HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yeahforsureman

224 karma · joined March 19, 2017

submissionscomments
yeahforsureman··on Magistral — the first reasoning model by Mistral AI
Are you sure?

The ePrivacy Directive requires a (GDPR-level) consent for just placing the cookie, unless it's strictly necessary for the provision of the “service”. The way EU regulators interpret this, even web analytics falls outside the necessity exception and therefore requires consent.

So as long as the user doesn't and/or is not able to automatically signal consent (or non-consent) eg via general browser-level settings, how can you obtain it without trying to get it from the user on a per-site basis somehow? (And no, DNT doesn't help since it's an opt-out, not an opt-in mechanism.)

yeahforsureman··on Apple introduces a universal design across platforms
Tsk, tsk! You're using thorn (ð) for two different 'th' sounds. Old English used 'eth' (þ) to mark both sounds but it'd be more precise to use both letters like in Icelandic, eg for the above: þings, ðe (although the vowel in 'the' is actually more of a schwa [ǝ] usually, or [i] before vowels). Also, you're still sticking to some English spelling pecularities there...

In a fictitious modern, phonology-based spelling system, you could write the above something like:

“Bat sač þings gou in sajkls, änd wan dej ðí Ingliš längwidž wil bí simplifajd.”

;)

yeahforsureman··on Apple introduces a universal design across platforms
Disagree on almost all points. Glass and the relative absence of color, texture and patterns make it look cold, detached, almost inhuman and absent of anything your eyes could rest on. There are ways to make this approach look cool and futuristic, but it suffers from the same downside as a lot of the white/glassy modernist architecture: the human eye abhors lack of detail and natural/organic patterns and texture. (It makes for a great canvas for graffitti though...)

Meanwhile, Android's Material You/Expressive design language is taking almost an opposite approach. Personally, I prefer it to Liquid Glass by a wide margin.

yeahforsureman··on How prestige outlets get away with copypasta
I think you Americans should stick to calling this group as liberals or move to progressives where appropriate (identity politics, woke "ideology" etc.), and leave "left" to those who can still perceive it as a somewhat coherent concept in their politics (although perhaps every day less so). What I mean is just that if you toned down their woke/progressive evangelism and posing, the Democrats would be a firmly center-right party in large parts of western and central continental Europe, for example.
yeahforsureman··on How prestige outlets get away with copypasta
I get the problem. Wouldn't say it applies equally to other outlets. RT is very specifically a single-state propaganda tube, while a lot of Western press could perhaps be characterized as vaguely Atlanticist and pretty pro-globalization. But I'm not sure whether this was what you meant exactly by power centers.

Would they need more categories, then? Like geo-political orientation and state influence (although the latter would often be close to the press freedom rating)?

yeahforsureman··on How prestige outlets get away with copypasta
Probably the same scale, although you can understand that in several ways. In any case, they clearly use the American typology, conflating the liberal-conservative axis with left-right. So it's next to impossible to tease out how left or right a publication is on more traditional markers, such as economic policy, in particular, but also labour issues, ideological orientation (e.g. Marxist/Social Democrat/Third Way/Social Liberal, or an even more mixed crowd on the right) etc.
yeahforsureman··on The enigmatic Portuguese R (2013)
Totally forgot the most obvious ones! I think "the" and "thing" are difficult to some degree for most non-English speakers. Actually, languages that have those both or something very close naturally are very rare. Only Icelandic comes to mind. And then peninsular Spanish, Galician, Albanian, Greek and many Arabic dialects have the "thing" at least.

Of all the approximates people use for "the", the soft Latin "d" is quite close to the original, compared to, say, the Franco-German "ze"! Even here in Finland, we are quite fluent in English as such but many completely disregard the difference brought by the "h" in both phonemes, and just aspirate the "t" like you would do without the "h" (and then pronounce the other t's softly without aspiration at all!).

It's all comprehensible as long as its regular, I guess. Still, as an elementary Spanish speaker, I still often get distracted by the Brazilian r's, since instead of "r", I hear the Spanish "jota" or otherwise something I would describe as in the range of h-like sounds, not r's.

yeahforsureman··on The enigmatic Portuguese R (2013)
How well do you cope then with e.g. Germanic and Eastern European features (such as vowels ä, ö, ü/y, y/ы and schwa, difficult consonant clusters, and short/long vowels and consonants independent of stress)?
yeahforsureman··on LLVM relicensing update and call for help
Looks like the moral rights regime in Australia is pretty similar to that in many civil law systems. You cannot just revoke your license based on the right of integrity. Where do you get that idea from? Based on the introduction, it works just like in most other systems: you would have to show derogatory treatment. And that, considering the nature of the work (computer code committed to an open source project), seems to be hard if not impossible in any conceivable circumstances.
yeahforsureman··on LLVM relicensing update and call for help
Apache-2.0 has corporate-friendly patent clauses missing from most other permissive licenses.
yeahforsureman··on LLVM relicensing update and call for help
Or lacking adequate case law, that's what the FSF et al. would want you to believe, anyhow. Although a bit vaguely drafted in this respect, the copyleft effect of GPL depends on the concept of a derivative work under copyright law. It would be a bit far-fetched to claim that in your example, the combination of the function and the codebase is a derivative of the function you incorporated.

Anyway, because the fact that people think GPL is that extensive is enough to create unnecessary problems, I too prefer MPL, where the copyleft scope is defined very clearly for its use case.

yeahforsureman··on CNN goes first two weeks of October without any program reaching 1M viewers
What's this obsession with ivermectin? I'm not American, so sincerely wondering.
yeahforsureman··on DoD Awards $1B Contract to Peraton to Counter Misinformation
Funny, "perätön" in Finnish means "unfounded", "baseless". I have a hard time believing this is a co-incidence.
yeahforsureman··on Assange case: Key witness admits he lied
Yeah, for sure.
yeahforsureman··on When will we get secure desktop OSes? (2018)
I would not recommend this article if you can't handle a load of New York pasta nerdiness before getting to the SAUCE, capisci?
yeahforsureman··on Self hosting is important
Regarding [1], do you know Brazilian law? I don't. In any case, the right to not incriminate yourself has been widely adopted, and in principle, could perhaps be invoked here, too.
yeahforsureman··on Assange case: Key witness admits he lied
I just now looked and noticed the journalist interviewed here also tells about his participation in a small pro-Assad info op, too, i.e., a bit of Douma denialism, an old Grayzone (or should I say Roublezone) favorite. Disgusting how low the Exile(d) has fallen.
yeahforsureman··on Assange case: Key witness admits he lied
I still remember when The Exiled were openly derisive of Assange. Now that they represent the same scene of broadly tankie-ish anti-American populism (not speculating on their reasons or connections to any regimes...), it seems it's a love affair.
yeahforsureman··on Assange case: Key witness admits he lied
True, although this has little to do with the issues of fair trial and trial coverage.
yeahforsureman··on “I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases as BSD”
No need to re-explain, I understood you well enough. Not trying to make fun of you either, it's just funny you end up calling restrictive something which is widely known as "permissive". Of course, it's called permissive because it contains maximal rights with little requirements for someone you would probably call the "first" user.

> So the tree of descendants of an originally "permissively" licensed code contains potentially more restrictions, that the tree of descendants of originally GPL licensed code.

I think the number of users should count as well. A proprietary application distributed to millions results, in a way, in more "freedom" of use (albeit of a thinner scope) compared to a GPL'd application rarely used or distributed.

> This is, as you rightly noted, not how modern business models function.

Some do, some don't. See e.g. Carlo Daffara on open source business models.

yeahforsureman··on “I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases as BSD”
I agree and thought that was well-conveyed, but guess not.
yeahforsureman··on Console Do Not Track – Proposal for a standard environment variable
If you think GDPR always requires consent, you would be wrong. Consent is just one of many possible legal bases, and usually the one you use only when you can't use any of the rest. In this case, and more widely, it's not at all clear which types of personal data processing do or do not require consent.
yeahforsureman··on “I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases as BSD”
What if that "bad" is insignificant compared to the good produced by that code as part of proprietary software? That scenario is impossible with GPL. Effectively, you're just restricting the business models of your users. It has worked for some projects (Linux above all) but if you're talking about a small project that likely stays small, I don't know if it usually makes much sense.

Also, your convoluted explanation of why permissive licenses should be called "restrictive" is hilarious.

yeahforsureman··on Saudi Arabia executes Mustafa al-Darwish for teenage protests
I see the hypocrisy. But you didn't mean to downplay the the very real human rights violations of the Belarusian regime, right?
yeahforsureman··on EU countries team up for semiconductor push
Not my experience. Away from some parts of Eastern and Southern Europe for lack of opportunities, but generally out of EU, no.

And anyway, if your kid goes to college, he or she is very likely to be of legal age and have, like, opinions of their own. Yet you make it sound like you're raising cattle for yourself or something.

yeahforsureman··on Slack stores browser cookies without user consent
The part of GDPR that gets applied here is the general standard for obtaining consent. It's very high-level stuff... So, without very specific case law, it's hard to say. The requirement that it should be as easy to revoke consent as it is to give one certainly resembles your argument.
yeahforsureman··on MacOS-like Fonts on Manjaro/Arch Linux
At least Linux and Windows shortcuts are easier to remember as they start with basically words, not a combination of weird symbols you never learn cause you never look at them (cause who looks at the keyboard when they type).
yeahforsureman··on Data Broker Opt-Out List
"It is your responsibility under GDPR not to store information about me without my explicit consent..."

Not commenting on the particulars of this case (you might be right in this particular instance), as a general statement this is not true. Consent is only one of several possible legal grounds for processing personal data. Generally, data controllers want to avoid it if possible in lieu of more convenient grounds. Nitpicking more, explicit consent is mentioned only as a processing ground for so called special category data, i.e. certain sensitive data, e.g. health data, requiring an additional legal ground.

yeahforsureman··on Zoom closes account of U.S.-based Chinese activist after Tiananmen event
That's weird use of the term "soft power".
yeahforsureman··on The Original Cookie specification from 1997 was GDPR compliant (2019)
The article is not that wrong, though. The GDPR is quite an abstract piece of legislation and it's no wonder specific technical terms aren't used. To be precise, the article author should have perhaps talked rather about GDPR-based interpretations, consensus and enforcement.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →