HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xg15

23,535 karma · joined February 12, 2014

submissionscomments
xg15··on Ask HN: Are tab completion models dead?
I don't know, I found AI autocomple pretty useful, e.g. if I'm coding manually, but still don't want to type tedious, repetitive log messages or other boilerplate myself.

The two Issues I saw were:

- If it says "tab completion", than that's what it should do, and not more. I eventually disabled the copilot model, not because it wasn't useful, but because VSCode's integration was overzealous and kept on suggesting all kinds of things even if I never asked for it, pulling me out of focus every time. Unlike any of their other completions, btw...

- It was not integrated with the existing completions at all, often creating chaos: The standard completions show you available classes, methods, parameters etc, in your current context, based on the information from the language server. The AI completion happily ignored the language server and showed you suggestions for nonexistent fantasy methods instead.

In general, I think acceptance of AI could be better if we offered more "lower-case AI" options, that let people offload the tedious parts of their workflow instead of taking away the entire process of creating.

As an example, there are lots of image generation models that take a short text prompt and will give you a complete finished work, making thousands of creative decisions in the process, according to their training data. Those models do not have artists as their target group - they are basically targeted at everyone but artists and replace their role. Hence the predictable backlash.

But where are the tiny, locally runnable models that, say, turn a sketch into a lineart, or apply coloring and shading according to given reference images?

xg15··on Root shell on Samsung TV
> confirmation bias, eg. "facebook is secretly listening to you"

Agreeing with your general point - don't jump to conclusions without evidence - but I don't like it if we're now establishing the "Facebook/Google/Apple/etc is secretly listening to you" rumors as the canonical example of that behavior, and thereby exempting companies from further scrutiny in this.

We've seen that by now there exists both the will and the technical means to pull off stuff like this. So even if it used to be a baseless rumor and urban legend, it deserves to be re-checked periodically, because companies might start to do it for real at some point. Samsung here actually did.

(Google also comes awfully close with its "song detector" which is now a stock Android feature I think)

xg15··on Online censorship is crushing indie webcomics
And turns out not everyone wants to allow others to see furry smut...
xg15··on Why is AI generated language so hard to understand?
This is complete speculation, but I wonder if the "thinking step by step" paradigm, when under reinforcement learning pressure, also encourages grammatically ambiguous sentences (like garden path sentences in the extreme case) that lets the model "keep its options open" until very far into the sentence.
xg15··on Wolves enter Finnish villages after Google clears 1300 acres for AI data centers
> “We look forward to maintaining an active, open dialogue with all authorities to strengthen our partnership with Finland and local organizations.”

I also like to have active, open conversations with the police after I've borrowed things from the store...

xg15··on Docker is weird
From the bits that I've looked into, the namespace, cgroup and filesystem tricks seemed relatively easy to understand - but there seems to be a whole lot of highly specific networking configuration going on (including lots of IPTables rules) that I couldn't make sense of yet.

Is there any writeup about those, or why they are there? Is this just to separate the different "networks" in a compose setup, or is there more going on?

xg15··on 'Der Viener Schlinger': The meat cannon that launched 20k hot dogs
Hah, wasn't aware of the English connotation of "ersatz". Thanks as well!

Both -satz (in the sense of set, kit or bank) and -werfer are technical terms often used for modern military equipment, so the word sounded a bit too "real" for me.

But that might just be different tastes.

"Wurstbeschleuniger" would work well, if you're ok with going scientific instead of military.

xg15··on 'Der Viener Schlinger': The meat cannon that launched 20k hot dogs
I dunno, I found the obvious, over-the-top faux-German of the original pretty hilarious, but maybe that's just me. Especially since it made the thing sound more concerning for German speakers than I imagine for English speakers. ("Schlinger" is the kind of word you'd expect in the name of a fantasy monster or WWII "Wunderwaffe"). Has some Spaceballs/Iron Sky energy to it.

But from your suggestions, "Wurstbeschleuniger" is very clever, "Wurstsatzwerfer" sounds a bit technical, "Fleischgeschütz" is um... how a german redditor might call his best piece.

xg15··on 'Der Viener Schlinger': The meat cannon that launched 20k hot dogs
I know, just found it funny :)
xg15··on 'Der Viener Schlinger': The meat cannon that launched 20k hot dogs
Well, they didn't mean "schlingen" obviously, so I guess they made up a new word :)

Vienna is probably because of Wiener Würstchen, i.e. the hot dog sausages.

xg15··on 'Der Viener Schlinger': The meat cannon that launched 20k hot dogs
> In German, “der” means “the.” “Wiener” means “of Vienna (Austria).” Although the English “to sling” probably traces back to Old Norse’s “slynja,” meaning “to hurl,” the German verb “shlingen” means “to wolf or scarf down,” as in food.

Yes, as a German, I was appropriately confused and expected some horrific contraption to get better in hot-dog eating contests or something like that.

But that's nice too.

xg15··on Constructors Shouldn't Throw
> The C++ container classes assume noexcept constructors for this reason, because creating a list of size 20 calls your constructor 20 times, and the cleanup gets so much messier.

I find it interesting that programming newbies are usually scared of C/C++ because "you have to deal with pointers" unlike in Java, Python, JavaScript etc.

It's interesting because all those languages of course use pointers and heap-allocated objects. The thing that sets the other languages apart is that they only allow pointer access and thus can make the language easier to reason about.

