HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yanmaani

591 karma · joined November 28, 2021

submissionscomments
yanmaani··on Who cares about plagiarism?
Grant that the obsession people have with citing everything - even basic stuff that everyone knows, like old poetry - is quite absurd. Just put it in italics or quotation marks or something. Either people are smart enough to figure it out, or they're too stupid.

That being said, I think there is the broader issue of discoverability. As a practical matter, it's very convenient, if I have a paper on X, that I can look at the citations and get good links to resources on Y. This isn't really a matter of making the author of this or that paper happy either, it's about giving the reader some useful information.

And I just don't see how to replicate that without citations.

That's not to say the social science style (Davis, 1953) isn't obnoxious, though - there it really seems (Johnson, 2010) to be more about name-dropping the big guys (Smith, 2007), than about putting a small unobtrusive number in a superscript.

yanmaani··on State of the Web: Static Site Generators
What is a "md5 file"?
yanmaani··on State of the Web: Static Site Generators
Yeah, there exist a few like that for WordPress, I know a few big sites use them. I think Simply Static <https://wordpress.org/plugins/simply-static/> is pretty popular?
yanmaani··on Show the case against
Money is not "literally worthless"; the state guarantees that you can use them to pay your debts, by cancelling all debts that you pay using dollars, whether your creditor agrees to it or not.
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
For example, by raising the new registration price to $1,000,000,000. Then, the DAO can register it at zero cost (it will get 100% of the fee refunded instantly), but anybody else would have to pay sticker price.

I believe there's also more complex schemes, where you directly restrict who can register it, but I'm not sure about those.

yanmaani··on Royal Society cautions against censorship of scientific misinformation online
That's ... not true? Children can learn a basic model of the greenhouse effect in school, and do so in most civilized nations. Whether this is sufficient is another thing entirely, but I would personally contend that (non-propaganda) education can never be 100% effective at causing someone to believe something?
yanmaani··on Substack gives rise to a literary rebirth
This is just a link to a substack; did you mean to link to an article?
yanmaani··on Naomi Wu video demonetized on YouTube
> modern science suggests that god probably doesn't exist

Huh? From my understanding, "science" has had the same perspective on this since like forever: it's unfalsifiable either way, but both explanations are at least self-consistent. There's no smoking gun against either side, and so it all depends on your priors.

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Yes, but that doesn't work if what you're voting on is consensus-critical (e.g. the ordering of blocks). If you're talking about other rule changes, sure. In practice, I think most would consider Bitcoin's sluggishness of rule changes to be a feature, not a bug. Because the process is not entirely deterministic, it is much harder for a bad actor to corrupt.
yanmaani··on Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates
People stop patronizing bars, restaurants, shops, etc, instead spend their leisure time/money/etc on infinitely more scalable digital services. Beyond imagination?
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
> Half the post is about Bitcoin.

Yes, because Bitcoin is an actually working, properly designed system used by people for real-world ends.

> A large chunk is about the ENS token distribution

That would be two lines just below "Which one is ENS?", plus the image text?

> There's no link to any of the contracts or code.

What is there you want me to link to, specifically? I mean, I suppose I could give a source for "they could crank up the fee for renewing only your name to $1,000,000,000, and then allocate it to whomever they please once it expires" if you insist. But this is not contentious, surely? Is there any specific contract or code you think the article would be improved by linking to?

> There's no comparison with existing providers

Unstoppable Domains is arguably even less serious, Handshake doesn't allow you to own domains at the second level but is otherwise solid, [project] is good but there is a conflict of interest associated with me promoting it, MoneroDNS and Emercoin seem all right but I haven't looked into them deeply.

> the trade-offs

The trade-offs only exist because ENS exists as a "crypto-asset," the governance of which has to be freely traded on the open market for the economic structure to work. If ENS wouldn't have the purpose of making a profit for the insiders, there wouldn't be any reason to make all of these strange trade-offs in the first place.

When you sacrifice censorship-resistance and decentralization, what is it that you get in exchange? What are you trading it for?

> There's no discussion on how DAOs are still very immature and evolving.

How do you expect them to "evolve" in the future? Is there a specific issue that will be solved in a certain way, or is it like Proof of Stake, where "new developments" at an unspecified point in the future are supposed to fix all the problems, so you shouldn't ask too much tricky questions today?

> There's no acknowledgement of how ENS has behaved since inception.

Well, I note that ENS made direct lies about their decentralization status prior to November 10, 2021, I note that ENS publicly announced their intention to censor if required, and I note that a few hundred keyholders is better than seven.

Is there something else you think I should acknowledge?

> Flash loan voting? Clueless.

Does ENS have some special precaution against this? Or is it simply outside of the threat model?

