HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wutbrodo

8,628 karma · joined March 27, 2012

submissionscomments
wutbrodo··on Caring for the only known full kākāpō feather cloak in the world
Seriously, the argument is ludicrous. I'm open to the idea that stability is important, but Britain isn't even the best candidate for that. Brits who make this argument don't seem to be very aware of their own history, as they was bombed quite badly in the 40s, causing damage https://www.liverpoolmuseums.org.uk/collections/world-museum...

Even if you accept this premise, there are a good handful of other countries relatively untouched by war/instability that would be safer homes. The argument is a thin fig leaf.

wutbrodo··on Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
The coronation has not happened, but the proclamation has: https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-62873235

Symon Hill was arrested for protesting at the regional proclamation in Oxford: https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/21275817.photo-gallery-pro...

Where did you get the impression that this was a funeral procession?

wutbrodo··on Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
> Yes to American ears it might sound weird - that there is a topic that cannot even be joked about or you risk getting arrested. I don't really have a reply for that, other than the fact that it feels right to me

Sure, this is a difference in norms (and law) that I'm intentionally taking for granted, and trying to further understand. If equally-applied, it's a little more comprehensible to me (eg Germany requiring massive game studios to censor Nazi symbolism in WW2 games).

But I have a much stronger revulsion reaction to the idea that the govt should be in the business of deciding whose expression is "actually" art, and inconsistently allowing well-connected creators latitude that nobodies aren't privy to. I don't doubt that there are many people find the Nazi pug funnier than the Father Ted joke (and vice versa); the idea that the latter is uniquely acceptable because a _British govt agency_ decided it was funny is astonishing to me.

wutbrodo··on Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
She also had a "fuck imperialism" sign, and was outside of the cathedral in which QEII's body was lying. Cultures that are more fragile wrt speech norms may object to that.

A better example is the man calling out "who elected him" to the proclamation of Charles III, at a ceremony that had as little as possible to do with funerary rites while still dealing with her son's ascension.

The better example is

wutbrodo··on Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
In what legal sense is the YouTuber with the pug less protected by the "art form" argument than the movie production? Did the latter get a permit for Nazi jokes? (Sincere question, maybe they did: UK speech norms and laws are incredibly alien to me)
wutbrodo··on Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
I think you're just seeing an example of the raging inferiority complex that many members of the rest of the West exhibit towards the US. There's a noticeable cultural difference along certain axes, with both significant downsides and significant upsides for both sides of the cultural divide. But there are many out there who aren't cognitively capable of processing the breathtaking nuance of global cultural differences, and unsurprisingly they end up with a reductive view of the culture they don't understand (same as it ever was).

My personal experience of backpacking around the world was replete with lectures from 25-year-old European women about the US's issues. They were of such poor quality that I mostly just smiled and shrugged it off, knowing that it'd be a waste of my vacation to try and explain to them the nuances of cultural difference. But I had the delightful catharsis of schooling a particularly-obnoxious British girl on her country's role as the primary contender for history's greatest supervillain (unsurprisingly, her grasp of history and politics was.... poor).

wutbrodo··on Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
The article describes an activist who specifically took pains to avoid any disparagement of the outgoing Queen, limiting his protest to the incoming coronation.

If that falls under the rule you're describing, doesn't that render it impossible to protest a ceremony, as long as it happens after a funeral? It seems you're defining away the protest of hereditary succession as unacceptably rude?

wutbrodo··on Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
True of the first two examples, but:

> in London, a woman was led away by four uniformed officers on Monday after holding up a sign reading "Not my king" — which has become a trending hashtag — near Westminster Hall.

If you count that as rude, you're essentially counting any dissent as rude, no?

Edit: there's an even better example, of a man who was nowhere near any funerary rites, calling out "who elected him" at the proclamation of Charles' ascension.

wutbrodo··on Apps have become too good at their jobs
Yea, I too get a mix of the inane 20-year-old girl crap and the hypermacho MMA/hustler entrepreneur stuff. I figure this is just the prior distribution, the stuff that hits the broadest audience. That's why I'm surprised that I haven't been able to meaningfully escape that rut, despite trying to feed the algorithm my disinterest. It almost feels like they don't know what to show me: the only stuff I see are other forms of undifferentiated crap crap, like handsome doctors overacting to videos about medical issues.

I'm pretty confounded by the fact that it seemed so poor at exploring the space of possible videos

wutbrodo··on Apps have become too good at their jobs
I put a couple of cumulative hours into it, purely to seed/discover the supposedly-fantastic recommendation algorithm. I was drowning in videos of cute couples doing inane things until I started doing the couple extra clicks to indicate Not Interested. After that it got a bit more diverse, but I somehow don't seem to have left seemingly-generic content behind, and at no point did I get any inkling of the "just one more video" flow that I've heard about.
wutbrodo··on Apps have become too good at their jobs
Could you elaborate on what makes it so addictive? Neither Tiktok nor YT Shorts seem to "work" on me, but I've heard from a lot of people, including intelligent & thoughtful people that I respect, that Tiktok's recommendation algorithm is unusually fantastic. I was a little skeptical that Tiktok had broken new ground in a _very_ well-trod space, and had chalked it up to the format and volume of content, which you'd expect to extend to YT shorts too. It sounds like you share this perspective, so I'd be interested to hear more about what you consider to be so addictive about the format.

This isn't some slyly-boastful "what's the big deal, _I_ don't have any issue with it", comment. I assume that this particular hook just missed my brain, and there are others that grab me more (I'm def not thrilled with the amt that I use Twitter). I'm just genuinely curious about the details of what makes the format so hyper-addictive, and can't really explore it by experimenting with my own brain.

wutbrodo··on Draw Anything – A Simple Stable Diffusion Playground
Ah, sorry for incorrectly assuming. I fully agree with you.

It's a very common tendency for people to smuggle their moral intuitions into calls for the precautionary principle, and this runs directly counter to _actually_ approaching these discussions with caution.

wutbrodo··on Draw Anything – A Simple Stable Diffusion Playground
Horrified gave me a NSFW error
wutbrodo··on Draw Anything – A Simple Stable Diffusion Playground
> At the very least, this seems like something to approach with extreme caution.

Like you, I'm not overly informed on the factual question here, but I don't understand why you think banning the content is somehow the cautious course of action.

The heuristics for which action is the "cautious" one is usually some combination of:

a) which outcome is less likely to be harmful b) which outcome is more passive (ie primum non nocere) c) which outcome is more predictable (eg the status quo)

It seems to me that bans fail on the first two counts[1] and squeak by on the third. Even this status quo argument is weakened by how new these bans are, and by the many contemporary countries in which fictionalized CP is legal.

[1] In the former case, this is based on the practically universal consensus that sexual preferences, even dangerous and deviant ones, are burned deeply into one's psyche and can't simply be ignored through lack of exposure. This view was most famously one of the strongest pillars of the successful iteration of the gay rights movement, and is why we consider conversion therapy to be horrific. One can make the claim that this factual claim only applies to gender preferences, but that seems quite an extraordinary claim.

wutbrodo··on Draw Anything – A Simple Stable Diffusion Playground
They're responding to a hysterical, Luddite portion of the public that would make them pay a PR cost if they didn't at least make a sloppy attempt at "safety". It's idiotic and futile, but blessedly short-lived.

Thanks to the miracle of open-source, it took me about 20 minutes yesterday to get Stable Diffusion up and running on my laptop's CPU, with no content filter. SD inference has low enough compute needs that using cloud GPU compute is cheap as hell (for now, perhaps), and discrete GPUs aren't that expensive in the grand scheme of things.

Ultimately, reality often does win. It's just not a stable equilibrium for companies to continue these laughable attempts at "filtering", any more than physical media formats were able to withstand the arrival of digital formats in the presence of piracy. Combine this with the cultural headwinds against the influence of mentally-ill hysterics on social media, and I don't expect the current level of filtering to last very long.

wutbrodo··on Google Pixel 6 still freezes when calling Emergency Services
> if you're going 'all in' on their branded phone

This inference doesn't make any sense. The Pixel isn't some weird niche project. The Pixel and the Galaxy SXX are perennials on the lists you find from a cursory "best android phone" Google query. This is about as casual as it gets, beyond walking into a Best Buy or Verizon and asking for an Android phone (which will also steer you to these two phones pretty often, assuming they're in-budget)

wutbrodo··on Why Does the U.S. Have the Best Research Universities? (2020)
It's the top of the thread, the comment that I replied to and was referring to.

> If it were a true meritocracy, I guess we would expect ~4-5% of US academics to be US born, given that it's our percentage of the world population, but in practice there are huge obstacles for foreigners to come and work here and succeed.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32595436

My claim was that even avid restrictionists don't claim a global meritocracy. They are optimizing other axe: Volk-style prioritization,cultural stability, etc.

wutbrodo··on Why Does the U.S. Have the Best Research Universities? (2020)
I agree with you more than you'd think. I'm aware that my open-borders belief is a radical one, and I accept the dramatic implications and knock-on effects.

But the vast majority of people accept the legitimacy of restricted immigration. IMO the line of moral revulsion they draw between your view and their own is largely illusory. Once you've accepted that you're selecting immigrants, it seems nonsensical to me that your selection criteria should consist of a) rigid and horrifyingly Kafkaesque processes for 99% of countries and b) an inconsistent drip of unselected migrants from an adjacent country (through a process that puts them at substantial physical risk).

Frankly, I'm a little contemptuous of people with this perspective. They don't seem to have thought through their belief that we should restrict the border, but do a shitty job of it in random ways.

wutbrodo··on Why Does the U.S. Have the Best Research Universities? (2020)
Yes, my comment doesn't assume a uniform sample.

In fact, it's predicated on there being a substantial filter applied to legal immigrants, such that they are highly successful in their destination country.

The performance gap between legal immigrants and natives is sizable, implying that marginal extra immigrants from loosening this filter would still outperform natives.

And the marginal extra immigrant outperforming the median native means that claims of a global meritocracy are farcical.

----------

> while touting their support for (limited) immigration of high skilled, well-heeled immigrants as evidence of that they aren’t simply against foreigners.

As mentioned, your comment isn't too related to my point. But to follow the tangent: This perspective seems like a consistent and defensible worldview? Wanting a Canada-like system that prioritizes economically-productive immigration is absolutely evidence against a bias against foreigners per se.

(I don't share this worldview. I think borders are something close to a crime against humanity. But I'm aware that mine is a radical position. The anti-immigrant boogeyman you describe sounds like a fairly logical extrapolation of a general belief in borders)

wutbrodo··on Meta is building an AI to fact-check Wikipedia
HN on FAANG-related threads may as well be a default sub on Reddit. Practically guaranteed to get a heaping dose of childish, manic hysteria instead of a basic understanding of the article's content.

Ive got no love for FB or "fact-checking", but I knew much of this thread would be a dumpster fire.

wutbrodo··on Why Does the U.S. Have the Best Research Universities? (2020)
I don't think even the most Pollyanna-ish perspective claims that there's a global meritocracy. The smashing success of merit-based immigrants in high-income countries is a pretty undeniable signal that we're nowhere near the point where the marginal legal immigrant is less "meritorious" than the pop avg.

I'm personally willing to bite the whole bullet and am an open-borders advocate. But it's a mistake to think that supporters of border restrictions aren't aware that they're explicitly anti-meritocratic.

wutbrodo··on Google Timer is back
This doesn't make any sense. "Software" isn't produced by a single company with a single set of engineering practices and trade-offs. Safety-critical software has been around for decades and decades, and it's not developed and tested using the same practices as a minuscule D-list feature of a web service.
wutbrodo··on Cut the cutesy errors
> if a housekeeper shouted your name from across the room, tapped you on the shoulder repeatedly, and then unplugged the TV you were watching to get your attention, you would expect them to say something like, "my apologies sir, the den is on fire," rather than, "lol, howdy

You're talking about something completely different, urgency rather than formality. In the rude interruption example you gave, you combined the two despite them having nothing to do with each other. "holy shit bro the den is on fire!" would be an infinitely more appropriate reason for a rude interruption than "my esteemed sir, how goes your day".

As I said, it's an arbitrary aesthetic preference. GP's irritation that computers dont address users as aristocrats makes just as much (little) sense as getting angry that they don't shower the user with compliments about your appearance.

Like, it's cool if they're into that, but it's super weird to describe it as a general principle of UIs

wutbrodo··on Instagram, TikTok, and the Three Trends
The novel element is combining the passive medium with infinite content. In my circles, sitting slack-jawed in front of the TV for hours was something that only those with little mental energy or drive did[1]. By contrast, probably 75% have some non-trivial degree of slack-jawed passive social media consumption, even more so since IG and Tiktok.

To wit, I think what's interesting about this Era of media relative to the TV Era is the vanishing proportion of the population that's able to escape the habit.

[1] Not a value judgment: my sister and her husband consume massive amounts of TV but they're also both early-career doctors. I would be braindead at the end of the day too.

wutbrodo··on Twitter says Musk’s spam analysis used tool that called his own account a bot
> makes them ineligible for protection from those violating securities and contract law

GP said he doesn't feel sorry for them. He said nothing about legal protections being inapplicable to Twitter. You just brazenly made this up out of whole cloth.

wutbrodo··on Cut the cutesy errors
> but I read it as half-assed.

Why is formality any more natural for a user interface than casualness? This seems like an extremely arbitrary personal preference masquerading as reasonable criticism, no different from getting riled up about the fact that Windows default theme is blue when it should _obviously_ be green.

> Computers are our servants, not our friends. They should act like it.

I had a live-in housekeeper for a chunk of my life, which is roughly as close to "servant" as one gets in the modern West; we communicated in normal, casual English. If you are going around insisting that service workers address you like an aristocrat, you're an enormous asshole.

wutbrodo··on Intermittent fasting 2 days vs. 1 day per week
> This right here is the first and most important reason to be skeptical of any study on weight loss. None of these things ever turn out to do anything useful on a time horizon that matters.

It's (always) worth skimming the article, or at least the headline. From the subheadline:

> *Given the same energy intake and expenditure*, intermittent fasting two days versus one day per week increases weight loss in overweight men and women

This study isn't saying "2 day IF is a miracle weight-loss cure and you should just do it bada bing bada boom weight loss solved". It's holding everything constant except the number of fasting days, and finding that it's (quite dramatically) more effective in the short-term.

This is a data point, not a weight-loss plan. It doesn't call for "skepticism", just careful reading and limited application (or for a start, reading the article/headline at all).

Nutrition is intensely complicated and devilishly difficult to study. But for scientifically-literate people who take it seriously, data points like this shed light on limited portions of the "solution space". This is crucial to mapping out the space enough to understand how to improve your own diet; it's not amenable to an impatient approach that expects every study to be a magic bullet.

Even ignoring the signal that this provides, the absolute minimum value of this study is that somebody who's already doing a time-limited IF-1 diet can switch to a time-limited IF-2 diet. That's valuable in and of itself.

> If you want to know how to lose weight for a few weeks you don't need a peer reviewed journal, just go get a "women's health" magazine and read about several ways that really do probably work to lose weight in that timespan.

With the same improvement in hunger levels, hormone profile, and cardiometabolic health (all mentioned in the for both the control and treatment)? I highly doubt it. Even assuming that IF isn't sustainable[1], people do have short-term weight loss goals sometimes, and IF provides a path to do so that keeps metabolic and hormonal health in mind relative to traditional crash dieting.

[1] I've been doing it for....five years now? Not only did I lose a reasonable amount of weight early on, it's been helpful for maintaining during a life phase of suddenly-expanding waistlines among my peers. Plus it's trivial to dial it up slightly when I do feel the need to tighten up a little.

wutbrodo··on Ask HN: Working in tech for climate?
> Income is related to consumption, and consumption is related to emissions and pollution.

This doesn't make any sense. The suggestion is to make more money and donate ~all of it instead of consuming it. You can't look at a plan to make more income and infer that the higher income means more consumption _when the entire point of the plan explicitly avoids consuming the excess income_.

wutbrodo··on Code doesn’t have to be a mess
The enormous silliness of this argument doesn't seem to stop it from popping up all over the place. People's expectations are relative to their environment. The large majority of things you might think to complain about in your life would look hilarious to a caveman or a medieval peasant or even someone from 1980. Similarly, the vast majority of HN users are extremely high-percentile for global wealth and income: this would be a very boring place if people bought in to your paralyzing insistence that you can't ever discuss improvements to something because problems larger than it exist somewhere in the world.

It's a worldview that's so nonsensical that it's its own reductio ad absurdum: If a fast-food worker complained about wanting to be treated with dignity at work, would you similarly scoff at them because coal miners or sweatshop workers don't even get physical safety?

Having high standards is a _good_ thing. It's the hallmark of society's progress. It doesn't preclude being grateful for the privileges you do have, and it's nothing to be ashamed of unless your self-esteem is so low that you think you don't deserve to be treated well.

wutbrodo··on It’s time to leave the leap second in the past
They explain this at the top of the article:

> This periodic adjustment mainly benefits scientists and astronomers as it allows them to observe celestial bodies using UTC for most purposes. If there were no UTC correction, then adjustments would have to be made to the legacy equipment and software that synchronize to UTC for astronomical observations.

> While the leap second might have been an acceptable solution in 1972, when it made both the scientific community and the telecom industry happy, these days UTC is equally bad for both digital applications and scientists, who often choose TAI or UT1 instead.

The claim is that the benefits accrue primarily to a community whose relative importance is minuscule compared to the broader software world in 2022. The tradeoff was made in 1972, when astronomers etc represented a vastly larger proportion of software.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →