HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xenophanes

3,793 karma · joined January 7, 2009

https://criticalfallibilism.com
submissionscomments
xenophanes··on How Google Sliced Away Our Knife Ads
The reason Amazon and Walmart get to do stuff is not because Google didn't notice them.

If there was some small company that got away with it, you might be right. But the issue here isn't Walmart's actions going unnoticed.

xenophanes··on Academia Is Eating Its Young
Look at the URL in the picture at the top. He did a search before doing the autocomplete.

This changes the results.

Try it. If you don't do the search for what you want to autocomplete, you will not get the same autocomplete options, in this particular case.

So he's basically posting a picture of doctored autocomplete options. If he just went to google.com and typed that in the search box, he would not get that dropdown.

xenophanes··on Apple is losing the war of words
> You're acting like an eighth grader who just discovered logical fallacies on Friday.

Your defense of your first ad hominem is an ad hominem against the HN poster who called you out for it?

sigh...

xenophanes··on What I Learned from a Sex-Crazed Short-Order Cook
There is a male cashier at my local McDonalds, so it can't be a universal rule today.

I think it sounds more like a dumb quirk of one store than corporate policy.

xenophanes··on Half of Destructoid's readers block our ads. Now what?
> This means that we're working twice as hard as other sites to sustain our company

No it doesn't, they have to deal with ad block too.

> Read more at http://www.destructoid.com/half-of-destructoid-s-readers-blo...

Maybe if you want your community to like you, don't use evil.js

> At first, it was about 10%, then 20-something. When I dared to blink it just increased faster. Over a few days it never got better, averaging at an ominous 42-46% block rate.

Why did it go up so fast? Maybe you used bad judgment and put up an ad that annoyed people?

You need to respect your users and treat them better before you get to complain.

I run ad block but i never tried to block the ads on Daring Fireball for example. Don't be one of the shady sites with crappy ads and evil.js

xenophanes··on Antibiotics and Antibiotic-Resistant Bacteria in Meat: Not Getting Better
Thomas Szasz was writing good books past 90.
xenophanes··on Browser Wars, the game
Next time you title your thing "X Wars, the game" please provide an actual game to play, not an article. False advertising :(
xenophanes··on Statement by Apple
How is it Apple's fault that Australia has accounting and tax laws that you consider ludicrous?
xenophanes··on Are Placebos Really Sugar Pills?
Then it's a rare paper that is good science. This would not really shock me but it doesn't make it any better.
xenophanes··on Are Placebos Really Sugar Pills?
They should list placebo ingredients after the trial is done so it's possible to duplicate the trial and get the same results, right?

If you don't provide enough information in your paper to repeat the experiment (and get the same results!!), then it's not good science. Good scientific studies need to be repeatable and need to provide enough information to do it.

And even if people don't want to repeat the full experiment, being able to review the details of how it was done will help them spot mistakes. You can't have things like "peer review" without saying what you did.

So this is a serious problem, even if the rest is breathless hype.

xenophanes··on How the EVE Online Servers Deal with a 3,000 Person Battle
Guild Wars 2 is stupid about this. At least on release, they stopped displaying ENEMIES FIRST. So if you're in a big enough group, a couple enemies can walk up and none of you can see them b/c you hit the limit from displaying allies, but they can still see some of you guys and kill you while invisible.

If they prioritized displaying just party members (parties only go up to 5 people) and maybe people on your friends list, and then enemies, it would have worked better.

xenophanes··on Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers
Apple, which has the highest profit margins, is on a crusade to make labor less cheap, thus lowering profit margins for everybody, which will hurt their low margin competitors much more than themselves.

I'm not saying that's their only reason but let's be careful applauding their altruism and ignoring the business merits of their policy.

BTW, also, if some Apple competitors can only exist because of the temporary cheap labor pool (one day China, India, etc will modernize a lot more. maybe it will take 50 years but it is temporary), then maybe that says something interesting about their businesses.

xenophanes··on Amazon, Apple, and the beauty of low margins
I think your take is reasonable.

That makes amazon overpriced by, what, 25%? Which is not particularly shocking. Lots of stocks are a bit overpriced. AMZN is popular. Don't buy it. Shrug.

