HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

win311fwg

188 karma · joined December 18, 2025

submissionscomments
win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
Well that didn't take long for Godwin to show up. Purposeful or lazy?
win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
The thing is that, by common definition, a problem ceases to be a problem when there is a solution. To not remove problems from the pool once they are solved would leave everything to be a problem forevermore, which isn't useful. I appreciate your desire to want to play a game of semantics and pet definitions so you can get your pent up angst out, but it is uninteresting. To restore good faith, how about you introduce an actual problem into the discussion?
win311fwg··on PhysicsForums and the Dead Internet Theory (2025)
2022 is when tech funding dried up, so it stands to reason that we ran out of hacker topics. The odd person still doing something cool in their basement for fun does not supply a sufficient stream of curiosities to keep the feed full. That required the unique time (ZIRP, etc.) when people were paid handsomely to explore cool things day in, day out.

HN was a product of its time.

--

> They are still being posted at the same rate based on my filtering.

"I rewrote X in Rust" isn't a hacker topic. Being able to draw some kind of connection to the tech isn't the same thing.

win311fwg··on America has lost 200k of jobs in media, film and the arts. How much is AI?
> But existing homeowners don't like to see their home prices go down!

As a homeowner I don't want to see my home price go down relative to all other homes as that leaves me in a precious position if I need to move, but if all homes fall in price together then that actually makes the prospect of moving less risky as, if I have to move into a house that is a step-up from the one I have, the cost to do so is lower. That would be an improvement over the status quo. High housing prices are a problem even for those with significant equity in a home.

But who doesn't want to see their wage go down is those who build houses. This is the bottleneck. The vast majority of people cannot afford a new house, which means they're stuck in their used houses, which means there is no inventory opening up for those with no houses.

> it's just that the solutions are deeply unpopular.

Is it? The solution in motion is to use AI to push software developers out of software development so that they have to become construction workers, thereby increasing the supply of construction workers, pushing construction wages down. It doesn't seem that unpopular (at least not outside of HN, but even on HN many welcome it with open arms). Maybe it will become unpopular once the motions are complete? That's a tad bit late, though.

win311fwg··on AI Is Not a Tool
> I would engage with this if it wasn't written so rudely.

No you wouldn't. Intellectual thought isn't swayed by meaningless human emotion. Let's be honest, you won't engage because you can't prepare a coherent response. We see this same diatribe in response to every other reply in this discussion. The pattern is clear.

> My original comment may have been a bit sarcastic

Yet you leave no affordances for that also being true of the earlier comment? A curious double standard. Confirms your true intention. What were you hoping to gain by trying to give us a thinly veiled lie? It's not like anyone cares about you posting something stupid on the internet. We don't even know who you are.

win311fwg··on AI Is Not a Tool
> it doesn't have consciousness

As measured, how?

Aside from your groundbreaking research that we're learning about for the first time, the science has held that we have no idea what is and isn't conscious, or if consciousness is even a thing. Humans tend to like to think they are, but it is philosophically accepted that it could be an illusion. So it is astounding that you aren't gushing with details. Maybe you don't understand the magnitude of your findings?

win311fwg··on No Need for Retirement When Utopia Is Around the Corner
> No ... actually yes

Nice to see someone update their worldview on new information. Doesn't happen often.

win311fwg··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
Whatever you want it to mean. Embrace your autonomy.
win311fwg··on Disney Raising Prices Days After Confirming Ads Will Now Show Up on Every Tier
For now.
win311fwg··on No Need for Retirement When Utopia Is Around the Corner
If there is nothing like UBI to give access to the AI-driven world then won't the 'have nots' fracture into their own subeconomy where they have to work for each other in order to survive, thereby giving them jobs again?
win311fwg··on No Need for Retirement When Utopia Is Around the Corner
> That's also how politics has worked since (at least) 2015.

You accidentally added 1, 2, and 5.

win311fwg··on What shall I teach my son?
> 40% of adults in 1st world countries can't do arithmetic.

Including whomever wrote the article.

"Suppose, a litre of cola costs US$3.15. If you buy one third of a litre of cola, how much would you pay?"

As cola has a large size-indpedenent cost, I would reasonably expect to need to pay more than the claimed $1.05 if 1 L is $3.15. Moreover, the marginal utility of 1 L isn't 3x more than the smaller container. There is no need to have that much soda when an appropriately scaled option is available. Based on real-world prices I could find (YMMV), 1 L of cola sells for $1.99, while a can (355 mL; about as close to 1/3 of 1 L as we find for actual sale) sells for $1.69, echoing that $1.05 is not a realistic price to pay on the open market. Most importantly, in actual practice I'd pay nothing for cola and order water instead.

And he is supposedly a lecturer in Economics and Social Statistics at a fairly well respected school. Goes to show, again, that the kids won't learn unless they want to. Forcing teaching upon someone plain doesn't work. Never has, never will. Incentivizing one to want to learn can work, but that's something else entirely and not at all what we're talking about.

win311fwg··on Code is clay now
If there is a threshold, it is certainly not obvious.

There has been no apparent change in the medium. Developers are still writing out their code in a programming language, inputting that code into a compiler, and see another representation of that program come out on the other side. Just like we've been doing since the early days of using digital switching. Whether or not a compiler is built using an LLM is just an implementation detail.

It does appear that the REPL has grown in popularity where in the past was used sparingly, but I don't really think a small difference in input method is a change in medium. I don't consider the introduction of punchcards to have been a change in medium over when switches were switched by hand either. It is still actuating the same mechanical switches.

Today's programming languages are way better than the ones we had even a few years ago. Like night and day difference. I suspect that is where your threshold idea is coming from. But, like, today's mechanical saws are way better than the early mechanical saws but I don't think we would normally consider a woodworker to be an artisan just because he's using a primitive deathtrap instead of a modern sawstop. Perhaps I'm out of touch with the kids today, but I expect an artisan woodworker is normally considered one that uses hand tools — that being a different medium from mechanized tools which do the work in a completely different way, not just an earlier version of the same thing.

win311fwg··on Code is clay now
It is true that there is no official body of standards and measures that defines exactly where artisan begins and ends, but it seems typically that the threshold occurs when the medium changes. To stay with your example, artisan bread is generally to be considered bread that isn't prepared mechanically.

Computing saw as similar medium shift from, as it pertains to programming, mechanical switching to digital switching. And I posit that is the threshold.

But we've yet to leave the digital switching realm. We still write our programs the same way we did 50 years ago. The compilers have gotten way, way, way more featureful and smarter, but it is still the same old story: You write a program in a language the computer can interpret, feed it to a compiler (or layers of compilers), and out comes something the machine can execute.

win311fwg··on Code is clay now
The traditional way to program computers is using switches, wires, and plugs. If you are still programming computers that way, I think we can fairly call you an artisan.

Calling people who write programs in yesterday's programming language that really only differ from today's programming language by having fewer built-in keywords 'artisans' is, per your definition, a stretch. We've been adding more and more built-ins to programming languages ever since the first one was created.

win311fwg··on What shall I teach my son?
> If you speak math problems to your child you are… wait for it… teaching them arithmetic. That’s what teaching is.

Exposure to something and being taught something are usually recognized as being quite different, but it is clear now that you just want to play a game of semantics, so we can put and end to that.

> I doubt a kid would even pick up language if you never spoke to them directly, and instead they just heard bits in passing between adults.

Kids not being able pick up on language by listening to a recording of adults speaking about some random thing is supported by the research so there is likely some validity to the latter half of your claim, with some assumptions about what you mean about "heard in passing", but the research also strongly suggests that kids can pick up on language if those adults are surrounded by additional context. For example, if adults in the same room were talking about a visible object in front of them then the research suggests that the child would be able to pick up the language even when not directly spoken to.

Why do you doubt the research?

win311fwg··on The compiler was supposed to end programming too
> With compilers there is a (roughly, barring optimizations) 1:1 correspondence between input and output.

Maybe if you are using a compiler to provider a portable assembler (i.e. C) where ~1:1 mapping is the whole point. But in that case you'd be actually be using assembler instead in a world where all CPUs were the same.

That is very narrow view, though. Often — and I'd say most often — people use compilers so they can think in higher levels of abstraction, like SQL. Taking SQL and adding millions or billions of additional keywords doesn't really change anything with respect to the concept. Its still the same thing at the end of the day, even of those millions/billions of additional keywords are much more powerful than a small set of keywords.

win311fwg··on What shall I teach my son?
Genie could't speak because she was deprived of exposure to normal human interaction, not because of lack of being taught. It is apparent you've never been around a child because otherwise you'd have quickly recnoized that most of them do speak before anyone tries to teach them how.
win311fwg··on Most advice is right for the person giving it
> Mark Cuban says the opposite

In what way are they opposing thoughts? Steve Jobs said keep putting in the effort until you find the thing that you love. Mark Cuban also said keep putting in the effort until you find the thing that you love. The exact word choice may have differed, but they both expressed the exact same thing.

win311fwg··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
It is true that they don't have the resources in their natural state, but it is extraction and use of those resources that causes the problem. Letting the resources remain in their natural state is the solution!

Here's the thing: Resources aren't extracted just for fun. It is only done so to serve the consumer, and those consumers are disproportionately young-to-middle-age adults. Not using resources is the only way to combat this. That is fully within their control.

win311fwg··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
The people of China vote.

You are right that they don't have a democracy because the people are unable to truly organize without the powers that be at the top putting an end to any movements, but the people in the remaining 2/3s of the world never bother to take time to organize either, so the democracy they do have is really only a belief, something theoretical, and they if they ever decided to exercise it in the future may find out that they weren't actually under democracy after all.

win311fwg··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
> Who knew the Amish were right all along?

When the Amish said that modern technology destroys the family they weren't envisioning a climate catastrophe being the thing that destroyed the family.

I recently travelled to the primary old-order region of my country, where I hadn't been in about a decade, and all the horses in the fields I remember have now been replaced by tractors. Let's be real: They don't fear climate change any more than the average Joe does, possibly less having less exposure to the science and messaging. All they have ever feared was families being broken apart by the kids leaving for the big city lights.

win311fwg··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
> and are the worst offenders regarding CO2 production

Unless you're doing those strange mental gymnastics of entities like oil companies are the emitters and not the consumers, that's not true. Old people who have gained large amounts of wealth have also lost large amounts of mobility and tend to not produce much co2 because they don't do much in life anymore, comparatively speaking. The data is clear that peak carbon emitters are in their 30s-40s, and they're still the ones most often seen crying about not being able to afford a home.

win311fwg··on What shall I teach my son?
> Yes but arithmetic is actually not intuitive at all, and you can certainly grow up to not know it.

If you are in a situation where you don't need it, sure, but if you don't need it then who cares? I get the nebulous "but what about the discoveries you are missing out on", but the type of people who wouldn't learn something like arithmetic for fun also never find discoveries anyway, and never would even if you could force feed them all the knowledge of the world. That argument really doesn't apply to most people.

> Children are still children, they very famously make poor decisions.

Not quite. What children are most famous for is that they won't learn until they want to. Poor decisions, implying that they could have made good decisions if only they would have listened, are the outcome of them not learning even when you tried.

> We have to mold and steer them

There are deadbeats in the world, sure, but for the most part that just naturally happens at least up until they hit the rebellious teen years. Kids want to be by your side, watching, learning. We wouldn't have made it as a species if this didn't occur automatically. Like I said before, you cannot exist without learning things constantly.

win311fwg··on What shall I teach my son?
> Most kids, left to their own devices, would not learn arithmetic.

Unlikely. Too many things in life depend on arithmetic. Most people will learn things when they must.

What is more likely is that kids won't learn arithmetic before they need it and therefore may theoretically miss out on the aforementioned discoveries that are overlooked when one doesn't already have a foundation in arithmetic. However, most people never have such discoveries anyway. Those who do tend to be the type that would learn something like arithmetic just for fun.

> I know few adults that were forced to learn something as kids that regret learning it.

As a once child, if I didn't want to learn something, I didn't. Forcing someone to sit in a classroom where a subject is being taught, for example, is not the same as actually learning the material. So this is an obvious truism. Those who didn't want to learn something never did.

win311fwg··on What shall I teach my son?
> You never know if learning calculus will make you discover new things that you might like to pursue.

Just as you will never know what you might have discovered if you used the time you spent learning calculus learning something else instead, of course. There is no magic formula to life.

> you shouldn't learn anything until you need it

Impossible. Simply existing as a functioning human means you are going to be constantly learning something. Not everything you learn will be useful, but that's also true of calculus. Not everyone finds it useful in the end either. You never know what will end up being useful, but you also can't learn everything.

The great thing about the curious mind is that you tend to be naturally drawn towards the things that are most useful for you. Those born most likely to do something with calculus already voluntarily choose to learn about it. You don't have to make them. The stereotypical druggy who has no interest in anything but getting high, who suddenly has his life turned around because you force him to learn calculus, is little more than Hollywood fantasy.

win311fwg··on Personal software factories are a waste of time
A play on 'factory farm', where developers are kept in deplorable conditions to produce code as efficiently as possible.
win311fwg··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
> I've seen specific examples given which do in fact serve a useful purpose when interrogated.

Interrogated to what extent? 'Bullshit jobs' was originally coined to mean jobs that do serve a useful purpose within the environment they exist in, but where zooming out reveals that the environment has no good reason to exist in the first place.

win311fwg··on Thank You, Deno
You make it sound as if implementation details matter. They don't.
win311fwg··on Meta’s new commercial terms will allow the scraping of news sites: experts
Not really. Consent has always been required. If a web server happily serves you up news content then you've been given clear consent to use it. Yes means yes. However, a site reserves the right to say no to whomever it pleases. News sites especially often don't happily serve up their content. Often you need to pay for access, for example. Hacking into their systems to retrieve content that wasn't normally happily given to you is clearly against the law. These terms gives Meta access to all content that is accessible to Meta users, seeing publishers agree to not say no to Meta.
← PreviousPage 4 of 20Next →