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Can or will?
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Proof of stake has a very specific definition. In Bitcoin, it's possible for a client to bootstrap with only knowledge of protocol rules. This is not possible in a proof of stake cryptocurrency, which also requires a trusted third party.
yanmaani··on The window to deploy surveillance-resistant systems is running out
Tor seems to do okay in Russia. Maybe not stellar, but in practice, it seems to work fine. Same for Signal and all this other stuff.
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
I can flash loan 0.4% of the supply from Uniswap right now. I need 1% for quorum. Is my math off?
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Is that always true, or just in some cases?

For example, a website hosting child pornography I think would be quite detrimental to the value of the project. Would the ENS holders seek to maximize their economic value, or "property rights"? Or is child porn good for business?

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
It's the economic majority - an exchange or a merchant has a lot of economic influence, some guy with a VPS almost zero.
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
If I borrow 51% of the outstanding supply, how much skin do I have in the game? What if I buy $100 million worth of ENS, while simultaneously shorting it on DeFi?

What if I tell people that if they vote for my proposal, I'll raid the Community Treasury and bribe them with the money I get from that? Do they have skin in the game? And if so, which game?

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Bitcoin doesn't have any keys to throw away. How is Bitcoin doing?
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Of course, but what happens when they selectively raise the renewal fee for your domain to $500 quadrillion? (Also, what prevents them from changing the controller back, if they have 51%?)
yanmaani··on The impact of hardware specifications on reaching quantum advantage
> wouldn't gaining access to everyone's wallets render it useless since BTC would no longer have value

It would only be useful for the wallets with known public keys. That's mainly old bitcoins, new ones only have its hash written to the chain.

This would certainly crash the price, but not to zero.

> Also, wouldn't we be able to restore everyone's wallets from the latest snapshot on a new blockchain?

Yes, but what good will it do you if the private key is leaked?

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Yes (actually, it would only have to be a soft fork), but that would require serious coordination. Ethereum has done it before, so it's not literally impossible, but it would require the whole of the Ethereum network to do it, not just the ENS people.

If it did happen, it would raise serious questions about the nature of the decentralization of Ethereum, and how suitable it is as a deterministic platform to build stuff on. Then again, it already happened and nobody seemed to really care.

If Ethereum is willing to fork over X, what's to say they're not willing to fork over Y? And the answer to this question is probably to do with "the big guys with the money at the top like X, but not Y". So much for decentralization.

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Why does this need a DAO? Why does someone have to "own" it? They could just have it be run by the smart contract without human intervention.
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
For enough money, they might. If I'm not mistaken, the "community treasury" has 50% of all ENS. This comes to 0.5 * 100MM = 50MM ENS. At current exchange rates (assuming no slippage), that comes to $17.92 * 50,000,000 = $896,000,000.

I'm assuming ICANN approved all this gTLD nonsense because they like the money. This naturally raises the question: how much money would they need to approve this? And is it more or less than $0.9 billion dollars?

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
It may very well be better in relative terms. After all, arsenic is clearly better for your health than strychnine. But neither is especially good, now is it?
yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Even if you control 70% of hashrate, that doesn't mean you can just do anything. You still have to abide by the rules. You can't approve invalid transactions or directly steal people's money, only re-order past transactions.

This is in contrast to ENS, where the equivalent of a 51% attack allows you to do just that - steal names, change registration parameters, basically anything.

Furthermore, in PoW coins, 51% attacks are fleeting by nature - they usually only run for a short time. Compare this to ENS, where if you get 51% control once, you can give yourself 100% control for perpetuity, because you can execute arbitrary code on the smart contract.

yanmaani··on Will charging for posts lead to higher social media content quality?
If you insist: There's a difference between destitute and poor. Someone working as a janitor with a unimpressive but acceptable salary, who has to pinch pennies to make ends meet, can still be a good poster. (Anecdotally, a lot of good Twitter posters seem to have lots of problems with student debt and the like.)

Obviously, it's not literally illegal. But it seems like you're not going to filter just for people who can afford to pay $1/month, but for people who are dumb enough to actually do it. Some rich people have interesting things to say; few (no?) rich people dumb enough to purchase money JPEG avatars do.

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
I mean, these days you have the DAO. So on the positive side, it's not 4 of 7 people anymore. But on the negative side, it's theoretically anyone, depending on how badly they messed up the code, concentration of ownership, and other economic/social factors.

You also have the problems that it's all resolved through a centralized service, in practice. So if Infura gets a court order to NXDOMAIN thepiratebay.eth, that's pretty much good night.

yanmaani··on No, Ethereum Name Service is still a clown show
Thank you!
yanmaani··on Core library of Arbitrum, currently securing $2.7B, appears to be nonfree
What do you expect? The purpose is to get quick, flashy results. Nobody is bothered to check this stuff.

Also, "$2.7B" is a highly suspect figure. There's no saying if you could actually cash out anywhere close to that amount.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →