473 karma · joined July 12, 2010
There will always be bad apples in the bunch. When I was in Europe there were some cameras set up to monitor an entrance. They hired local nationals to monitor these cameras. Just so happens, there were residences near the entrance; and the 100x zoom didn't help. The people in charge of monitoring the cameras were caught gawking at women undressing and houses had to be black-bared.
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
Under different circumstances your solution would be 100% correct, however, in this situation we are worried about "everyday" type criminals. These are the guys/girls that find a laptop in an unlocked locker and snatch it; small window of opportunity. In your analogy the description of the criminals is much more sophisticated; Oceans 11 types.
Stealing RAM can potentially tip someone off to a threat, a better solution IMO is the Stone-Cold Bootkit[1]. The bootkit can hook into Windows in order to gain unrestricted access. It does this by writing to the MBR unrestricted; haven't we seen this before[2]? Once installed it will log your decryption password and do what ever with it.
A BIOS password(windows) and HHD encryption will be enough to keep the NSA out for a while, and a normal criminal out indefinitely.
It would be nice to have a mobo with some type of secure memory encryption programs could write to- digitally signed. Of course that could be owned too, but it's a start. In the words of Bruce Schneier, "[sic] it is very difficult to secure data when the attacker has physical control of the machine the data is stored on."[3]
Now I am thinking about the /boot partition in linux; where GRUB is stored.
[1] http://www.stoned-vienna.com/
[2] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1643451
[3] http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/02/cold_boot_atta...
[4] PSA: http://zedomax.com/blog/2009/02/23/linux-boot-hack-how-to-pa...
"black box" reverse engineering - systems are observed without examining internal structure.
"white box" reverse engineering - the inner workings of the system are inspected.
This whole post got me thinking about ways to sniff out proxies. I am usually behind on this kind of thing, but bare with me please :).
Using PHP and Javascript I think you could weed out the majority of proxy users; avoid IP spoofing, protect sensitive places a little better. Use php to get the users IP address. Find location of that IP. Find timezone/time of that ip. Have a range set up to catch errors. Now use JavaScript to get the time.
Javascript will return the time specific to the system. If the two times do not match up then you possibly have someone using a proxy.
There are some issues with this type of system, traveling business man, but it could be useful at some point.
One of the many great quotes:
Diana Christensen: I watched your 6 o'clock news today; it's straight tabloid. You had a minute and a half of that lady riding a bike naked in Central Park; on the other hand, you had less than a minute of hard national and international news. It was all sex, scandal, brutal crime, sports, children with incurable diseases, and lost puppies. So, I don't think I'll listen to any protestations of high standards of journalism when you're right down on the streets soliciting audiences like the rest of us. Look, all I'm saying is if you're going to hustle, at least do it right.
Do not under estimate the zerg. Although ssh servers on different ports are "harder" to find, they are still not invisible. Try changing your banner, using 'port knocking', TCIP fingerprint spoofing, and other obfuscation techniques. Nothing is 100%, but you can still have really secure boxes. Proper admins are your best line of defense.
Did your opinions change after hearing other people's woes, or did it help to reaffirm them?
It does not seem reasonable because you have cited no statics or data. It would seem reasonable to assume, that on average, ants are all red. You can't just say something and it become true.
I guess this is one of the reasons I was never allowed to cite wikipedia.
http://www.stoned-bootkit.info/
http://www.h-online.com/security/news/item/Bootkit-bypasses-...
http://www.anti-forensics.com/modify-truecrypt-encryption-bo...
This still does not make it right for GRUB et al. to call claim to that area of the hard disk. If anyone can write to it, for what ever their needs may be, then forethought should have said, "hey, this can potentially screw some stuff up. We should find a BETTER way". I use GRUB as my primary bootloader and I still cannot get on their side in this debate.
Now is Microsoft going to steal your code? I dunno, probably not, but it is something to think about.
I really like that they take a pro active approach to issues. It was one of the main reasons I switched.
Spammy blogs are the other big problem, but there's no easy band-aid for that one.
A lot of "spammy blogs" are owned and operated by the same people. The whois data is usually enough to tip you off. I do not see why some spiders do not do a whois query and black list the owner/company; at least for a set period of time, and allow appeals.
I do not mean to make you think that I believe that monogamy is "the only way", however, psychology plays a huge role in our sexual and social relationships. Many women prefer a more intimate one-on-one relationship, while men do not; or so it has been said.
In evolutionary terms, a woman would want to give the man the impression that she'd never mate with another if he was gone or away. Whether that's true is a different question.
I do not believe that all women want to cheat on their spouse. More data from a wider set is needed, and even then it is a matter of biology and social context; random chance.
But don't assume that a society that overtly pushes monogamy will actually wind-up with husbands always fathering their official children.
I did mean to imply that I did. It really depends on the social context and size of the group. A smaller group will be more apt to provide more intimate care than a larger group. It was not my intention to put the blame on the male gender by any means. Women and men have an equal role to play in the physical and mental rearing of any child.
In the third link there is a rather interesting theory as to how it all started(hint: women made us do it).
When we imagine this apocalyptic doom of population, and mankind, we imagine a perfect world in some much that we think everyone will breed with everyone. Some men my have a problem(ED), some women may not be able to bare children(thus the creation of fertility gods), and some-be it male or female- may not want to "do it" period(homosexuality). We may also still hold old world values/moral beliefs, such as monogamy, dear.
The quote posted by Obiterdictum[1] from Orwell, one of my favorite writers, is very intriguing to me. The part that stands out the most is:
''But this is a fallacy based on the notion that human beings can be bred like animals.'' -One the topic of utilitarianistic gender values
Animals in captivity are usually force breed to maintain a linage or specific trait. Animals can build emotional bonds, however, in the wild we see very few mammal species that follow the same guidelines we find social acceptable[2]. For us to believe that every male will mate with every female we must also believe that every female will mate with every male, and vica versa.
Part of monogamy is breed into our subconscious, part is based on proximity, part is due to social context, and part is, well, emotional[3]. There are countless stories of widows never marring after their husbands are gone[see Penelope in The Odyssey]. We, many of us, enjoy monogamous relationships. Something about them brings us a joy that is very hard to put a value on. We can be tricked into them, stockholm syndrome, we can even be forced into them, rape, but we can rarely artificially create them, Truman show.
We must also asses the value of monogamous relation ships versus open relation ships(I am sorry I do not know the proper word for it); thinking that everyone will value them the same. I do not have enough data to pass judgment, although, the animal kingdom does seem to be doing well for itself ;).
Then we have to break down the proper breeding matrices. No one has said anything about age distribution in population. So are we assuming all the males/females too young/old to breed died OR are we not including them in the first count? To inspire discussion I will say we never included them in the first count...but then the situation doesn't really work as we have a new generation coming of age at some point; a boost if you will. Hypothetically, using the example given with a population size 150(aftermath) we are left with 100 women and 50 men. Breeding can be done in at least 1 day; a week at the utmost. Now those women are taken pretty much out of commission at the ~7,8,9 month. That leaves 100 women more vulnerable to starvation, illness, miscarriage, death giving birth. We also do not have the number of still births. What is the status of food? How did this population destruction occur? Too many variables.
For every perfect scenario there exists an imperfect one just as likely to occur as the latter. No person, be it male or female, is more valuable because they were born with a functioning set of genitalia. Value is always in the eye of the beholder[see currency, trade, marketing].
[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1635248
[2]http://www.trinity.edu/rnadeau/fys/barash%20on%20monogamy.ht...
[3] http://www.csulb.edu/~kmacd/346monogamyAnimals.html
[4]http://www.mythweb.com/odyssey/book01.html#notes5back
I had to edit and remove some of my comment as it became more of a rant than an acceptable comment. The tl;dr version is, we are all different and thus behave differently. Some may be more willing to breed for the sake of it while others not so much, however, we can all be conditioned so that we are prepared for such a situation. I am not condoning this. I feel that place male and female on a scale is boarding the lines of eugenics- to which I am more opposed than I am for. Some men are strong, while others are weak. Some women are stronger than a weak man. Some men are cowards, others are not. Some women are brave, others are not. Measuring strength is easy, measuring other- not so physical traits- is harder.