When you compare a 3000 P/E to a 20 P/E, you might come away thinking amazon is overpriced by a factor of 100, which would be shocking. But I don't think there's any reasonable case that it's overpriced by a factor of more than 2.

xenophanes··on Amazon, Apple, and the beauty of low margins
In short, not all demand curves have a monopoly price point at which you would make more money by restricting supply (e.g. it's possible to have a demand curve where demand would fall off a cliff if price went up slightly, even if supply went to near-zero. in this case, you cannot make monopoly profits). And even if there is a monopoly price which could provide monopoly profits, it can be hard to figure out what it is and you can lose money (or even go out of business) trying to find it. Therefore, not all monopolies can lead to monopoly profits.

Quoting minimally:

http://mises.org/humanaction/chap16sec6.asp

> The special conditions and circumstances required for the emergence of monopoly prices and their catallactic features are:

> 1. There must prevail a monopoly of supply.

> 2. Either the monopolist is not in a position to discriminate among the buyers or he voluntarily abstains from such discrimination.[12]

> 3. The reaction of the buying public to the rise in prices beyond the potential competitive price, the fall in demand, is not such as to render the proceeds resulting from total sales at any price exceeding the competitive price smaller than total proceeds resulting from total sales at the competitive price.

> 4. It is a fundamental mistake to assume that there is a third category of prices which are neither monopoly prices nor competitive prices.

> 5. [some stuff about cartels]

> 6. The concept of competition does not include the requirement that there should be a multitude of competing units. [i think you will have to read further to understand this one]

> 7. If it is possible for the seller to increase his net proceeds by restricting sales and increasing the price of the units sold, there are usually several monopoly prices that satisfy this condition.

> 8. The monopolist does not know beforehand in what way the consumers will react to a rise in prices. He must resort to trial and error in his endeavors to find out whether the monopolized good can be sold to his advantage at any price exceeding the competitive price and, if this is so, which of various possible monopoly prices is the optimum monopoly price or one of the optimum monopoly prices. This is in practice much more difficult than the economist assumes when, in drawing demand curves, he ascribes perfect foresight to the monopolist. We must therefore list as a special condition required for the appearance of monopoly prices the monopolist's ability to discover such prices.

> 9. A special case is provided by the incomplete monopoly.

> 10. Duopoly and oligopoly are not special varieties of monopoly prices, but merely a variety of the methods applied for the establishment of a monopoly price.

> 11. The monopolized good by whose partial withholding from the market the monopoly prices are made to prevail can be either a good of the lowest order or a good of a higher order, a factor of production.

> 12. [discussion relating to governments intentionally encouraging monopoly]

And it goes on.

The biggest takeaway is that monopolies sometimes but not always enable higher profits by restricting supply. It's important not to assume all monopoly will enable significantly more profits than competitive market prices. Some analysis is required in any given case.

And the issue of whether and why monopoly prices are bad, and what if anything should be done about them, is considerably more complicated than "the government should prevent all monopolies" (typically with no mention of whether they are charging monopoly prices, or even could profitably do so tomorrow).

xenophanes··on Amazon, Apple, and the beauty of low margins
I think it might be fairer to look at AMZN's price to revenue ratio and compare that with other big companies which have margins AMZN might reasonably have when they start trying to make profits. That would maybe give a reasonable understanding of expected upside. Looking at their profits when they aren't trying to make a profit is a little silly.

GOOG on the other hand I think is a fair enough comparison. Actually GOOG has pretty much failed at all their attempts to make money off anything but ads, which I consider kind of worrying.

PS FYI you posted this twice and the other one is marked dead. I recommend deleting it.

xenophanes··on Amazon, Apple, and the beauty of low margins
Have you ever read about the economics of monopoly prices? E.g. in Human Action by Ludwig von Mises? It's not actually that simple and doesn't always work well.
xenophanes··on Aaron Swartz saw suicide as SOLUTION not PROBLEM
If he made a bad choice, isn't that on him (and perhaps partly on his parents/educators for how they equipped him to deal with life), not on the Government?

If he made a bad, irrational choice in this matter, I see no particular reason to assume he wasn't doing an equally bad job with the rest of his life too. So I still don't see any reason to regard the suicide in particular as the tragedy. He didn't like his life, he took the "easy way out" which may well have been a selfish choice that sucked less for himself.

As to the link, if anti-suicide people want to be effective and moral they should A) be less sure they know what's best for someone else's complicated life B) never ever use force on people who ask for their help (this fear of violence is a big reason some people don't, e.g., call suicide helplines. note that perhaps this unsuitability of such lines arguably contributed to Aaron's death -- if the world was a better more helpful and nice place he might have gotten more help that he found helpful and preferred staying in it more)

xenophanes··on Metasploit Rails 3 Remote Code Execution Hours Away
Are you maybe hitting a cached page on production that can get handled without rails being involved?
xenophanes··on Metasploit Rails 3 Remote Code Execution Hours Away
Rails 3.2.11 is OK. I upgraded a website to it and did nothing else and when I try the curl command ( curl -i -H "Content-Type: application/xml" -X POST -d '<id type="yaml">--- !ruby/object:ActionController::Base bar: 1</id>' http://example.com/ ) I see something like this in the production log:

  Hash::DisallowedType (Disallowed type attribute: "yaml"):
  activesupport (3.2.11) lib/active_support/core_ext/hash/conversions.rb:112:in `typecast_xml_value'
xenophanes··on Metasploit Rails 3 Remote Code Execution Hours Away
Thank you, very helpful.

EDIT AGAIN: I think putting it at the end of environment.rb works. I somehow messed it up and got confused, but then I tried it again and it worked. Just make sure you confirm your fix with the curl command!

xenophanes··on Metasploit Rails 3 Remote Code Execution Hours Away
So for old versions of rails 2, can someone tell me where to put this?

ActionController::Base.param_parsers.delete(Mime::XML)

if i just stick it at the bottom of environment.rb, will that work? i am not sure how to test to confirm that i've fixed it.

xenophanes··on Asian Workers Now Dominate Silicon Valley Tech Jobs
I'm white and I can get work. Maybe the other whites who have trouble should try being as skilled/awesome/smart/responsible/etc as me, or as their asian competitors.
xenophanes··on Apple - Think Twice
> So what is the point of paying the Apple premium if they are just the same as everybody else ?

OS X and increased quality of some (not all) hardware. And they do have better customer support on average.

xenophanes··on Apple - Think Twice
I had a different experience with apple. my 27" imac screen had some strong ghosting and i got it replaced near the end of the 3 years of apple care. i did this without ever visiting an apple store.

when i first phoned them, i had some low quality photos of the screen and the guy said he wasn't sure if it was really a problem. i didn't want to take a 27" imac to a store b/c i have no car and apple wouldn't send me a box. so he gave me his email address and said i could contact him any time in the future with better photos.

months later i got a new ios device with a better camera, took a larger number of pictures, emailed him the link, and he sent an on-site repair guy to give me a new screen. no problem.

i think it depends on which customer service people you talk to. some are great, some are not so good.

(the on site repair guy was great too, btw. he gave me a lesson on how to open up imacs, change stuff, and put them back together)

xenophanes··on Telomerase – Mouse lifespan extended up to 24% with single treatment (May 2012)
What is the argument the mice were living a percentage longer instead of a roughly fixed amount of time longer?
xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
I said the majority, I linked to something saying the majority.

Your mistake is no random accident. You should go learn positive things about Israel until you wouldn't make such a mistake again.

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
I've never seen a single example of a person who:

- criticizes israel in public, in ways anti-semites like to criticize israel - is not anti-semitic - does not include any clarifications in his criticism to differentiate himself from anti-semites

I think all good people know such clarifications are needed when you sound like you might be an anti-semite but actually aren't. If you leave them out, you're giving aid and comfort to anti-semitism and misleading people about your character, at best.

Note that any old clarifications won't work. Many anti-semites try to clarify how they aren't anti-semitic. A decent person would have to figure out how to say something that objectively differentiates himself. And he would care to do it if he wanted to publicly agree with the anti-semitic position on some specific point.

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
That's not what that link actually says. it doesn't say Israel as a country owns the place b/c of the (defensive) war. It argues the place has a status such that there's nothing wrong with individual israelis choosing to build homes there. it also makes some important points you left out, e.g. that trying to kick all jews out of the area would be ethnic cleansing, and that whatever you think of this issue it cannot justify terrorism.

the issue with millions of hostile persons becoming israel voters is not paralleled by any similar issue with some settlements in palestine. first, isn't the population figures of the settlements more in line with the amount of arabs already in israel than with trying to take over? second, the israel settlers are not, as a whole, hostile/violent/dangerous to have in your country, so there's no reason to mind them. palestinians, while some individuals are decent folk, as a group they are dangerous, like it or not it's simply a fact: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/01...

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
are you disputing facts like these?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/01...

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
you think saying your position being right is "well known" and that Noam Chomsky agrees is an objective, rational argument that will persuade people who don't already agree with you...?
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →