for what it is, not how it works beneath the sheets.

If you are asking if PhysicsForum in particular is a good product, I cannot meaningfully answer. It is not something that would have floated my boat at any point. From my point of view it never was, but it is apparent that sentiment hasn't been shared, although apparently there has been a meaningful decline in interest so it seems it hasn't held up as a product over time. Key here is that whatever controversial changes were made were made because interest in the product had declined so much already.

What's curious is that nobody was complaining about how bad it had become amid that long decline. They just walked away when it wasn't good anymore. Yet here we are, where you can still walk away all the same, but somehow that's the end of the world?

← PreviousPage 3 of 20Next →