HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xorfish

857 karma · joined December 30, 2016

submissionscomments
xorfish··on Coronavirus clue? Most cases aboard U.S. aircraft carrier are symptom-free
They would need to collect data again now to get a better result. Otherwise the data is the same as on the day the test was made.
xorfish··on Coronavirus clue? Most cases aboard U.S. aircraft carrier are symptom-free
If the virus spreads exponentially, you would expect most cases to be presymptomatic at any given time.
xorfish··on Chernobyl wildfires and radiation risk
There was also much less radiation that got out in the Fukushima accident.

Levels are so low, that you can't make predictions that are bases on real data. You can only extrapolate the cancer risk from higher doses.

Every coal and gas plant does around the same harm as a Fukushima accident every year if you look at the deaths they cause.

https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy

xorfish··on The Metric We Need to Manage Covid-19
That is not what we see. Mortality for 65+ is way above the baseline because of covid19.
xorfish··on The Metric We Need to Manage Covid-19
Best data is excess mortality.

Many deaths won't be attributed to covid19 but still caused by it.

Here an explanation:

https://twitter.com/firefoxx66/status/1249996541424816128

xorfish··on DP-3T/Documents: Decentralized Privacy-Preserving Proximity Tracing
I really hope Google and Apple will implement the proposed protocol from DP-3T and give audited and open source apps more control over how the contact tracing is done.
xorfish··on DP-3T/Documents: Decentralized Privacy-Preserving Proximity Tracing
Some of the attacks seem to be high cost, low payoff.

Have you read the newer version?

There is a new proposal that would protect against most of these attacks.

xorfish··on Leakage paths for the Apple / Google Bluetooth tracing system
Have you taken a closer look at the technology?

https://github.com/DP-3T/documents

The nice thing about this technology is, that it will stop working as soon as there are no more cases.

xorfish··on Leakage paths for the Apple / Google Bluetooth tracing system
Is it really worth it to track 0.1-1% of the population for a few days?

I don't really see how this level of investment is worth it.

I'm also not sure as to how widespread it has to be, with the 2. proposal from DP-3P, you won't be able to link EPIDs, so you would need to infer the new infected epids from the last known position. That seems only feasible if there are sensors everywhere.

xorfish··on A Smart Plan to End the U.S. Lockdown Arrives Just in Time
You exchange a one time id with each close proximity.

If you test positive, you publish your recorded close proximities ids on a public server. Authorities can supply you with a one time tocken with the test result to append said server.

There are certanly more efficient and elegant ways to solve this problem, but it is solvable.

xorfish··on A Smart Plan to End the U.S. Lockdown Arrives Just in Time
You don't need surveilance. All recorded contacts can be stored locally and only informed once a positive test is returned.

More information here:

https://www.pepp-pt.org/

xorfish··on Covid-19 Sanity – Covid-19 papers from bioRxiv/medRxiv searchable and sortable
The number of people that are infected doesn't tell you that much about R0. You can get R0 from the increase in daily new deaths and the generation time between infections, given that the quality of care stays constant.

Serological tests will tell you something about the early outbreak and how many cases where not detected and how high the infected fatality ratio really is.

I have seen many people that still believe that the IFR is in the range of an average flu. With the data from South Korea, we can put a number at what we can expect the IFR to be if we make some optimistic assumptions.

That is why I say that you should not expect that serological tests show that a large part of the population already had covid19 and that the IFR is much lower than we expect. They will show where exactly the IFR is.

xorfish··on Usage of Masks “Flattened” Growth of Coronavirus Cases in Czech Republic
It would certainly be a failure if it is communicated that mask wearing prevents you from getting infected. They reduce the risk of infecting others more than they reduce the risk of getting infected.

A 20% reduction in infection risk is already substantial and worth it. If there is a 50% reduction in infecting others, mask use alone could replace most social distancing measures.

xorfish··on Usage of Masks “Flattened” Growth of Coronavirus Cases in Czech Republic
Experts devise do-it-yourself face masks to help people battle coronavirus:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNjpH5lBZ8w

xorfish··on Covid-19 Sanity – Covid-19 papers from bioRxiv/medRxiv searchable and sortable
This will be important information in a few months when countries have lowered the new detected cases and the lift of harsh measures is considered. So there is still some time to get the data. At the current moment, they are not important for the decisions.

However I want to caution anyone to expect a large proportion of the population to test positive in these tests.

We know that South Korea was able to contain the spread before a significant proportion of the population was infected. A important part of the strategy was contact tracing. For contact tracing to work, you need to detect at least 1-1/R of cases. If we assume that other measures such as masks and limited social distancing pushed R down to 2 and assume they were able to trace 100% of contacts, then we still have only twice as many that are infected. If nobody of the cases that are still ongoing dies, we look at a lower bound of the IFR of 0.8%.

xorfish··on Italy and South Korea virus outbreaks reveal disparity in deaths and tactics
New cases in SK are on a downward trend for around 10 days now. They achieved a reproduction value that is quite a bit below for at least the last 3 weeks.
xorfish··on Covid-19 update and guidance to limit spread
So 22% don't have any vaccation.That is insane.

If the sick leave is limited, it isn't worth much.

38% without any sick leave is already pretty bad. How many of the rest can take 14-21 days of payed sick leave?

xorfish··on The Virus
There are quite a few universal vaccines in the works. The window for a truly horrific pandemic is closing.

https://gcgh.grandchallenges.org/challenge/ending-pandemic-t...

xorfish··on SARSCoV2 cell entry depends on ACE2 and TMPRSS2, blockable by protease inhibitor
A false negative doesn't make a reinfection.

There are going to be a lot of still positive people that test negative with a test that has a high enough false negative rate.

xorfish··on Switzerland Federal Council bans large-scale events
Switzerland has the capability to run 1'000 tests per day right now, they currently are not at the limit for testing.
xorfish··on The war on food waste is a waste of time
Meat doesn't require farmland, it will be produced in ordinary factories in a few years.
xorfish··on The wear patterns of jeans aren’t good forensic evidence
The key is to only use evidence in court that was not used to identify the perpetrator.

If a piece of evidence is used to identify, you select for the population that matches that property.

xorfish··on CDC declined to test new coronavirus patient for days, California hospital says
The problem in such cases is the prior. If a false positive is 10%, 1%, 0.1% or 0.01% makes a huge difference. With 0.01% and two different tests, you will get a false positive in every 100'000'000 tests. Testing twice solves many of the issues. It also gives information about the sensitivity and specificity of a test.
xorfish··on Calculating Pi: My Attempt at Breaking the Pi World Record
Heat pumps are quite a bit more efficient than electric heaters.
xorfish··on Screens Are Bad for Young Brains
There are so many factors that influence child development and media use. I don't think it is even possible to properly control for them.

How can you for example control for the believe that they are bad? Better parents will have more success reducing the metrics that are believed to be bad than other parents. How can you control for the rising philosophy?

I'm especially skeptical about the claim about ADHD and that games are bad. There is lots of evidence that games, especially of competitive nature like shooters or strategy games, improve cognitive functions. ADHD is to a large degree heritable and influences all kinds of behavior. I think it is by far more realistic that ADHD would influence screen use and not the other way around.

xorfish··on Screens Are Bad for Young Brains
Did the study only compare differences between siblings?

There are so many studies that are wortless because they don't controll for the environment.

Besides there is quite a bit of evidence that games and especially competitive games are good for the brain.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/freedom-learn/201502...

xorfish··on Screens Are Bad for Young Brains
last time I looked there wasn't much evidence for breastfeeding when you controlled for other factors.

https://www.wbur.org/commonhealth/2014/02/28/sibling-study-f...

xorfish··on China's role in the U.S. fentanyl epidemic
Switzerland had a open heroin epidemic around 30 years ago.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3UYmaalotK0

Repression only made it worse and I can only imagine how much worse it would have been with the possibility that every shot may have something far more potent.

Maybe the important bit is also how it was resolved:

https://www.thelocal.ch/20120531/3427

In short, save injection sites, controlled diaphin or other opioid replacement therapies made the life of addicts livable and reduced the harm that happened.

xorfish··on Is Recycling a Waste of Time?
I don't know, but it seems to be a mostly us problem. Many European countries are quite a bit better when it comes to recycling.

The most important thing is to separate the different materials as early as possible. Aluminum, paper, cardboard, PET and other plastic bottles and glass has to be separated by the consumer.

Waste that can't be recycled can still be burned to gain energy and reduce the impact and space it uses. Landfills are much worse and probably cost more over the long run anyway.

xorfish··on Twitter says an attacker used its API to match usernames to phone numbers
You can also match phone numbers and Instagram accounts
← PreviousPage 8 of 14Next →