HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wnmurphy

455 karma · joined November 20, 2015

submissionscomments
wnmurphy··on Tesla Roadster
> I am not fan of Musk, but one has to have some crazy blinders on not to give him credit here.

Tesla does have ~700k other employees.

wnmurphy··on Tesla Roadster
I'm glad someone else gets it.
wnmurphy··on Tesla Roadster
This would be a horrible deal for Tesla investors.

Long-term investors would lose about 40% of their investment to subsidize the inflated valuation of X (bought by xAI), the inflated valuation of xAI (bought by SpaceX), and SpaceX (whose valuation is based on the assumption that demand for inference is effectively unlimited, and that everyone will prefer hardware in space over Earth).

The valuation of both companies was inflated prior to acquisition, and Tesla shareholders will be asked to dilute their investment by absorbing that cumulative inflation.

Not even to mention that Musk would have exclusive control over the entire conglomerate, with not even the pretense of a Board to check his power.

When even Steven Mark Ryan is like "let's pump the breaks a little bit," you know it's bad.

wnmurphy··on OpenCode 2.0
Good lord, me either. I thought it was a gag reading through these comments, but there was no way all of these people commenting were that locked into a joke.
wnmurphy··on Secret of Orange Cats Revealed After 60-Year Search
That was the final straw for me as well. Forcing you to log in to see old.reddit.com + forcing you into the app when viewing on mobile + the general toxicity just made it no longer worth it to use Reddit.
wnmurphy··on Feds got warrants to use fake cell towers to hunt down Don Lemon's producer
This administration has an impressive record of lying in order to manufacture charges against critics.

They also consistently lose in court once these charges are subjected to scrutiny. The point seems to be to merely manufacture bad headlines to smear the targets.

Prior to this administration, the feds had a 93% conviction rate. With so many frivolous cases falling apart in court, I'd be curious to know where that percentage is now.

wnmurphy··on America.gov
True to form for this administration, they just ripped off Apple's style guide for https://america.gov/privacy.
wnmurphy··on AI needs $6T in annual revenue to justify data centre boom
Yes, and it's $30T when you include all knowledge worker roles.
wnmurphy··on AI needs $6T in annual revenue to justify data centre boom
Bingo. When that 1000% increase in spending on tokens represents a cost savings of 80% on knowledge worker labor, companies will happily pay it.

The other factor that threatens the $6T required to justify... open source models crushing the pricing power of these companies. If I can use some open source agent management framework + self-hosted Qwen to basically replace my entire Product org for free, then why would I pay Microsoft/Google/Anthropic/OpenAI?

wnmurphy··on AI needs $6T in annual revenue to justify data centre boom
I think what's lost on the general public who mainly thinks AI is ChatGPT, is that these companies are gunning for knowledge worker salaries. That by itself is ~$30T/year globally. Nothing else justifies the infra spend. Data center investment is a bet that they will be able to virtualize knowledge workers in the next 5 years.

Warehouse and factory labor is the next largest market for AI/robotics, at about $7T/year globally.

The bubble question is really about the target year. Will these companies start on a trajectory where AI begins eating these massive markets before investors lose faith?

To me it looks like one of these is true:

(1) this is indeed a bubble, and AI will turn into a useful tool integrated into everything but fall short of expectations. We'll see some significant multiple compression in the share prices of these core AI companies, but they'll remain good investments in the long term.

(2) this is a real transformation, the investment was worth it, and these companies will earn massive revenue while causing Depression-era levels of unemployment (24% if half of knowledge workers and factory/warehouse workers can get jobs).

Basically, the revenue required to justify the infra spend requires that they start eating existing industries, because that's certainly not going to come from ChatGPT/Claude subscriptions.

wnmurphy··on Ask HN: Why were OpenAI, Claude, and Grok simultaneously down?
xAI mentioned a Memphis outage, which is where Anthropic was leasing capacity on Colossus 1. I do think this is the explanation.
wnmurphy··on Ask HN: Why were OpenAI, Claude, and Grok simultaneously down?
Actually, nevermind... this looks more like Anthropic and xAI coincided due to shared xAI infra (6:23am and 6:30am), and OpenAI's issue was more likely then a coincidence (7:43am).
wnmurphy··on Ask HN: Why were OpenAI, Claude, and Grok simultaneously down?
Curious then as to why the incident coincided with similar issues with Anthropic and xAI.
wnmurphy··on Corporate America is getting hooked on open-source AI
Yeah, I'm looking forward to this actually.

https://chatjimmy.ai/ blew my mind at how fast etched model weights can be.

For on-device LLMs, there's a point of diminishing returns, meaning you don't need to have the latest frontier model for most operations.

wnmurphy··on Playa Phone
I just want to say thank you. The playa phone is a fixture.

I think in 2008 I walked by it and said "oh, that's a funny art installation." Then the phone rang, and I said "wait, what? is that a working pay phone?"

I picked it up and someone asked me if I was satisfied with my home insurance.

wnmurphy··on Playa Phone
Every sort of experience is possible.

You could spend the entire week high as a kite, biking around and just looking at everything without talking to anyone, though the vast majority of the community are people you probably would enjoy interacting with. I find most burners thoughtful, compassionate, playful, caring, etc.

What I suspect would happen is you'd start out this way ^, but then you'd gradually discover that the community is great and interactions with people are pretty fun actually. Part of the experience is the opportunity to get outside of your normal baseline personality if you want. You can be anyone for a week. Most people don't even want to talk about their lives off the playa.

Culture changes on the weekend, when you get a lot of "partiers" just for the man and temple burn. There are a bit more irresponsible and inconsiderate people then, but not enough to ruin the overall community vibe.

wnmurphy··on Coding expertise is going to collapse from AI reliance
Complement: I know many devs who are exceptional at 1 (writing code), and 2 (contextual thinking) never even occurs to them. They will happily implement whatever they are told, without ever thinking to ask "why am I being asked to implement this?" or "is this actually solving the problem?"
wnmurphy··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
If you are a US citizen, they are not entitled to your unlocked phone. They need a judicial warrant if they want you to unlock your phone with a PIN/password. It is settled case law that that falls under your protections under the 14th Amendment.

They can take it for a "reasonable amount of time" (inconvenience you for a few hours and make you miss your connecting flight) while they copy an encrypted image. They then must return it to you.

wnmurphy··on US announces new sanctions on top ICC figures
It’s a preemptive attack to prevent accountability for Trump and Hegseth under the next presidency. All of those extrajudicial boat attacks that have been justified by claiming they were smuggling drugs (cocaine imports to the US haven’t dropped at all, BTW) are likely unjustified murders.

This administration attacks any body or authority that has the power to hold them accountable. See: attacks on the judiciary, attacks on the media, attacks on academia, etc.

wnmurphy··on Gloomberb
Seriously. I see a cool product that someone built and is sharing with the community, and the top comment is basically a criticism that it's not a $31k terminal.
wnmurphy··on Bioengineered chewing gum may offer a way to fight HPV and other microbes
In case this is useful for anyone, this study on high-risk HPV and medicinal mushrooms blew my mind:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25271984/

In 88% (36 out of 41) of patients with high-risk HPV, taking reishi + turkey tail mushrooms daily for 2 months cleared the virus, versus 5% clearance (1 out of 20) in the control group. I suspect that 88% clearance rate would be higher if they continued for longer than 2 months.

wnmurphy··on Position: LLMs Can't Jump
Humor requires a sudden orthogonal leap from context. That's what a punchline is.

I think you're saying that you can eventually train models to arrive at that destination by training on existing jokes, effectively encoding these leaps as probabilities.

In that case, the model isn't actually making an intuitive/comedic leap; they're just following new probability chains in attempting to approximate examples they've seen in training.

I'm suggesting that something architecturally different is necessary to create a model which can make intuitive/comedic leaps.

Try to get a frontier model to write a clever, funny joke which hasn't been seen before. Or, try to get it to make an intuitive leap that leads to a novel discovery.

You can use them to guide your own efforts along these lines, as a sounding board. But with current architecture I just don't think either is possible for an LLM to do on its own.

wnmurphy··on Position: LLMs Can't Jump
I had a related insight, but in the domain of humor [1].

LLMs are inherently probabilistic, and there's currently no mechanism for producing an orthogonal directional change in the path traced through a latent space which is also contextually relevant (landing on a punch line).

In other words, LLMs are fundamentally incapable of making intuitive/orthogonal leaps in context.

It might be possible to add this capability with a new architectural component like transformers, but specifically for making "left turns"/intuitive leaps.

[1] https://wnmurphy.com/llms-cant-do-humor/

wnmurphy··on Prevent cognitive debt by manually retyping LLM-generated code
There's value to hand-copying something. Hunter S. Thompson transcribed Hemingway to internalize the cadence of his writing.

However, if you're serious about it, then why not hand-write your LLM-generated code? You'll get much better retention and comprehension than typing.

wnmurphy··on Taylor Farms has rewritten its cyclospora statement four times in sixteen days
Where do you suppose the taco trucks procure their lettuce?
wnmurphy··on Commodification of Intelligence: Good, Bad, and Ugly Circular AI Deals
Intelligence doesn't require sentience.

Think of it like this: if you can offload a task to an AI model that requires reasoning or representing a nonlinear system, you are offloading intelligence.

wnmurphy··on “We have information that Moonshot distilled Fable for the development of K3”
It's funny to me that these models were created by effectively "distilling" all available content including the proprietary works of many other people, but now it's a problem that someone is doing the same to them.

You're using available information (copyrighted works, or the output of another model) to train a model to encode the information in a new form. Why is the former not theft, but the latter is theft?

wnmurphy··on Stealing Is a Skill
I think the author's choice of words is framing the discussion. They did build their own website, but they loved the look of the one they saw, so I'd think a better choice would be "inspired by" rather than "stolen from."
wnmurphy··on Stealing Is a Skill
This was my first thought as well. Hunter S. Thompson used to copy Hemingway by hand to internalize his cadence.
wnmurphy··on Tesla allegedly in autopilot mode crashes into Texas house, woman killed
The telemetry will tell the story, not the clickbait news headline based on preliminary information. I seriously doubt FSD would drive into a house.
Page 1 of 5Next →