So what's "unusual" in C, C++ and Rust is really the parts that are not pointers, i.e. the ability to manage a data structure and its layout in memory directly, with all its consequences.

xg15··on William Gibson and the trademarking of cyberspace
"At long last, we built the Torment Nexus from the famous scifi novel 'Don't Ever Build the Torment Nexus'. We hear the author was thrilled about our thank you letter and the 10% off coupon for the TormentNexus(tm) online shop that we included!"
xg15··on How Far Will AI Assistants Go for a Refund They Can't Get?
Never thought we would get to a point where https://xkcd.com/416 becomes something to seriously think about, but here we are...
xg15··on NY announces game ownership bill requiring ownership rather than licensing
Isn't this basically an announcement of an announcement?

One senator makes a press release saying that he plans to introduce a bill protecting game ownership.

It's not clear if this bill has any chance of being voted in - and even if it does, we have no idea what is actually in the bill.

xg15··on Tell HN: Remember to migrate away from .name domain
> You might think that, obviously, both registrations stick.

I actually thought that one of the two registrations would be denied.

The only (barely) sane way I see how a registrar could offer both 2nd and 3rd level domains at the same time would be to keep them entirely separate:

Maintain two lists: One is a list of ordinary 2nd level domains that were directly sold, say something like whatsina.name.

The other would be a list of "commons" 2nd level domains that cannot be sold, because people own individual 3rd level domains on it, like doe.name above.

Which domain belongs to which list would realistically be first-come first-serve: If Jane Doe got there first and purchased doe.name, it would become a directly sold domain, and John Doe's (and also Jack Doe's) registration requests for john.doe.name and jack.doe.name would be denied.

Conversely, if John Doe got his registration for john.doe.name through first, doe.name would become a "commons" domain and Jane Doe's request would be denied, but Jack Doe's request for jack.doe.name would still get through.

Though I guess management at registrars doesn't like the phrase "cannot be sold" so I guess that wasn't how it was handled?

xg15··on Artificial intelligence is capitalism's final destination
Yeah, capitalism loves to bedazzle people with marvels, as long as it doesn't have to provide boring things like living space, food or other necessities.
xg15··on Artificial intelligence is capitalism's final destination
Unlike in the wet dreams of some economists, physical resources are finite, so if a small group aims to control the majority of them, this will directly lead to degraded living conditions for the rest. That's not envy...
xg15··on Artificial intelligence is capitalism's final destination
Written on your iPhone, made in China, a non-capitalist country...
xg15··on Simons Foundation launches $15M effort to help mathematicians navigate AI era
The joys of trickle-down economy...
xg15··on Simons Foundation launches $15M effort to help mathematicians navigate AI era
I love how "society" is investing billions to develop a tech that makes its own citizens obsolete, but doesn't manage to provide basic healthcare, housing or infrastructure...
xg15··on I know why the mathematicians weep
Because the "glorified autocomplete" crowd likes to ignore the technical detail of how the autocomplete actually works.
xg15··on I know why Mathematicians weep
The beginning of this article is decent, the end sounds like a tobacco lobbyist touting the health benefits of nicotine.

> If intelligence becomes less uniquely human, we may come to value more highly what remains uniquely human: our capacity to relate and to care for one another.

Lol. How does the author think relations between people work? (At least those outside the family). Relationships require something that fills them with meaning - a reason why you would want to have that relationship in the first place. Without meaning, no relationship.

I recommended reading this other post that was on HN earlier today: https://thetheorygirlie.substack.com/p/ai-was-great-until-it...

It describes in pretty grim words what happens to collaboration once you have nothing anymore to collaborate on.

> Mathematicians may still teach proofs, argue over what they mean, translate alien logic into human insight, and pass that understanding to students.

This would people to have time to understand and dissect those proofs - it doesn't work if there is a new breakthrough proof every week.

xg15··on The Toftwood Male Voice Choir: A Mystery Pressed in Vinyl
Yep :)
xg15··on The Toftwood Male Voice Choir: A Mystery Pressed in Vinyl
Btw, "Fijnaarts Jeugdorkest" seems to be a recording from the youth orchestra of the town of Fijnaart, Netherlands.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fijnaart

xg15··on The Toftwood Male Voice Choir: A Mystery Pressed in Vinyl
Found it a bit funny that the author became so involved with finding the people behind the record without ever listening to the actual record (or having any interest in it, really). It was really sleuthing for the sake of sleuthing.

...but at that, impressive.

xg15··on Gaming on Linux without cheating
I feel this might be the beginning of a new trend: With software becoming more malleable due to coding agents that can do reverse engineering, I could imagine that software companies in general, not just for games, will increasingly try to lock down distribution channels.

If you cannot control anymore what is being built, the desperation to try and control what is being run will only become larger.

xg15··on Gaming on Linux without cheating
If it were just used for e-sports or online multiplayer situations, I'd be fine, but there is nothing to keep game developers from using this for single player or multiplayer with friends as well, all in the name of "protecting revenue streams"...

There is also nothing from stopping other companies that have nothing to do with gaming from jumping on the bandwagon and requiring EAC Linux if it's already available.

xg15··on Gaming on Linux without cheating
> Does EAC Linux v2 use a kernel driver?

No. [...]

Does EAC Linux v2 run in the background all the time?

No. [...]

Those seem a bit misleading if the anticheat encompasses the entire operating system...

xg15··on Catch a Bird – I made it for my own sanity
Agreeing with the others, this is really cool! :)

I find it interesting that if you switch between languages on the site and the language has a local variant of the proverb, the text will have an additional paragraph explaining it.

E.g. this is the case in French, English or German, while other languages seem to fall back to the English "happy as a lark" one. (And all of them refer to the Hungarian proverb of course)

Did the translation model do that "on its own" or was that a conscious decision?

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →