HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xenophanes

3,793 karma · joined January 7, 2009

https://criticalfallibilism.com
submissionscomments
xenophanes··on [dead]
It being pure distilled drama would be a reason for it to be #2 on front page. You didn't even reply with a different opinion about what reason it's high on the front page.

So he has an opinion that he's willing to write out and expose to critical evaluation. You don't. You're thinking & conversing wrong.

xenophanes··on The world’s rich stay rich while the poor struggle to prosper
Correct.
xenophanes··on The world’s rich stay rich while the poor struggle to prosper
FWIW I'm not convinced that more appeasement of status signaling stuff would be a good thing, even if that kind of compromise got SENS some more money in the short term.

Living longer is great but living better is also very important. Social games waste so much of many people's lives.

xenophanes··on The world’s rich stay rich while the poor struggle to prosper
Their kids will need SENS ~30 years after they do.

I get that the typical plan is to have a dynasty via grand kids, great grand kids, etc, but it's dumb to ignore SENS.

xenophanes··on The world’s rich stay rich while the poor struggle to prosper
He didn't say that yachts are good for manslaughter or that manslaughter is good.

I don't want to debate politics with you because you don't come off as seeking a rational open-minded discussion.

I'm commenting primarily to make it clear that I do not agree with you. I didn't want to leave that ambiguous since both your and my comments about the rich were primarily negative in this thread.

xenophanes··on The world’s rich stay rich while the poor struggle to prosper
If you care about your children, then hugely benefitting them is both selfish (changes the world in a way you personally prefer) and rational. Whatever the OP meant I think it's important.
xenophanes··on The world’s rich stay rich while the poor struggle to prosper
If they care about their kids, that's plenty of reason to fund SENS!
xenophanes··on The world’s rich stay rich while the poor struggle to prosper
Big SENS fan here. Good question.

A lot of the reason is that people do philanthropy to gain various types of status and reputation. It's often a social action. Investing in SENS wouldn't impress their friends in the right way, while various other causes optimize for social signaling.

Yachts and social media companies are a bit different. The yachts are for fun in addition to being a social signal that impresses some people. The social media companies are usually either to make money or to hang out in certain circles, but they do also have some signaling possibilities (you can tell your old stodgy rich friends that you're involved in more hip investments than them).

xenophanes··on Jb’s story about how he nearly lost his Twitter handle
so that's better than before, right?
xenophanes··on My Prescription for Nintendo
It was a gamecube game that was ported before it came out. so there was a parallel period, but originally it was a gamecube game. If you wanna look stuff up for discussions, look it up better. BTW they even mirrored the entire world for the wii version so link could be right handed btw (like the worldmap is mirrored even), it's pretty neat if you wanna go read about it.

gamecube launch was delayed to help sales of wii version for fairly obvious reasons. you're telling me things i already know and then concluding, based on a quick (and careless) reading of wikipedia, that you know better. your own link even says stuff like motion to swing sword in wii TP is cuz they ran out of buttons.

xenophanes··on My Prescription for Nintendo
Of course twilight princess controls are equivalent to buttons. it's a gamecube game that was ported to Wii.

i'm not sure how casual gamers feel about it, but i find the motion controls extremely frustrating and they make games significantly worse, IMO. this might be more of a matter of opinion with better motion technology but for Skyward Sword the motion technology simply isn't good enough. i can test several motions to try to find the right one and do them carefully and both 1) struggle to do something successfully at all 2) find the identical motion gets variable results in game. Not fun. if the motion controls in Skyward Sword were equivalent to buttons at least they'd be simpler and I'd be able to mostly do the actions i want.

And I say this as a fan of the Infinity Blade iOS touch sword fighting games. if the non-button technology is good quality and the game actually makes sense with the controls, then it's fine. skyward sword fails on both counts.

Meanwhile in Link Between Worlds it breaks the flow of the game every time you want to change items or take the broom because you have to use the touch screen for those (which probably means pulling out the stylus since the touch screen sucks), and the whole rest of the game is buttons. the break in the action to grab your stylus, press twice, and set it somewhere again (on your shirt and hope it doesn't fall on the ground?) constantly interrupts you and does not add any fun.

xenophanes··on Possibly fake Kiva loans
According to those pages, they want more than an average year of income for a person in that area, to buy inventory. Isn't that too much inventory to buy all at once?

And yeah it looks like there was a shared template for both of these.

xenophanes··on Google Calendar Unexpectedly Leaks Private Information
does it really count as unexpected at this point?
xenophanes··on Google outed me
They seriously hurt a lot of people in a very predictable and avoidable way, and are not interested in fixing the harm they've done. And you're whitewashing it without giving any substantive answer to the points in the linked article.
xenophanes··on Warren Buffett offers $1 billion for perfect March Madness bracket
It's standard BS. Waiting 40 years has negative value – approximately half a billion dollars worth of negative value.
xenophanes··on Warren Buffett offers $1 billion for perfect March Madness bracket
The payout is $500m though, plus false advertising.
xenophanes··on Ask HN: How to find part-time developer work?
Why do you think blood drives are good? Why wouldn't it be better if the standard thing was to pay for blood? If it was typical to pay donors for this kind of thing (organs too), wouldn't that better ensure plenty of supply than making charity the primary source?
xenophanes··on Female Founders
PG isn't a worm. He's done good things, not bad things, and he knows it and won't say otherwise. He tries to clarify (implying his accusers are mistaken), rather than apologize. Some people don't like anything great; they weren't tearing him down due to misunderstanding but malice. They don't like his attitude and accomplishments, and clarifying that his views are reasonable won't satisfy them. This is an explanatory passage from Atlas Shrugged, by Ayn Rand:

"My sister. My dear sister. Oh, she'll think she's great, won't she?"

"You dislike your sister, Mr. Taggart?" He made the same sound; its meaning was so eloquent that she needed no other answer. "Why?" she asked.

"Because she thinks she's so good. What right has she to think it? What right has anybody to think he's good? Nobody's any good."

"You don't mean it, Mr. Taggart."

"I mean, we're only human beings—and what's a human being? A weak, ugly, sinful creature, born that way, rotten in his bones—so humility is the one virtue he ought to practice. He ought to spend his life on his knees, begging to be forgiven for his dirty existence. When a man thinks he's good—that's when he's rotten. Pride is the worst of all sins, no matter what he's done."

"But if a man knows that what he's done is good?"

"Then he ought to apologize for it."

"To whom?"

"To those who haven't done it."

xenophanes··on Happy Guys Finish Last: The Impact of Emotion Expressions on Sexual Attraction
what is this crap and why is it upvoted?

> In contrast, women over the age of 30 tended to rate shame- and happy- displaying men as equally attractive (and both more so than neutral).

happy guys finish ahead of control, not last... and the BS title is from the original paper.

that's over 30, but several of the graphs in the paper (not all) show happy guys beating the control. meanwhile i don't see anything clearly indicating happy guys lost to the control overall; it looks more the other way around. at the very least, it's not clear happy guys finish last and lose to the control.

EDIT: the abstract says:

> happiness was the most attractive female emotion expression, and one of the least attractive in males.

so they knew the title was BS and didn't repeat the claim in the abstract. in the abstract they use weasel words, in the title they intentionally lie to get more attention/views.

xenophanes··on Happy Guys Finish Last: The Impact of Emotion Expressions on Sexual Attraction
There are a variety of alternative explanations, consistent with the data. The conclusion in the title is just one of many possibilities they didn't differentiate between.

It could be, for example, that guy photos do best when they stand out instead of looking like every other guy. it could be that the best guy photo would be a happy smiling guy who stands out in a different way, but when you remove everything else from the photo and the choices are standing out or being happy, both good, then standing out is better.

this is a standard practice in pseudo "science" – get some data, make up a conclusion that doesn't contradict the data, say you have evidence for your conclusion (or say something stronger), don't carefully think about everything else you could have included instead and how to pick between them.

as usual with bad "science", there is no section titled "sources of error" or similar. nor is there a section covering alternative conclusions compatible with the data. if you aren't thinking about all the ways you could be wrong, it's not really science. (and if you think about them but don't publish that part, you're not publishing science)

xenophanes··on Happy Guys Finish Last: The Impact of Emotion Expressions on Sexual Attraction
the controls are terrible. her hair isn't arranged the same in every pic and her breasts are more visible in the happy and pride pics than the neutral one.

all the pics are way too over-acted, the "pride" girl pic isn't a typical girl pose (it's super exaggerated for a guy, and even less realistic for a girl). these poses have little to do with real life. it's just ivory tower BS, incompetently done (quite apart from being so unrealistic, the bad controls are just incompetent even within the narrow field, just by basic scientific standards)

xenophanes··on Apple’s 2013 Scorecard
I've had two big problems with Messages and all my friends have the same problems. First, typing anything in the Search box would beachball the app indefinitely until Mavericks. Second, there are issues with messages not being sent and having a red exclamation point by them – that has happened so much we have a backup Skype chat for when Messages is acting up.

Also Mavericks removed the ability to disable graphical smileys :(((((( (Is there a workaround or fix anyone knows? please tell me!!)

I mostly use Messages on Mac but use iOS some too. There's a huge problem on iOS which is scrolling to the bottom when people type stuff, which prevents you from catching up on conversations until everyone stops talking. That's super frustrating.

(Auto scrolling to the bottom when you talk, on Mac, is also annoying. I want to read through chat I missed, reply to things as I go, and not lose my place. You have to open a second copy of the window to deal with this.)

xenophanes··on The Mac Pro Review
Your post was unclear and I asked what you meant. I didn't debate anything. i was extremely clear and explicit about this. i asked a question, said i didn't know, said i was curious, didn't dispute anything you said.

Only a domain expert could be expected to automatically know whether double GPUs is effectively the same thing as double CPUs or not. Apple has put a lot of effort into making their GPU structure effective (in general, not just for a few special cases), and I didn't know if you were saying they'd failed or not. i know parallel processing is hard, but i also know apple has smart people who've worked on it. i don't know things like whether "lack of unified memory" is a problem for apple's design too, or not. it seems completely plausible to me, not knowing the domain that well, that apple could have had something that works well in general, or not – i don't really know and you didn't say, just assumed your reader would somehow know what you meant (which will basically only work for people who already know your point and have no need to read your comment at all).

xenophanes··on The Mac Pro Review
so you think 2 compute cards is bad. but what about the mac pro approach 2 gfx cards? good or bad? not sure what position you're taking and curious.
xenophanes··on Ask HN: I'm 15, won a grant to develop a suicide prevention app, what next?
What I would recommend next is recognizing that suicide is a complicated and controversial issue, and there are differing attitudes and approaches towards it. Your app, like it or not, will be opinionated. Have informed opinions. For example, read this:

http://www.amazon.com/Fatal-Freedom-Ethics-Politics-Suicide/...

If you disagree, fine, but have an informed opinion.

xenophanes··on Apple mail “bug” turns out to be user script after all
How do you compose plain text in reply to someone who sent both?
xenophanes··on Apple mail “bug” turns out to be user script after all
And they basically removed support for plain text email.

I haven't hit any major bugs, but my friend did. But they removed the "view different encoding" thing from the menu, or whatever it was called. Before you could switch how you view multi-format emails, and set plain text as default using a terminal command. I'm really sad to see that gone.

xenophanes··on Why a Free Society Needs a Free Money
When you take money away from someone who was saving to build a factory, so his factory is not built, then the factory doesn't produce anything, so wealth is lost.

Moving money around disruptively (via inflation or other methods) makes it harder to do economic planning and successfully do large wealth creating projects. So it does mess up wealth creation.

You say you agree with my points but you are disagreeing. Hopefully this clarifies.

A major cause of inflation is printing money.

Fractional reserve banking is basically the same thing as loans. It increases the amount of money that exists only if you ignore the amount of debt that exists. If you subtract people's debt when considering how much money they have, like you should, then nothing actually happens to the money supply.

(In practice, banking is complicated by factors like FDIC insurance. But the basic idea of borrowing money then loaning out the borrowed money, while it does come with some issues, doesn't cause inflation because loaning neither creates nor consumes money, it balances out (unless you selectively ignore half of what's happening))

xenophanes··on Why a Free Society Needs a Free Money
> Inflation does not reduce wealth.

Inflation (a jargon word that basically means printing money) transfers money from savers to debtors. This is destructive.

It's destructive because the amount of money the government will print is not fully predictable, so it creates financial risks for people who plan ahead.

It's destructive because the new money enters the economy unevenly -- and basically unpredictably and unfairly, not efficiently.

It's also destructive because it discourages savings and capital accumulation, which are important to wealth creation.

So inflation does reduce wealth, overall.

xenophanes··on Qualcomm backtracks from Apple A7 marketing gimmick comments
http://www.mikeash.com/pyblog/friday-qa-2013-09-27-arm64-and...

In short, changing architecture is big and they changed multiple things. The new architecture is 64 bit but it's actually some of the other changes that will help the most. So what Apple changed will make a substantial difference, but most of the improvement isn't well explained by saying "now we have 64 bits".

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →