HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

x187463

1,291 karma · joined May 28, 2024

submissionscomments
x187463··on Couchers is officially out of beta
In that case, the reviewer seems to have completely misunderstood the subject of the review. That's a fine review (I guess) if the subject of the review is Amazon and the purchasing/delivery experience. Of course, it would be obvious from reading the review that it's not useful to somebody looking for book reviews and it should be (re)moved, but for whatever reason we have accepted platforms such as Amazon will simply fail to handle it properly.
x187463··on I'm dialing back my LLM usage
Am I spending too much time on HN or is every post/comment section filled with this same narrative? Basically, LLMs are exciting but they produce messy code for which the dev feels no ownership. Managing a codebase written by an LLM is difficult because you have not cognitively loaded the entire thing into your head as you do with code written yourself. They're okay for one-off scripts or projects you do not intend to maintain.

This is blog post/comment section summary encountered many times per day.

The other side of it is people who seem to have 'gotten it' and can dispatch multiple agents to plan/execute/merge changes across a project and want to tell you how awesome their workflow is without actually showing any code.

x187463··on A proof-of-concept neural brain implant providing speech
Curious how much intentionality is required from the user to produce sounds. It would be unfortunate if this device just started firing off speech for what would otherwise be thoughts one would not say out loud. I suppose that depends on the mechanism required to activate the neurons to which the device is connected.
x187463··on Use keyword-only arguments in Python dataclasses
What do you mean pass a dict? As in kwargs?

    kwargs = {'arg1':'val1', 'arg2':'val2'}
    my_obj = MyDataclass(**kwargs)
Works fine for a dataclass with arg1 and arg2 attributes.
x187463··on What Happens When Hertz's AI Scanner Finds Damage on Your Rental
I agree. Regardless of what you think about Hertz or the dubious fees associated with the damage repair, the actual tech is doing something useful. I'd rather scan the vehicle as I leave the lot and have clear evidence of its state before and after the rental period, than have to argue with a random employee about the timing/source of damage.
x187463··on Fun with uv and PEP 723
run script

"missing x..."

pip install x

run script

"missing y..."

pip install y

> y not found

google y to find package name

pip install ypackage

> conflict with other package

realize I forgot a venv and have contaminated my system python

check pip help output to remember how to uninstall a package

clean up system python

create venv at cwd

start over

...

</end of time>

x187463··on OpenAI o3-pro
It's arguable ChatGPT is not such a great name, either. The general public has no idea what GPT means and will often swap the letters around. It does benefit from being unique, however.
x187463··on My Cord-Cutting Adventure (2020)
This sounds like a lot of effort to keep watching commercials.
x187463··on Eleven v3
This is the feature that has me using Edge at work. Having the browser read every blog/article at 2x speed with word highlighting is awesome.
x187463··on A Song of “Full Self-Driving”
FSD is incredible in that it works everywhere, most of the time. The problem is it works most of the time. I do not think the current FSD sensor suite (camera only) will ever be safely capable of true unsupervised FSD. I use FSD every day. I would seriously estimate FSD has put 95% of the miles on my car. I regularly encounter the following:

* treating red lights like stop signs

* completely ignoring flash reds

* stopping at flashing yellows

* ignoring school zones

* driving 10mph under the limit

* driving 20mph over the limit

* ignoring turn only lanes resulting in being dumped into oncoming traffic until it leisurely moves back into the correct lane

* waiting until the last minute to get into the correct lane to make a turn/take an exit

* ignoring signs indicating a lane ends and having to force its way into traffic

* ignoring signs a lane ends and changing into the lane only to have to change back immediately

* pulling out in front of cars, especially at night or other camera obscuring events

* ignoring cars merging onto the highway and blocking them until I take over and get out of the way

I treat it like cruise control. And based on the recent accident during which FSD decided to run itself off a perfectly straight, open, clear rode and into a tree, I keep my hand on the wheel.

Even in a geo-fenced environment, FSD is NOT going to work for unsupervised robo-taxi applications. Musk needs to get out of the way and let them stick LIDARs on these cars.

All that being said, it has also handled really complex driving in/around DC/Baltimore including some tricky merges/transitions that are hard to track as a human driver. It's knowledge of all of the surrounding vehicles allows it to make these maneuvers with far more confidence that I would. It also frees me up to track the bigger picture of traffic while not having to manage my speed/lane position. It's like driving with a friend who's not necessarily the best driver, but is basically competent. Let's just hope it doesn't decide to drive me in to a tree for no particular reason.

x187463··on Show HN: Terminal Flower Garden
You might like TerminalTextEffects. Disclosure, I'm the author.

https://github.com/ChrisBuilds/terminaltexteffects

x187463··on I tried to buy an actual barrel of crude oil (2015)
I find it nearly incomprehensible that so much oil exists. That's ~7k Olympic swimming pools of oil every day. This has been going on for decades.
x187463··on How I blog with Obsidian, Hugo, GitHub, and Cloudflare
Copilot is helpful for handing formatting and repetitive structural stuff. It doesn't need to actually create the content to be useful.
x187463··on We Have Made No Progress Toward AGI
> Which means these LLM architectures will not be producing groundbreaking novel theories in science and technology.

Is it not possible that new theories and breakthroughs could result from this so-called statistical pattern matching? The information necessary could be present in the training data and the relationship simply never before considered by a human.

We may not be on a path to AGI, but it seems premature to claim LLMs are fundamentally incapable of such contributions to knowledge.

In fact, it seems that these AI labs are leaning in such a direction. Keep producing better LLMs until the LLM can make contributions that drive the field forward.

x187463··on Demystifying decorators: They don't need to be cryptic
I think much of the challenge people have with decorators is not in understanding how they work, but in identifying when they are useful.
x187463··on Gemini 2.5 Flash
Personal Projects

Will finally implement that gravity in TTE, despite vowing not to. We all know how well developers keep promises.

Knowledge Growth

Will achieve enlightenment on the true meaning of 'enshittification', likely after attempting to watch a single YouTube video without Premium.

I found these actually funny. Cool project.

x187463··on Discord's face scanning age checks 'start of a bigger shift'
I see a lot of comments here arguing age requirements are overreach and these decisions should be left to the parents. To those presenting such arguments, do you think that applies to other activities as well? What about smoking/drinking/firearms? Pornography? Driving?

I haven't researched the topic of social media's effect on young people, but the common sentiment I encounter is that it's generally harmful, or at least capable of harm in a way that is difficult to isolate and manage as a parent.

The people closest to this issue, that is parents, school faculty, and those who study the psychology and health of children/teens, seem to be the most alarmed about the effects of social media.

If that's true, I can understand the need to, as a society, agree we would like to implement some barrier between kids/teens and the social media companies. How that is practically done seems to be the challenge. Clicking a box that say's, in effect, "I totally promise I am old enough." is completely useless for anything other than a thin legal shield.

x187463··on Firebase Studio
Do you think Cursor's AI tools are significantly better than VSCode's Copilot? I haven't had time to check out Cursor. But from the general description, the AI tooling sounds very similar.
x187463··on No elephants: Breakthroughs in image generation
This is a before/after moment for image generation. A simple example is the background images on a ton of (mediocre) music youtube channels. They almost all use AI generated images that are full of nonsense the closer you look. Jazz channels will feature coffee shops with garbled text on the menu and furniture blending together. I bet all of that disappears over the next few months.

On another note, and perhaps others are feeling similarly, but I am finding myself surprised at how little use I have for this stuff, LLMs included. If, ten years ago, you told me I would have access to tools like this, I'm sure I would have responded with a never ending stream of ideas and excitement. But now that they're here, I just sort of poke at it for a minute and carry on with my day.

Maybe it's the unreliability on all fronts, I don't know. I ask a lot of programming questions and appreciate some of the autocomplete in vscode, but I know I'm not anywhere close to taking full advantage of what these systems can do.

x187463··on Waymos crash less than human drivers
I think the correct response for FSD would have been to stop in the situations presented in the video. That wasn't anything like normal fog, rain, or light obstruction. The situations they created were so extreme you simply couldn't operate a vehicle safely. That being said, the effectiveness and precision of lidar should be a legal requirement for autonomous vehicles.
x187463··on Waymos crash less than human drivers
I use FSD every day and it has driven easily 98% of the miles on my model 3. I would never let it drive unsupervised. I honestly have no idea how they think they're ready for robotaxis. FSD is an incredible driver assistance system. It's actually a joy to use, but it's simply not capable of reliable unsupervised performance. A big reason, it struggles exactly where you think it would based on a vision only system. It needs a more robust mechanism of building it's world model.

A simple example. I was coming out of a business driveway, turning left onto a two lane road. It was dark out with no nearby street lights. There was a car approaching from the left. FSD could see that a car was coming. However, from the view of a camera, it was just a ball of light. There was no reasonable way the camera could discern the distance given the brightness of the headlights. I suspected this was the case and was prepared to intervene, but left FSD on to see how it would respond. Predictably, it attempted to pull out in front of the car and risked a collision.

That kind of thing simply can not be allowed to happen with a truly autonomous vehicle and would never happen with lidar.

Hell, just this morning on my way to work FSD was going run a flashing red light. It's probably 95% accurate with flashing reds, but that needs to be 100%. That being said, my understanding is the current model being trained has better temporal understanding such that flashing lights will be more comprehensible to the system. We'll see.

x187463··on Block YouTube ads on AppleTV by decrypting and stripping ads from Profobuf (2022)
It's crazy how that option completely evades many people's reasoning on the subject.
x187463··on Block YouTube ads on AppleTV by decrypting and stripping ads from Profobuf (2022)
Perhaps on review of specific ad presentation practices, you could argue for a degradation of experience, but showing adds more or less within YouTube to free users seems like an acceptable method of generating revenue.

As an aside, the fact that people pay for cable and still have 4-7 minute ad-breaks every 15 minutes make anything YouTube does pale in comparison.

x187463··on Tesla electric car sales plunge again in Australia – Model 3 down more than 81 p
It certainly seems as though many people's opinion of FSD is very much out of date. I recall riding in a friend's M3 in 2020 when he attempted to demonstrate FSD (or whatever it was called at the time). We didn't make it more than a minute or so before he had to deactivate it. When I picked up my M3 years later, I assumed FSD would still be mostly vaporware.

I honestly can't believe how good is has gotten. It's not perfect and I maintain full awareness of what it's doing, but it performs incredibly well 95% of the time. It's really nice to feel like you're being driven by a mostly competent driver everywhere you go. Really, it makes about the same number (or less) of mistakes as other people I've driven with, but the mistakes are of a different sort, and after a while you develop an intuition of the situations that are going to challenge it.

x187463··on Tesla electric car sales plunge again in Australia – Model 3 down more than 81 p
Are there any other carmakers with anything close to SFSD? People love to hate and act as though SFSD doesn't work, but SFSD v13 has driven ~95% of the miles on my model 3. From the driveway to the office and back, SFSD drives the car with minimal input. I would love to switch to a different manufacturer without giving up the huge convenience.

Either way, I certainly won't buy another Tesla while Elon is running the place.

x187463··on Andrew Tate and brother leave Romania for US after travel ban lifted
Probably wants to offer them senior leadership roles at a federal agency.
x187463··on YouTube's New Hue
I have had premium on a family plan for almost as long as it has existed. It's great to add family members who use YouTube on their televisions giving them an ad-free experience without the shenanigans of setting up blockers at a network level.

I very much don't understand the opposition to paying for some of the services we use every day. I get not wanted to pay 15-20/month for something like Apple or Disney, if you only want to watch a single show/film. But people act like you are crazy for paying for YouTube or Twitch, meanwhile they lose countless hours experiencing the frustration of advertisements. It's common to find discussions online where people are both completely opposed to paying for YouTube, with no real justification for that position, and highly upset at having to watch ads. Same goes for Twitch, which is arguably worse as the ads interrupt live broadcasts.

I use adblock everywhere else, but I thoroughly enjoy not having to worry about it on the platforms I use the most. It's not a scam to pay for something you use and enjoy every day.

x187463··on To buy a Tesla Model 3, only to end up in hell
Every modern car has, at least, a media player interface. Why wouldn't you want to be able to update that software to support changes in CarPlay, modern apps, etc?
x187463··on Donald Knuth's 2024 Christmas Lecture: Strong and Weak Components [video]
He wears it almost every year. You can go back to at least 1997 in this playlist.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLoROMvodv4rOAvKVR_dyC...

x187463··on In the belly of the MrBeast
If I find I am receiving recommendations in which I am uninterested and are clearly based on a handful of videos I watched previously, I can clear those from the history and the algorithm doesn't use them for future recommendations. The simplest example would be watching videos for a one-time use case such as repairing a specific home issue. I definitely don't need more recommendations to fix that/related issues, but YouTube is likely to spend a little time sending them my way. I can fix that quickly by removing the original videos from my history.
← PreviousPage 6 of 7Next →