1,092 karma · joined March 13, 2012
You're part of the problem of course. You and everyone like you. By rejecting philosophy you reject ethics and therefore any possible means of addressing these systematic problems.
Screw that.
The problem isn't with government per se, it's with the typical intellectual.
http://lessig.tumblr.com/post/40347463044/prosecutor-as-bull...
The gun isn't metaphorical, it's very real.
If the property legitimately belonged to you, then I'd have no problem with "my house, my rules, love them or leave them", but nothing but ownership gives you that kind of prerogative. You are making a pure might makes right argument, it's completely amoral. (Incidentally, do some research about what this megalomanical kind of "ownership" leads to, e.g. "Trail of Tears.")
Your reasoning is that of a child, not mine.
Might doesn't make right. This land is not all your land. You may have total and utter domination of it, but that's not a moral argument.
There's no concise way to answer why your underlying political philosophy is wrong, unfortunately. One thing that should be a clue though is that the majority agrees with you. That's always a bad sign.
As it happens I did write a book on this topic, I don't know what the etiquette is here for posting links, just search "for individual rights" in books, you'll see it. If I could provide a more concise argument, I would, but that's the best I can do, sorry.
Your world is one where you point a gun to my head (using the government of course) and tell me what kind of medical care I can trade with some guy you don't even know. So don't talk to me about "barbarian animals", OK? Your only means of doing what you think is "ideal" is to resort to cowardly force -- cowardly because you just pull the voting lever and somebody else does your dirty work.
Don't wonder why "resources are scarce" when your reply to someone who creates an unapproved alternative is to beat them up with the government.
Unfortunately, we are so far down the path of doing things the wrong way that stating the proper solution only leads to misunderstanding. Think of a complex software system that has hack piled upon hack, and where the only programmers left are those who've been the ones piling on the hacks. These are not the people who can understand that what they've been doing is wrong.
Our system is the final consequence of people who, among other things, want safety guaranteed by the government. Unfortunately, there are no guarantees in life, so they are chasing a fantasy, and fantasies can become hideously expensive, as this one has. It is tragic that they do not comprehend what they are doing to themselves, but it is even more tragic that what they are doing isn't only to themselves, but to those of us who understand as well.
I've read that Valve Software would like to fund games on this model but as of now they can't legally do it.
I guess I should thank all you naysayers for the compliment.
And anyway, the point wouldn't be to support all platforms, just the prevailing ones, so I'd say your remarks miss the mark.
If, over the long term, it's costing you 40% to keep the popular versions of Linux working, then you're doing something wrong. Could it hypothetically cost that much? Sure, but only if you're incompetent.