HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

woah

11,504 karma · joined July 6, 2012

submissionscomments
woah··on Solarpunk
It's a cool aesthetic, but as a practical movement has some issues with reality. You get stuff like the solar powered website that runs out of batteries when enough people visit it. Cool statement but it would probably have been more environmentally friendly by any measure to deploy on a tiny virtual instance living ephemerally on cloud hosting. Bumping AWS's power consumption up by a tiny fraction vs having a bunch of components shipped to your house.
woah··on Making o1, o3, and Sonnet 3.7 hallucinate for everyone
With LLMs, I hope we move towards libraries that make code easier to read, not easier to write.
woah··on A Letter to the American People
I would love to only receive one delivery of junk mail per week
woah··on GPT-4.5
Perhaps you could use LLMs in a list ranking context to generate your scifi recommendations https://github.com/noperator/raink?tab=readme-ov-file
woah··on Claude 3.7 Sonnet and Claude Code
Seems like that must make it impossible for the Cursor devs to use their own product given that Claude is the default there
woah··on Train Your Own O1 Preview Model Within $450
Each time someone clicks "send" on chatGPT, Warner Bros gets 1c

$25 to Elsevier per GPU purchase

woah··on OpenEuroLLM
Depends on the goals. If they were fine-tuning leading foundation models, then I could see this being an entirely sensible undertaking. But since their goal seems to be to make foundation models, I don't think that they will end up being the leading models with so many other conflicting requirements.
woah··on A cryptocurrency scam that turned a small town against itself
My mistake. I had assumed that the first exchange was also a fake website put together by the scammers with no crypto behind it.
woah··on OpenEuroLLM
The three goals featured prominently above the fold are:

> truly open > including data, documentation, training and testing code, and evaluation metrics; including community involvement

> compliant > under EU regulations, OpenEuroLLM will provide a series of transparent and performant LLMs

> diverse > for European languages and other socially and economically interesting ones, preserving linguistic and cultural diversity

The first one seems good, but the second two seem to be pretty beside the point of creating models that compete with the cutting edge of China and the USA.

woah··on A cryptocurrency scam that turned a small town against itself
This didn't have anything to do with cryptocurrency at all. It sounds like the "victim" never even touched an actual blockchain. He was induced to send money to to a scammer, using the traditional banking system.
woah··on Scented products cause indoor air pollution on par with car exhaust
get some air filters
woah··on Apple Debuts iPhone 16e
I know you're trying to make a point or something, but Apple or an independent service center will do just that for not much more than the price of the battery.
woah··on "Ensuring Accountability for All Agencies" – Executive Order
> And most of what you described only exists in a Fox News fever dream

It also exists in the 2024 election results

woah··on Can I ethically use LLMs?
> Consider architecture (bland), clothing (low durability), food (fast food, frozen food, worse nutrition, bland taste) etc etc. Sure, people happily buy all this stuff, it works. But I can't help but feel our stuff is a lot worse than it used to be. I bet I'm not alone.

For every intricate handcrafted cathedral or mansion, there were millions of one room huts with leaky roofs. A change of clothes used to be an investment along the lines of what an expensive phone or even a car is for us today, so most people only had one or two changes of clothes, and not in very good condition. Food used to take up most of a person's wages and a bad harvest could cause immediate starvation for large numbers of people. Also, most people a diet consisting almost entirely of grains.

So, yea, if you are imagining some kind of past where you happened to be an aristocrat, you could live in a beautifully handcrafted house, wear only hand-tailored clothes, and eat heirloom vegetables for every meal. But if you're imagining yourself as an aristocrat, then you can live pretty well with that status in the modern era too.

woah··on "Ensuring Accountability for All Agencies" – Executive Order
No. Since 2016, leftist democrats have promised that if only the democratic party moves far left enough, they will unlock some kind of secret progressive majority. This has been repudiated at every turn, most resoundingly in the last presidential election. The demographics that the leftist democrats had appointed themselves the saviors of went over to Trump, along with the tech industry which had formerly been a huge source of monetary and intellectual capital for the democrats.

Unfortunately, the democratic party seems to be unable to make the necessary adjustment and return to the winning formula of the Obama years because the political hobbyists and professionals that make up the core of the party have purity-tested out anyone with more mainstream views. If they aren't careful, they will end up as a party representing only university HR administrators.

woah··on Magnetic field sorting of superconducting graphite particles with Tc>400K (2024)
There are a lot of skeptical comments here, but the authors make this claim in the abstract:

> We have obtained a concentrate of above room temperature superconducting particles.

Is this just a lie?

woah··on Firing programmers for AI is a mistake
The OS code that exists is much higher quality so the signal to noise ratio is much better
woah··on Firing programmers for AI will destroy everything
Huge numbers of accountants and lawyers use excel heavily knowing only the built in formula language. They will have a few "gurus" sprinkled around who can write macros but this is used sparingly because the macros are a black box and make it harder to audit the financial models.
woah··on Teen on Musk's DOGE team graduated from 'The Com'
Data access controls couldn't have been followed in this case, given the short timelines, right?
woah··on Ingesting PDFs and why Gemini 2.0 changes everything
> Most AI research has been conducted as if the computation available to the agent were constant (in which case leveraging human knowledge would be one of the only ways to improve performance) but, over a slightly longer time than a typical research project, massively more computation inevitably becomes available. Seeking an improvement that makes a difference in the shorter term, researchers seek to leverage their human knowledge of the domain, but the only thing that matters in the long run is the leveraging of computation. These two need not run counter to each other, but in practice they tend to. Time spent on one is time not spent on the other. There are psychological commitments to investment in one approach or the other. And the human-knowledge approach tends to complicate methods in ways that make them less suited to taking advantage of general methods leveraging computation.
woah··on Ingesting PDFs and why Gemini 2.0 changes everything
Getting "bitter lesson" vibes from this post
woah··on DoppelBot: Replace Your CEO with an LLM
There isn't any value judgement here. There are not more cooperatives because they don't prioritize growth. Who are you angry at?
woah··on DoppelBot: Replace Your CEO with an LLM
There is no secret conspiracy stopping cooperatives from working. They simply do not supply a large portion of the products and services that people want, due to the fact that they are by definition not set up to do so.

Who are you angry at? You are yelling into the wind.

woah··on DoppelBot: Replace Your CEO with an LLM
If I didn't like my working conditions, I would look for a different job.
woah··on DoppelBot: Replace Your CEO with an LLM
> The purpose of the company isn't to dominate the markets and become the biggest company ever, it's to make a better life for the people working for and patronizing the company, instead of just the people who own it.

That's perfectly fine, and also the reason why cooperatives are a pretty niche thing: they don't prioritize growth.

woah··on DoppelBot: Replace Your CEO with an LLM
If far superior AI CEOs existed then only one board would need to replace their CEO with AI. The company would then dominate the marketplace because of the far superior decisions being made, and the rest would be forced to follow.

If AI CEOs were slightly inferior to human CEOs, but cost $1 per year, it still wouldn't be worth replacing an expensive human CEO, unless that CEO's compensation was worth more than a few percent of revenue (it never is).

I wouldn't want to invest my money in a company which was making worse decisions to try to save money on the CEO, when the money paid to the CEO is going to have very little effect on my return on investment. That sounds like a good way to for my investment to underperform. The only winner in that scenario is online forum posters who want to feel jealous of the abstract concept of a "CEO".

woah··on DoppelBot: Replace Your CEO with an LLM
This is called a cooperative, and it is completely legal. However, they tend not to be very successful in the marketplace, outside of a few outliers.

If you separate revenue and control (employees get to vote on decisions, but investors get the revenue), then employees will be incentivized to maintain the status quo instead making decisions to make the company successful. The employees have almost no incentive to make difficult decisions like cutting unsuccessful lines of business etc. I would be very uneasy about investing anyone's retirement savings into such an organization.

If you keep revenue and control combined (a simple share structure, where each share gets a piece of the revenue and a vote, and employees get shares when they join), then you have other paradoxes. To make this work, you need to prohibit employees from selling their shares to investors, otherwise you're back to a conventional corporation. You also need to take the shares away from employees when they leave the company, otherwise former employees become a de facto investor class that you wanted to avoid. As an employee, I would prefer to work at a company where my equity does not have these restrictions placed on it.

You may say "but if we all just tried a little harder to believe in a better world it could be possible". But it is possible now. Cooperatives work easily under existing corporate law, and are even incentivized in some places. They just aren't very successful for the reasons above. The only widespread form of cooperative is doctor's and lawyer's practices, which are legally required to be organized as cooperatives through a limited liability partnership structure.

To make cooperatives work in the broader marketplace, you'd have to force employees to accept restrictions on their equity or force savers to put their money into cooperatives managed by employees who are not incentivized to invest it well.

woah··on Launch HN: Karsa (YC W25) – Buy and save stablecoins internationally
Did you even read the post? They are buying dollars
woah··on Cali's AG Tells AI Companies Almost Everything They're Doing Might Be Illegal
Imagine if the US (public and private sector), transferred 2% of GDP to Warner Bros
woah··on Goodbye, Slopify
I'm so confused by these complaints. I use Spotify every day, and just type in the music I want to listen to. You click on a song and it plays. How are people getting all wrapped up in whether some podcast shows up on some screen, or whether there's AI generated music on there, or if the Electron app is properly optimized?
← PreviousPage 13 of 34Next →