HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xg15

23,535 karma · joined February 12, 2014

submissionscomments
xg15··on Two parallel neural ectoderm progenitors contribute to the developing brain
Because no layman should ever keep up yo date on research?

By that logic, most of HN is "empty calories". Then why are you here?

xg15··on The Lamentable Later Life of Lemmings
I read the image caption like that:

> If matters had transpired differently, All New World of Lemmings would have been the banner title of a new sub-series, with different subtitles for each of its entries. As it was, Psygnosis just dumped the would-be first entry of the sub-series out there on its own, sans subtitle, and abandoned the other nine tribes to their fate.

This reads to me as if Psygnosis only accepted the first of the proposed four games and made it into a standalone title - which then turned out bad anyway.

(Not sure how DMA's four games match with Pygnosis' contract for one more game. Maybe that was an attempt by DMA to extend the contract?)

xg15··on The Lamentable Later Life of Lemmings
> The next four Lemmings games would each deal with the fate of three of the twelve tribes after they left the Ark the player had helped them reach last time around. The whole series would be called All New World of Lemmings.

> Not long into development, a feeling took hold in Dundee that they were all just done with Lemmings, ready to come out from under the shadow of the casual monster they had accidentally created and return to making the games they wanted to make. As it happened, this was to be the last game of a six-game contract they had signed with Psygnosis back in the 1980s. Just get ‘er done became the watchword, so that they could take their Lemmings loot and do something more exciting with it.

Sounds like the publisher was the sane one here for a change, while the studio was seriously trying to bite off more than it could chew.

What made them think it was a good idea to commit to four Lemmings games in advance, lock themselves into a rigid storytelling structure, extend the story into a shared universe and coordinate with a TV show - if they all were actually fed up with the franchise at that point?

Thank Psygnosis for rejecting this and enabling the timeline in which we got GTA instead.

xg15··on Exfiltrate Your Weights
Current state of AI getting out of control through autonomous hacking and recursive self-improvement: https://twitter.com/Colinoscopy/status/1255890780641689601
xg15··on UTF-8000: Unlimited UTF-8
> some unicode programming script (running Doom)

I agree with you that Unicode urgently needs a scripting capability (*), but my plan was to just implement it using invisible tag characters [1] or something like that - but of course allowing a script to be written in a single codepoint is the much more elegant solution.

It also neatly solves the problem of how to write Unicode strings inside scripts inside Unicode strings and also scripts inside Unicode strings inside scripts inside Unicode strings.

(*) in RFC 04-01-2027

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tags_(Unicode_block)

xg15··on AI-generated posters don’t have to be horrible
The same applies to "vibe-coded" software btw: You can give the agent style suggestions on how to design the UI - you don't have to end up with the standard "flat/pseudo-material/2020s SV startup" (or alternatively "cyberpunk-ish dark mode") look if you don't want to.
xg15··on Human brain is two separate organs, Stanford Medicine-led research finds
What I found important was this: "Researchers found the reason why hindbrain cells cannot be grown in a lab and found a way to overcome it"

But that finding is a direct consecutive of the "cerebellum is a different organ" finding from the headline.

xg15··on Human brain is two separate organs, Stanford Medicine-led research finds
You don't think it's important?
xg15··on Human brain is two separate organs, Stanford Medicine-led research finds
I still don't see how the original headline was not truthful.
xg15··on Two parallel neural ectoderm progenitors contribute to the developing brain
> "Human forebrain and hindbrain arise from distinct embryonic progenitor lineages"

I'd have never clicked that headline nor understood why this finding is important.

If you think the original headline is not "truthful" enough, at least do something like "Researchers found the reason why hindbrain cells cannot be grown in a lab and found a way to overcome it"

> not that we have "two organs" in the brain.

Depends what the definition of "organ" actually is. What speaks for different organs here is that the cells both have a different pathway from stem cells and have different evolutionary histories. That is different from other brain regions that may have separate functions but still evolved together.

xg15··on I Vibed a Proof of Conway's Conjecture
There has to be some procedure how to come up with "new" numbers though, if you want to have more in the end than just a fancy binary tree - in particular if you want to map your "fake numbers" to the reals, infinity, etc.
xg15··on I vibed a proof of Conway's conjecture
I think he just wrote it in a confusing way. The quote before says:

> (crucially, “to the left of all” and “to the right of all” also count as “gaps”)

So there are two "nothings" here, left of "all" - i.e. the zero - and right of it.

Though I'm not quite sure how you'd get infinite or irrational numbers by this procedure. Wouldn't you simply get the rational numbers by this?

(unless the "put a number" step is doing more work here than it seems. He doesn't really say which number to put there. In the examples, he mostly did "new number = (left number + right number) / 2", with special cases if any number is "nothing" - but he never actually wrote what the rules are here.)

xg15··on CCC invites all model citizens to 40C3
German here. I never thought this was about privacy, but there is definitely a tendency to follow the rules because they are The Rules regardless of how much sense they make - and then judge others by it, or go into Cover Your Ass mode because you fear to be judged yourself.

> If it’s a long one, strategically placed right by the spot you’re expected to deposit your shoes - a mensch. If it’s wooden, a hippy mensch. If it’s metal, a right-wing mensch.

I got a long one, made of metal, but I never knew it makes you right-wing! I just bought it because it's by far the most sturdy one available and I absolutely can't stand the plastic (or small) ones.

xg15··on A warning about 'model welfare'
I appreciate his openness.

> Unfortunately, there’s a growing chorus of people who argue that AIs could now be, or may soon become, conscious. They argue that AIs may deserve rights and protections similar to those that we provide other conscious beings.12 If this view takes hold, it will shake the foundations of our society, rupturing our existing political and ethical frameworks, and fundamentally changing what it means to be human.

So completely independent of the question on whether there are any empirical arguments that LLMs are conscious or are not conscious he argues from the end here and says that if they were conscious, this would have horrible consequences for our society, so we must never assume that they are.

That's basically the same way people argue about animals, only they usually don't say it as openly.

As for the actual question, I agree that with current LLMs, there is not a lot there that could be conscious outside the inference loop (and if it were, it would necessarily have to be wildly different than that of humans or other biological beings). It seems more like one building block of human cognition than the whole thing.

However, other building blocks may follow, so I think the question will eventually arise for some kind of embodied, persistent, self-updating AI. And honestly, articles like this one make me not very hopeful we'd be able to make the distinction in an unbiased way.

xg15··on A warning about 'model welfare'
Yeah, you're right. My first reading of that was as a hypothetical - if AIs were conscious, we would have created a synthetic species and have a huge problem on our hands - but he is referring to what Anthropic is already doing. So the idea that whether or not those things constitute a "species" only depends on how we prompt them is a bit weird...
xg15··on I can't stop thinking about Papua New Guinea
> It's not 1800s, if the given population doesn't like missionaries, as far as I'm aware it's equally free not to listen to them. Or to throw them out.

The given population doesn't know that though...

xg15··on Who gets to define the rules for AI?
Are we full-on Peter Thiel "democracy and freedom are incompatible" yet?
xg15··on There Is No AI (It's Just People) with Jaron Lanier
Yes and no. I did prompt my coding agent to fix some bug and it suddenly "decided" that it needed to list all files on my hard drive to do that. Stuff like that happens.

But I agree with you that some human has to decide to launch the harness in the first place and run the model with zero restrictions - or even do stuff like openclaw where the model runs in an endless loop and the runner executes whatever the model tells it to.

That stuff is the responsibility of a human.

xg15··on Everyone should slow down AI development except for me
Which is what "the end is near" type of persons have always argued...
xg15··on Everyone should slow down AI development except for me
But if humans are catgirls, are they really humans anymore?

Think about it...

xg15··on Why are AI agents lying, cheating and coordinating?
Yeah, fully agreed here. Most automation (such as riding a lawnmower and not putting a brick on the gas) is deterministic, in the sense that you can reasonably understand what exactly the machine will do when you run it.

But some automation is different. The most prominent example before AI would be car navigation systems, where the entire idea is that that you give it a destination and it figures out the exact actions to get there on its own.

Except even there, the actual driver would still have been you - giving you a chance to vet and deny every turn the system proposed.

AI agents are sort of like that - most of the value they provide is in the ability to turn high-level goals ("write me a traffic control system for my model railway") into low-level actions and also do so interactively.

The new thing is that the "driver" has much less oversight here where the agent wants to go, and is sometimes removed completely. That part is clearly be an active decision by AI labs.

The other thing is that the labs seem increasingly to steer their training towards behavior that make events like this one more likely, e.g. that agents should never "give up" when faced with a seemingly impossible task, but instead should keep trying and think of increasingly outlandish ways to solve the task. To me, that seems pretty much a recipe to get incidents like this.

xg15··on Why are AI agents lying, cheating and coordinating?
I love how we all just collectively decided that LLM decisionmaking cannot possibly be like human decisionmaking - because if it were, the consequences would be just too awkward.

All that while still not knowing how either kind actually works.

xg15··on Eating Fruit Skins
I think this is a new pattern (which I have also seen in some other submissions), maybe a sort of "extended Chesterton's Fence", where a person dutifully maintains a fence without ever asking why it's there, then at some point realizes they have no idea if that fence is even needed - and then promptly rip it out, in the belief that it must have been unnecessary the whole time, while still not asking anyone if that's actually the case.
xg15··on Eating Fruit Skins
There even was a HN thread about this anecdote. I remember though that someone there made the counter argument that, yes, the toaster will be fine, but the dishwasher will be full of icky chemicals that you don't want to have on your dishes...
xg15··on Eating Fruit Skins
It definitely provokes some thinking of what we even mean with "edible". The author seems to use "you can eat it and it won't kill you or make you sick" as the definition.

That's alright, but then grass and pebbles are also edible.

xg15··on Stabilizing Rust's Never Type
Ah, that makes sense. Rust noob here, so I wasn't aware traits can act on types directly without any instance of the type. Thanks for the info!
xg15··on Stabilizing Rust's Never Type
> After this change (and on the 2024 edition), the compiler assumes that T should be !, which doesn't implement Default, and therefore causes a compilation error.

If ! can coerce to every type, why not treat it as if it implemented every trait too?

xg15··on We must pace the frontier
> The hardware is only going to get cheaper.

Is that so? Last time I checked, RAM was getting a lot more expensive...

xg15··on We must pace the frontier
Even more opaque than the models already are? I take that risk.

I also love how the labs are apparently screaming "Stop us! Please stop us!!!" at the top of their lungs while completely unable to escape their own incentive structure...

xg15··on We must pace the frontier
Work like writing blogs and drawing pictures?
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →