HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xabotage

174 karma · joined December 13, 2015

submissionscomments
xabotage··on 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction
Survivorship bias. Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing. This leaves those who are either too afraid to confront the cognitive dissonance or who were already happy in the first place.
xabotage··on The Science of the Benefits of Religion
If the people who believed in evolution more out of faith than true understanding actually did the legwork to remove their biases and objectively study/experiment on the subject, they would come to find that evolution is real. And if Jehovah's Witnesses actually did the legwork to remove their biases and objectively study/experiment on their religion, most of them would run as far away as they could.

Some things just have to be taken on faith because life is too short to get a PhD in every subject, but I sure hope the world continues to move towards evidence-based rather than magic-based foundations of default belief.

xabotage··on The Science of the Benefits of Religion
"Impossible standards," for some religions, include things like being happy and fulfilled in a mixed orientation marriage with a large number of children.

Not all directions are worth pushing in, and religion is actually really bad at identifying the good directions.

xabotage··on Renting a car will be a pain until at least 2022
Depends. I wouldn't want to get slapped with a high fee if I were held up in traffic, I'd end up renting elsewhere. Also, I've heard that rental agencies often lend vehicles between one another, which could further complicate the issues that make capacity unreliable.
xabotage··on Renting a car will be a pain until at least 2022
Rental car companies cannot control their inventory as well as we might hope. Sometimes cars are returned early. Sometimes late. Sometimes late and in need of maintenance. Sometimes people cancel. If the rental agency planned for these contingencies with additional inventory, that would just be extra cars lying around depreciating most of the time. I think we are to understand from their "untenable conduct" is that margins are too low to not be cleverly utilizing all of their inventory JIT-style, and nobody in their market segment wants to pay higher fees in exchange for a guaranteed vehicle model.
xabotage··on Jeff Bezos Is Not My Astronaut
On the bright side, ultra-billionaires like Bezos will never be space pioneers. The reason is simple: they value themselves too much to risk literally going where no man has gone before. They'll wait for "more expendable" (wo)men to go there first and prepare the way.
xabotage··on ‘Dragon Man’ skull may be new species, shaking up human family tree
The thing about crackpots with wildly unsubstantiated self-aggrandizing anthropological theories is that they often wield disproportionate power and influence. Take the Mormon church for example: they believe Native Americans were white Jews who were cursed with dark skin and it was god's will they be wiped out by European settlers. It's horrifically racist and there's zero evidence to support the origin story. And yet, the church holds over $100 billion in their investment portfolio alone and nearly had one of their own elected as US president. It's hard to laugh at.
xabotage··on I'll pay you to read my book (2013)
This. It has to be a net monetary loss for the consumer, otherwise you're just inviting a form of "e-book mining." I can picture it now: meet Patrick, a graduate student who works part time on his uncle's kindle farm scrolling through pages on hundreds of devices and earning $18/hr
xabotage··on Descript – A collaborative audio/video editor that works like a doc
I counted as well, pedant that I am, and I still believe that 2 is an unusually high number of times for hners.
xabotage··on Descript – A collaborative audio/video editor that works like a doc
This. I've never seen hners describe a product as "sexy" as many times as in the comments here.
xabotage··on Zero-click, wormable, cross-platform remote code execution in Microsoft Teams
> Microsoft acts like an ex that wants you to believe they’ve changed but you always regret trusting them

This is the most apt analogy I've yet seen. I went "back" to Microsoft in the mid 2010s right around the time they started gaining a reputation for sucking less. Big mistake. But at least it gave me enough perspective to realize that the competing non-microsoft products and OSes (even the FOSS ones!) really aren't lacking as much as you'd expect.

xabotage··on Translation from VC-Backed PR Jargon to English of Magic Leap CEO Statement
This. I have worked and developed on the HoloLens; it is 20% cool tech demo and 80% cardboard propped up by Microsoft's over-eager marketing (think Xbox Kinect). Only difference between them and Magic Leap is that Microsoft has a large swath of existing gullible enterprise customers who will happily buy whatever superfluous products they can be talked into buying, whereas I guess Magic Leap's core competencies are on the opposite end, selling to gullible VCs.
xabotage··on DirectX is coming to the Windows Subsystem for Linux
The developers' word is irrelevant. Microsoft is a business. Microsoft will pursue its long term business interests. Developers are hired to do what the business directs. So the question is really, "what would best serve Microsoft's business interests?" and not "what do the developers intend?" because in time only one question matters and unfortunately it's not the one with the best interests of non-windows-users in mind.
xabotage··on Tolstoy’s Children’s Stories
Agreed, I think the secret is often a kind of subtlety that can often be confused with meaninglessness. For example, the first time I read "Of Mice and Men", I found the "meaningless" suffering to be infuriating - how could this book possibly be considered a classic? - until I later understood more context around the novel's time period and message, and realized it was only my juvenile tastes and expectations that made it seem meaningless (no happy ending? What is this tripe?)

I doubt Tolstoy wrote his stories without some kind of purpose, but I agree it would be a mistake to try too hard looking for meaning in case he just felt like writing up some sad shit.

xabotage··on Tolstoy’s Children’s Stories
Assuming "meaningless" truly is an apt description for them, I actually think this makes Tolstoy's stories seem all the more intriguing. Most violence and tragedy in life is meaningless, we humans ascribe meaning to it. It's sometimes fun to read a fictional piece and contemplate why the themes resonate with me, without having a ham-handed, prefabricated meaning shoved down my throat. Modernized fairy tales (and almost all modern fiction) are not intended to confront the consumer with these kinds of emotional/intellectual obstacles without a moralistic guide. This often makes it suitable for children, but I wonder if we underestimate children's ability to confront this kind of ambiguity (but that doesn't necessarily mean we should read Tolstoy's stories to them, or only ever offer ambiguity as a moral socialization strategy).
xabotage··on Ask HN: What scientific phenomenon do you wish someone would explain better?
Agreed. I find it difficult to even ask for a deeper understanding of evolution without first explaining yes, I know basically how DNA works; yes, I understand natural selection; no, I'm not a young-earth creationist. I have a solid grasp of basic biology and genetics and I'd just like to comprehend how randomness can lead to such incredible complexity of organisms within billion-year timescales (and not, say, million-trillion-trillion year timescales).

I feel as though it's simply Occam's Razor to assume that evolutionary complexity is the result of randomness because I know of no better explanation. Is there a self-reinforcing process at play? (Natural selection partially counts as reinforcing, I just feel like randomness is still the engine that powers it).

xabotage··on As YouTube traffic soars, YouTubers say pay is plummeting
I find myself generally unaffected by advertising and would normally fall into the "waste of money" camp, until I started hanging out more with non-engineering types. Seeing them made me realize A) advertising does work, at least for a critical mass of people, and B) advertising doesn't take away their ability to judge a product, no matter how well targeted it is. I've even found they have a superior ability to judge products and services than I do at times because they intuitively jive with the marketing in a way that my engineering brain doesn't (they can piece together subjective qualities about a product/service being marketed to them, and I just think "show me the specs and price." Both approaches have benefits and downsides).
xabotage··on For people with an abusive partner, lockdown means captivity
> "I am afraid for my well-being and/or am being held hostage in my own home; please send a police escort to rescue me from my house; and then, optionally, please take me into protective custody, so that I may be safe for a few days while filing a motion of a restraining order."

These magic words likely will elicit the correct response from law enforcement. But being able to formulate this phrase implies awareness on the part of the victim that they are being abused, that something can be done about it, and that they have the courage to do what it takes to escape. The truth is that many victims are manipulated into believing there's no way out. Even the ones who do pull the trigger experience a lot of pain upfront that only becomes worth it later - they are still emotionally attached to their abusers.

We should absolutely educate people as to the usefulness of police in abusive scenarios (an abuser would have the victim think they are helpless), but getting victims to recognize and say the magic words is more than half the battle.

xabotage··on From Spain to Germany, farmers warn of fresh food shortages
It's different because I don't use my ass to open doors, type on computers, prepare/eat food, or scratch my eye. Your face and arms, however, get involved in those activities sooner or later. I don't care if my poop cannon has a bit of residue around the rim that paper can't quite remove, handling shit is literally what it does every day, and it's otherwise stowed away safely.

Granted, I bet a warm-water bidet feels fantastic and I would probably never go back if I had one.

xabotage··on Do Not Trust Journalists – A Mormon Example
Leakers are playing their part in the same game. In the case of companies I've worked for in the past, leakers were just grabbing cash in exchange for helping the media push the distorted narratives that were already being published, framing the leaker as a hero. This isn't to say all leakers are to be mistrusted; "skepticism" is indeed the right word, and I believe it still applies to leakers.

Edit to add: there are obvious cases where whistleblowing is a necessary and welcome action for ethical reasons, but most often "leaks" that I've seen get blown up by the media over sensitive information that does no one any good, inside or outside of the affected company. I think "737 Max is unsafe"-style leaks are less common.

xabotage··on Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under constant surveillance
> If it's not, then why do we allow open carry/concealed carry permits in public spaces?

It's often not allowed to carry in places like schools (varies depending on district or state). However, many pro-gun supporters make the argument that CC supposedly makes public spaces safer because active shooters don't really need a license to murder people anyway, so anyone carrying during a situation has more defense (just stating the argument, not certifying it's correctness). But I'm interested in hearing how often it's the case that some licensed idiot badly secures their weapon in a public space leading to an active shooter situation (and for this reason I definitely wouldn't trust students to CC. But I'm also not in favor of clear backpacks, as that similarly feels like a case of "solving the wrong problem").

xabotage··on Visa, Mastercard, Stripe, and eBay exit Facebook’s Libra project
>They had the ability to monitor all of your transactions and if they didn't like you they could roll back or block your transactions.

Unlike, what, my established credit card company which still blocks me randomly when I'm traveling overseas even when I explicitly call their 800 hotline, sit on hold for 30 minutes, and tell some unempathetic worker "I'm overseas, don't block me"? Yes, thank goodness libra is dying, otherwise there might actually be some innovation against the exact things you just mentioned which perfectly describe the current state of affairs.

