HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wissler

1,092 karma · joined March 13, 2012

"In [corporate] religions as in others, the heretic must be cast out not because of the probability that he is wrong but because of the possibility that he is right." - Edsger W. Dijkstra
submissionscomments
wissler··on Why You Can't Build a Smartphone
I was about to say the same thing -- glad to see I'm not the only one who recognizes the real reason why there will be no more competition in this space.
wissler··on Patent trolls have a surprising ally: universities
It comes down to whether you think it's moral that one person filing paperwork with a bureaucrat grants him the right to haul other people who independently think the same thing he did into court, trying to take their property. Patents are tantamount to the creation of thought crimes, on a vast scale.

Furthermore, if you aren't against patents in general, there is no principled argument that can be made against software patents in particular. Software is just as inventive as other realms.

wissler··on Patent trolls have a surprising ally: universities
Patents are morally reprehensible in principle, the result in practice is therefore inevitable. There is no middle road or way around this: patents must be abolished.
wissler··on The Vaccination Effect: 100 Million Cases of Contagious Disease Prevented
Evidently you're not familiar with moral philosophy, but there is a difference between taking an action that you know will kill random people vs. not taking the action and leaving things to accident.

Also, there is a problem with the hypothetical, since there are other means of reducing disease than vaccination, e.g. aggressive quarantine and disinfection, trending toward telecommuting or smaller school classroom size, etc.

wissler··on The Vaccination Effect: 100 Million Cases of Contagious Disease Prevented
"if vaccines killed one person for every ten saved it would still be worthwhile"

Why?

wissler··on "Patent Trolls" Threaten to Drain Silicon Valley Startups [video]
Of course it is completely ideologically bankrupt, but so is virtually everything else about our political and cultural institutions. Not a whole lot has changed on this front since Galileo was thrown into prison, at least not in terms of ideological fundamentals.
wissler··on "Patent Trolls" Threaten to Drain Silicon Valley Startups [video]
Fallout from the recently enacted and ironically titled "America Invents Act":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_to_file_and_first_to_inve...

wissler··on FDA Orders Genetic Testing Firm 23andMe to Halt Sales
It's clearly not as simple as that, since there is such a thing as tyranny and perversion of justice. Now, you may be the kind of person who would approve of what his government does, whatever it does, and you may even be in the majority, but that doesn't make you right. I also imagine that, like most people with such views, you have cognitive dissonance. I.e., there are some governments that you think should change their behavior, on moral grounds.
wissler··on FDA Orders Genetic Testing Firm 23andMe to Halt Sales
People should be able to knowingly enter into whatever contract they want.

Glad you agree.

Should a company should be able to...

Contract theory is far more rich a subject than you realize. In your example, a rational theory of contract wouldn't be enforced based on mere promise, but would allow contracts to be broken so long as it puts both parties more or less back to where they were before. E.g., if you promise to paint my home for $100, but then you don't paint my home, I can't then enslave you and force you to paint the home, rather, I get my $100 back.

This is of course an approximate explanation.

wissler··on FDA Orders Genetic Testing Firm 23andMe to Halt Sales
Considering the fact that we know 99.9% of people blindly click through agreements, this is the way it should be.

This is just a bald-faced non-sequitur.

wissler··on FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe
Of course it's punishment. You have to pay an extraordinary amount of time and money under threat of violence. And even when you do comply, from then on you have to start judging whether or not the next feature you add is worth the cost of compliance.

This is going to stifle innovation.

wissler··on FDA Orders Genetic Testing Firm 23andMe to Halt Sales
In our era, it doesn't matter if two consenting parties agree, what matters is whether the judge or regulatory agency approves of the agreement.
wissler··on FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe
No, you stop advocating that the rights of innocents are violated for the sake of cases where there is evidence of fraud. Instead, advocate that cases of fraud are actually followed up on. Be an upstanding citizen, not part of the ignorant mob.
wissler··on My deadly disease was just a 23andme bug
It is good to know of real-world misdiagnoses made via 23andMe.

Now, can we see some real-world statistics by the government-licensed medical profession? I wonder what a side-by-side analysis of the errors 23andMe has made vs. those the medical community has made might look like. I wonder how the real-life consequences might stack up.

As far as I know, 23andMe has never accidentally amputated the wrong limb, so it's at least go that going for it.

Interesting tidbit: you can always double-check the reports 23andMe gives to you by getting followup tests someplace else.

wissler··on FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe
It's just a trivial statement of cause and effect. If the causes in operation are in operation, then ceteris paribus the effect will occur.
wissler··on FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe
Actually, the "aka" is: "I fully realize that most people have been indoctrinated to ignore the obvious, but here's the obvious."
wissler··on FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe
Make no mistake -- after having stomped on this "not little guy", any new little guy that comes along is definitely going to get stomped on. Which of course means that no new little guys are going to come along. This is the process whereby established players obtain a monopoly. In other words, what doesn't kill 23andMe will make it stronger.
wissler··on FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe
Fact check: libertarians think fraud is a rights violation, a crime that is properly punished.

On the other hand, governance by the FDA is tantamount to punishing for a crime not committed. It'd be like putting cameras in your home because you might abuse your children someday. And surely, a lot of stupid people abuse their children, right?

wissler··on FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe
As if the FDA were qualified to make such determinations.
wissler··on The shared genius of Elon Musk and Steve Jobs
http://www.quora.com/Elon-Musk/Is-Elon-Musk-the-next-Steve-J...
wissler··on How to design a class
The problem with this isn't OO, it's a misuse of OO, which isn't supposed to be about metaphors but programming by difference.
wissler··on The Narcissism of Small Code Differences (2008)
I think there's a straw man here.

I don't think any sensible person from any paradigm would have objected to the code as it was originally written. The substantive arguments between paradigms happen at larger scales of code organization.

So it comes across to me that the "agnostic" is trying to make other schools of thought look ridiculous. The trouble is he's done it by cheating.

wissler··on About the Bitcoin ‘bubble’
What will Bitcoin clones do to the value of Bitcoin? In principle you could have an unlimited number of them, it's not as if Bitcoin is the only possible instantiation of a cryptocurrency.
wissler··on The Quality of Embedded Software, or the Mess Has Happened
Regarding the EE bashing, there's an element of truth but overall it is an unfair characterization.

I think the true source of the problem lies not in the EE degree or lack of a CS degree, but in a specific, weird distrust of abstraction by in the institutional culture of embedded systems development. This opposition (and it is opposition, not merely ignorance) isn't coming from the degree per se but from the field as it is sometimes practiced.

My guess is that the reason for this culture is that long ago, there was a history of "fancy newfangled compilers" screwing up the code, engineers getting repeatedly burned, and learning not to trust such "fancy" tools. This attitude may have made some sense a long time ago, but now it's an institutional relic.

So the irony is: the engineers are avoiding abstraction in order to increase reliability, but they wind up decreasing it because the code becomes impossible to manage.

Anyway, this is not a defect in the way EE's are educated, it is a very specific subculture of embedded systems development, which traditionally happens to tend to hire EE's.

wissler··on The Quality of Embedded Software, or the Mess Has Happened
Is there a reason why something so fundamental as throttle control/braking ought to be governed by a computer, instead of by foolproof old-fashioned hardware?
wissler··on After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal probes and colonoscopy
The fact that we regard it as "civilized" discourse to treat people with respect regardless of how barbaric their remarks are is one of the problems with our present state of civilization.
wissler··on After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal probes and colonoscopy
People like you are why things just keep getting worse.
wissler··on After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal probes and colonoscopy
If most people don't have trouble believing it -- then that's not the real problem.
wissler··on After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal probes and colonoscopy
It is not just about these cops, these doctors, or this judge. It is about institutional rot, a rot so wide and deep that to point it out will get you scorn and ridicule in most quarters.
wissler··on Nexus 5 Teardown
That is a presumptuous attitude, completely wrongheaded.

I have a ton of music and that's what I put on the microSD. If I lose it, no big deal, but it's really nice to be able to have all my music there.

← PreviousPage 2 of 18Next →