(Edit) I think it's fair to not trust Facebook with your currency, but keep in mind the players in the current system (governments, Banks, and credit companies) have hardly proven more trustworthy.

xabotage··on RSI as a Developer
Could you elaborate on this specific genetic condition? I, like many I'm sure, have been tossed back and forth from one clueless doctor to the next, none of whom have even an inkling about what RSI is, much less ways to treat it that don't involve blindly prescribing one drug after another. Does this condition have a specific name and/or type of specialist qualified to diagnose it? It definitely sounds like something worth exploring, but I wouldn't want to seek surgery yet if neither I nor my prospective doctor are familiar enough with this tendon sheath condition (this is the first time I've heard of it myself)
xabotage··on China to the Rescue of Nuclear Power?
I see your point, but I think the original point still stands - even if we take into account the shortcomings of Japanese business culture, what developed country is without its fatal flaws? In other countries, especially less developed ones, they might lack the negative stereotypes of not questioning superiority because they're too busy fighting worse stereotypes like greed, incompetence, or ignorance. What threshold of perfection does a country have to attain before it can be trusted to utilize nuclear power? And I would say Japan does set a pretty high bar when compared with most of the rest of the world.
xabotage··on How Much Does it Cost to Climb Mount Everest?
Does this take into account opportunity cost for time off of work? I watched a presentation from someone who had summitted, and apparently you have to spend several weeks at basecamp acclimating to the altitude before you even start the climb. So not only are you paying for equipment/travel/license/lodging, but you have to make sure you'll still have a job when you get back. I imagine CEO types can take all the time in the world, but all my sick/vacation days combined as a lowly employee wouldn't give me enough time.

Edit: from the article, "Alpenglow unapologetically offers a climb from the Tibet side for an astonishing $85,000 per climber... They have a high western guide ratio, and include pre-acclimatizing in an altitude tent at home." So it sounds like pre-acclimatizing exists, but with this particular deal it's not cheap either.

xabotage··on Spurn the computer game industry
Not sure what "empty pockets" means with an engineer's salary using FOSS tools day in and day out. When was the last time you had to purchase a programming language? A Unix terminal? What makes you think FOSS tools only create FOSS products? When products become tools for other products, opting for the open source tools increases the margin used to feed the "wage slaves".
xabotage··on Spurn the computer game industry
By that I mean, given that artists and game developers are often underpaid and exploited, proprietary tools only exacerbate the situation because the artists are forced to pay whatever price the vendor names (even if the company buys the licenses, it just means less resources left to hire more people to alleviate the insane overtime). Independent shops or freelancers are especially at a disadvantage when they have to rely on expensive tools. Just because the business model for using Unreal is favorable now, that may change (and it certainly isn't favorable for people hooked on Autodesk products).

I understand that if no decent alternatives to tools exist, there is a cost-benefit justification for buying good software. But if artists and game developers are so passionate about what they do that they accept more work for less pay, why can't they be more passionate about FOSS? I'm passionate about FOSS precisely because it allowed me to explore and hone my creativity at a time when professional tools seemed well out of reach.

xabotage··on Spurn the computer game industry
I agree with a focus on open tools. Luckily, there seems to be quite a few OSS game development tools out there, which is why Unity and Unreal now give away their full platforms for "free". That being said, I'm highly skeptical of the "openness" of those platforms, which is why I can't quite bring myself to abandon Blender as a game engine, even though it is somewhat inferior.

The problem is, now that Unreal and Unity are so readily accessible to anyone, a FOSS competitor is unlikely to spring up: from my experience, game developers and artists are paradoxically so willing to shackle themselves to proprietary software (and actively deride anyone who opts for the "inferior" open-source alternatives), whereas I can make a lot more money as a software engineer using FOSS languages, libraries, and platforms.

xabotage··on Spurn the computer game industry
>Most commercial computer games require very powerful computers. This means that a less-wealthy person cannot play online games with their more-wealthy friends. This is especially a problem for young people, for whom gaming is an important social activity.

This. I'd love to try out a variety of fun Half-Life 2 or Quake 3 mods (which all work just fine on an old, low-end laptop running Linux), but everyone I could conceivably play them with is too preoccupied with Overwatch, Battlefront, Call of Duty 36, or whatever closed-server, walled-platform, resource-intensive game came out within the past year or two. Open Arena? These graphics look old, it must suck.

xabotage··on How Social Isolation Is Killing Us
I've seen this brought up many times before but I disagree completely that American cities' designs are the culprit. I enjoy visiting my family in their "suburban fortresses" out in the Midwest where you have to drive a car to get anywhere. I enjoy it because it gives me a chance to recover from the crippling social isolation that comes with living in a city with roommates, taking buses everywhere, walking around in crowds, and generally being surrounded by people who don't care about you.

The way I see it, the level of community involvement and social interaction in general have almost nothing to do with infrastructure, unless you decide to go full-on hermit in the mountains. It matters what people are in your life, not just how many are in your proximity.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →