HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ygjb

2,393 karma · joined September 8, 2011

Yvan Boily Founding Security Engineer Co-founder, Oghmere parentsguidetoai.ca https://nimblemyth.ca
submissionscomments
ygjb··on No Man's Sky's update introduces billions of new stars, planets, and more
The poster asked if you played the game, and acknowledged that you don't have to like it - that's not a fallacy, it's a clarifying question.

The game has had clearly observable and measurable improvements, in terms of features, like multi-player, but also in terms of overall content, game and storyline components, and substantial new and revised game mechanics.

It is abundantly clear from player feedback that your opinion is in the minority.

Steam reviews - Recent Reviews: Very Positive (1,837) All Reviews: Very Positive (256,838)

ygjb··on Canada's Online Harms Act (Bill C-63) (2024)
While it was generally well received in contrast to other similar bills in the past, it still had flaws. Either way, this bill died with prorogation of parliament in Canada on January 6, 2025.

It could be reintroduced if an amenable government wins the next election, but the current front runner for that election is the Conservative Party of Canada which would be unlikely to implement this law.

ygjb··on Canada threatens 'single largest trade blow' to U.S. if Trump follows through on
Trudeau is the currently elected Prime Minister, and it appears that Singh and many other Canadian Federal MPs and provincial leaders are aligned.

There is an upcoming leadership race, and then an election. Calling an election now, presumably with Trump tariff orders coming out tomorrow would lock Canadians into an election with a caretaker government that would be unable to pass any meaningful legislation. It would be monumentally stupid and your comment makes it clear you have little to no understanding of our government.

ygjb··on Canada threatens 'single largest trade blow' to U.S. if Trump follows through on
That's what happened last time around with Trump.
ygjb··on Show HN: Kate's App
A side effect of my career is that I have been in compliance adjacent roles for 20 years or so, and as a result I have read most of the related regulations. I still defer to a lawyer for actual opinions, but have frequently had to explain the technical implications of regulations to lawyers.

The bottom line is that the regulation is not a technical specification, it is a legal document, and parsing a legal document requires both the ability to read the regulation, and also to reason by applying the jurisprudence that is specific to the jurisdiction for the regualtion. Essentially, interpreting the law and translating it into requirements requires the ability to both outline the technical requirements and understand what is required to make the implementation legally defensible.

A good example of this is data deletion under GDPR. The expectation of the law is that when you get a deletion request, you will delete the data. In practice, deleting data is hard, unless you build your backup mechanisms to allow deletion of individual fields. With that in mind, companies meet this requirement by implementing a deletion scheme for production systems, and a mechanism such that datasets marked for deletion are logged, and when a restore from backup is performed, the restoration process references those deletion logs to ensure that deleted records are not restored. This, technically speaking, does not result in proper deletion of the data, but it has passed audits under data deletion regulations (Disclaimer: this is based on public documents detailing data deletion requirements, not my work directly. Consult your lawyer, I am not a lawyer, and I am not on your compliance or security team and this is not a recommendation).

ygjb··on Show HN: Kate's App
This service is currently running, in production, in the United States, and is missing key features that are regulatory or legal requirements. I won't enumerate them because I work in security, not privacy or compliance (although those are features that require strong security and I often support related projects).

The app is designed to allow sharing of personally identifiable information, and apparently doesn't distinguish regions, age, etc.

Assuming OP is American, and hosting the service in the US, and given the target audience and proposed use case, I can think of a couple of regulations that apply:

  FTC Act
  COPPPA
  CCPA
  All of the privacy laws documented here:   https://iapp.org/resources/article/us-state-privacy-legislation-tracker/
In addition, if a Canadian user signs up, then PIPEDA, and various other regulations come into play.

If an EU user signs up, then obligations must be met under the FTC's Data Privacy Framework and compliance with various EU and national regulations come into play.

It's not impossible for someone to adhere to all of the laws, it's just a full time job to do it. It's probably not reasonable for a single person to build and operate a service with the privacy and security requirements and claims that the author of KatesApp makes, and meet the compliance requirements. It is abundantly clear to anyone who works in privacy or security that the website doesn't meet the bare minimum requirements, and has very little standing to defend itself.

For reference for anyone who hasn't signed up for it, there is no terms of service, and no privacy policy.

The service includes features to allow uploading of data related to:

  Prescriptions - medication, dosage, instructions, prescriber, and pharmacy
  Medical Appointments - who (presumably the medical professional), date/time, location, and reason for medical appointment
  Doctors - a list of doctors, clinic, contact info
  Upload files, with this helpful list of suggestions of medical records to upload:
   - insurance information
   - advanced directives or DNR/DNI
   - a copy of your vaccination card
   - lab test results, doctors' reports, x-ray, MRI, and CT    - scans, or other images
   - voice recordings of visits with the doctor or other providers
   - self-monitoring logs (sleep, diet, exercise, etc.)
There are logs to show who created a data element under each of those types of records, but I didn't test the site deeply enough to determine if there are any audit controls or logs that are visible to users on who accessed what, but the privilege system implemented is rudimentary, and is fundamentally weak due to the fact that user accounts are unverified.

Anyone can sign up and create and share files and resources using this service. From the main public page, the author requires a signup code, but signing up from the HN link on the post bypasses this. There is no validation of who the user is, no confirmation that the person who signed up owns the account, or options to delete my test account or data. There are no controls that appear to limit what might be uploaded other than file size.

As of right now, this site is in violation of Canadian law and EU laws regulations. I assume it is also in violation of American laws and regulations.

I understand what the author is attempting to do, and why they are doing it, and they are deserving of empathy (and in my other comment I provided them a road map to improve some of the security issues on the site), but launching a website into production that gathers this data, in the United States is not only unwise, it is probably negligent, and it's reasonable to expect that someone could sue the owner of the application.

From a user privacy and security perspective, a user of this service would quite literally have more protections and controls using a google spreadsheet or shared folder to store and share these documents.

ygjb··on Show HN: Kate's App
> Comments on security: This is a huge issue for me. I've followed best practices as nearly as I can, but I've also been asking around to find out who could do a comprehensive security audit, but haven't yet found anybody I trust. Does anybody have any recommendations on how to find someone?

The best first step is to conduct a review yourself; you may want to hire or recruit a volunteer to do a security review, but you can kick it off yourself by using free, open source tools to scan your application, your code, and your environment.

Your first stop should be https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/observatory because there are some simple, prescriptive improvements you can make.

Your second stop should be using a container or cloud security scanning tool to check for vulnerable configurations and packages. There are a myriad of tools available, like Trivy for container scanning, Prowler https://github.com/prowler-cloud/prowler or ScoutSuite https://github.com/nccgroup/ScoutSuite for scanning your cloud environments, etc

Your third stop should be https://www.zaproxy.org/, which is a free download you can use, and https://www.zaproxy.org/getting-started/ is a great way to get started. This will help you quickly identify low hanging fruit that can be found through automated scanning.

Your fourth stop should be running language appropriate static analysis tools against your application. There are too many to mention, but here is a good starting list: https://owasp.org/www-community/Source_Code_Analysis_Tools

All of these will give you quick, tactical things you can address. Once you get through any critical findings (which frequently, but not always means they are directly exploitable without additional effort) you should threat model your application, and build a plan for security - https://owasp.org/www-community/Threat_Modeling

ygjb··on Show HN: Kate's App
> The second is a bit more complicated, since multiple family members may have access to the same data, and may have different opinions on deleting it. I'll work it out.

I know it's been said elsewhere, but you need a lawyer. This isn't something for you to work out, it's something for you to clearly understand your legal obligations, and what your exposure is based on which jurisdictions a user might log in from.

ygjb··on Show HN: Kate's App
Uh, this is appears to be an application that collects data that is regulated in most legal jurisdictions, lacks a published terms of use, doesn't have a published privacy policy, and at first glance is missing rudimentary security controls related to TLS and content security.

The sparse documentation makes claims about privacy and security, but there is no evidence to back those claims.

ygjb··on Justin Trudeau promises to resign as PM
Sure, Trudeau was a ski instructor. You will also note that I neglected to mention that Poilievre had a paper route; that's because paper routes aren't professional experience.

Trudeau was also a secondary school teacher, acted in a tv movie. He also reputedly worked as a bouncer and worked in various (heavily politically affiliated) non-profits. He had a career before politics.

That said, my primary point is that Poilievre hasn't been a particularly effective politician, and his reputation is largely that of a blowhard who's main appeal is that he is not Trudeau.

ygjb··on Justin Trudeau promises to resign as PM
Here's the primary problem with your argument: the current front-runner to win the next election is the Conservative Party of Canada, with Pierre Poilievre as leader, and pretty much a shoo-in for the next Prime Minister.

Poilievre is a career politician who's only professional experience has been as a politician, has no work history to speak of (don't take my word for it, his wikipedia entry details only a job as a collection agent, and that he started a business in 2003 focused on political communications, and then was elected in 2004).

Poilievre has spent the last several years in the lead up to becoming the party leader for the CPC cozying up to the alt-right, supporting the anti-vax movement, and hasn't published any meaningful policy documentation.

Poilievre is basically the last man standing from Stephen Harpers administration (in terms of policies and practices), and has failed to drive or pass any meaningful legislation or policy changes in his 20 year career. His victory in the 2022 CPC leadership campaign was a landslide, but also suffered from allegations of foreign interference from India and China. There is still an outstanding report on foreign interference due on January 31st.

Trudeau's greatest mistake was not implementing the electoral change he campaigned on, which likely would have marked a long term shift toward more left leaning social policies along side centrist fiscal policies, which have typically characterized Canadian society. Unfortunately, unless a very compelling alternative to the CPC emerges in the next 3 months, we will most likely get a government lead by a sock-puppet who lacks any real strength to negotiate with a presumably hostile incoming US administration, and the official party line from other Conservative groups in Canada appears to be appeasement and concession.

It's gonna be a rough couple of years :/

(edited for shoe-in)

ygjb··on Justin Trudeau promises to resign as PM
True, but this is normal; two other Prime Ministers have taken this approach over the last 30 years, Brian Mulroney and Jean Chretien both announced their intention to resign, and then held leadership conventions to select a new party leader before actually resigning.
ygjb··on Fraudsters steal 22 tonnes of high-value cheddar
For the example Parmesan cheese vs PDO (Protected Designation of Origin, under European law) Parmesan Reggiano cheese, the differences are in flavour and texture. It is absolutely possible to make Parmesan that matches PDO Parmesan Reggiano cheese outside of that region, but if you don't have the stamp (or counterfeit the stamp), you can't charge a premium price.

The same applies to a laundry list of food ingredients and products, including wines, cheeses, teas, produce, and meat. PDO isn't the only such scheme, several countries have their own appelation programs.

From a counterfeiting perspective there are three major concerns - misleading the consumer, economic harm to the cheesemakers in the region of origin, and potential food safety.

In terms of misleading the consumer, mass market parmesan cheese is usually produced with pasteurized milk vs raw milk and cured for 10 months vs 24 months. It is often sold ground into a fine powder to conceal the lower quality texture, and the flavour profile is substantially different. When cooking with 10 month cured cheese vs 24 month cured cheese, there is a noticeable difference in how the cheese melts and incorporates into different foods which can result in downstream lower quality foods (in terms of presentation and flavour, nutritionally the differences are negligable).

In terms of economic harm, parmesan cheese is substantially cheaper to produce, and has a retail price as low as $~0.50/ounce. PDO Parmesan ranges in price from $~1.50/ounce for 2 year aged, and as high as $~10/ounce (note my prices are converted from CAD to USD, and based on prices from the cheese market near me, prices may vary by market). If a counterfeiter can sell parmesan as PDO Parmesan Reggiano, they command a significant margin, even if they sell it much cheaper than the retail price).

In terms of health risks, PDO and other Appelation designations often require audits or reviews of production process to ensure compliance and quality control. Fake PDO Parm made with unpasteurized milk and not handled properly can bring the risks of using raw milk to the consumer - properly made PDO Parm results in a cured and extremely low moisture product that should destroy most of the bacteria and molds. Even minor changes in the production process can make the resulting product unsafe or higher risk for consumption.

ygjb··on How to delete your 23andMe data amid the company's turmoil
Practically speaking, it also makes using and querying that data and doing any kind of analytics much, much more expensive. It is done that way in some cases, but in the absence of a technical requirement to do so, there are cheaper approaches.
ygjb··on How to delete your 23andMe data amid the company's turmoil
I can't speak for any other companies, but you don't need to speculate. You can search the internet and find several articles outlining that the correct strategy for businesses here is to delete the data from production systems, and then maintain a record of references to those deleted records such that a restored backup can ensure that deleted records are not put back into production.

There is generally an expectation that data may be retained in backups for a specified retention period, but will not be used or restored. Beyond that, it is up to the regulator to determine if this is meets the standard, but it's worth noting that there are notions baked into the text and the interpretations of the text of GDPR that account for reasonable costs and efforts.

Auditors can and do test and monitor for this, both using audit processes and demanding evidence, and by performing manual testing and experimentation.

ygjb··on Canvas is a new way to write and code with ChatGPT
idk, I can definitely see value in a lightweight LLM component for VIM to help me look up the correct command sequence to exit :P
ygjb··on Google says it won't follow Amazon's lead with a return-to-office mandate
> For large organizations, remote can be the difference between one state's paperwork + regs + taxation, and every state and country under the sun's paperwork + regs + taxation. That is a real burden. Not just the paperwork + administrative overhead, but being subject to differing employment + everything else laws from everywhere will really muck up ability to run a consistent business.

This is a real burden for small businesses. The nature of Amazon's business as an online retailer with a massive distribution network means that for any significant market they do business in, they will have employees. Practically speaking, this is a solved problem for any state in which Amazon has a warehouse (which I think is probably all of them for the US?).

ygjb··on Anthropic hires OpenAI co-founder Durk Kingma
> This barely-disguised contempt for what should likely be their most valuable power-user base suggests

Yikes. I am a long time Mozilla supporter, active user of Firefox since before it was Firefox, and former Mozilla employee, but this comment is pretty crazy.

Firefox is well below 3% market share, and is essentially a niche browser at this point - it sucks when I run into sites and services that aren't supported by Firefox, but I don't assume that it's contempt for me as a Firefox user. I simply assume that I, as a power user, have opted to use an alternate tool that has features that are compelling to me, and I certainly don't expect every business out there to prioritize my use of a niche tool.

I learned a long time ago that while power users can be an effective avenue for building a market for niche products, they also end up being some of the most problematic users, because of the assumptions that power user needs should be placed above the regular users. It's fine to want to be catered to, but it's not really great to assume malice when you aren't - it shows contempt for the prioritization of the limited resources they have available.

ygjb··on Anthropic hires OpenAI co-founder Durk Kingma
I think that the approach that Anthropic is taking to governance is a little different than "all for myself", it's worth having a read of https://www.anthropic.com/news/the-long-term-benefit-trust

It sounds like they are least trying to build on the notion of being a public benefit corporation, and create a business that won't devolve into chart must go up and to the right each quarter.

Time will tell of course, OpenAI was putatively started with good, non-profit intentions.

ygjb··on Is there no way to protest the email spam filter rules of Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook?
I didn't miss that part. I am telling you that users hitting report spam on emails (yours, or others) that they don't want to see are not abusing the button. They are sending a signal that they don't want to see (or receive) those emails anymore. They are using the user interface of their client to control their user experience because they have decided that your workflow (or others workflows) to stop receiving the messages is more annoying than hitting that button. It's not a user problem, it's an ecosystem problem, and developers and product owners like you are continuing to drive the problem by insisting that "No, it's the users who are wrong!".

> I'm listing supporting facts for why it's insane to let less than 1% of the population to dictate something for everyone else.

I would argue that there are less than 0.01% of email users in general that own or manage private or commercial distribution lists. Expecting that owners of those lists can dictate to users how the owners can access users limited attention is even more ridiculous.

Either way, you are still attacking or insulting not only your users, but also all of the people who may have or will receive unsolicited email address from a service adjacent (in a shared cloud service sense) to yours.

> Email. Not marketing email.

It appears you believe that there is a distinction. It is still a marketing email because you are using email to drive engagement or deliver service. Marketing isn't limited to a direct offer of a product or service, especially if you depend on those emails from growth or retention.

ygjb··on Is there no way to protest the email spam filter rules of Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook?
> Their spam filters are awful and are harming what I feel is a very important project.

Cried every marketer in history when individuals, groups, or governments implemented rules to make it hard to reach people.

> They're allowing the 1% lowest common denominator to determine what the other 99% are allowed to see.

Conversely, think of it from the perspective that those 1% of users are fed up with receiving marketing emails, and the result is that they are taking the measure they feel is effective to reduce the amount of spam they receive.

> "60% of the population have an IQ under 85; this is not a small issue." > For $25/mo, which is a 50% increase in my monthly SES cost. (pulled from your reply)

Look in the mirror. If you are attacking the intelligence of your users because they are doing the best they can with the limited tools that advertising driven companies use to manage their email, it may be worth taking some time to reflect on why that is. You want to send marketing email; you opted to use a cheaper service that has documented considerations for reputation impact. You know the correct solution, you just think you are entitled to a lower cost service to get your product in front of other people. You aren't, and it isn't the users who are the problem, it's the ecosystem.

ygjb··on Amazon ordered a return to the office – but research says they'll backtrack
There may not be a direct metric, but there are a number of mechanisms that municipalities can use to track things:

* use of public transit

* use of roads / traffic measuring

* measuring counts of pedestrians

* anecdotes and actual data about the performance of businesses near offices

* water, electricity, and other utility metrics

* parking tax rates

These are just the ones I can think of off the top of my head, and I am sure there are many others that are not obvious.

Those are just the things off the top of my head.

ygjb··on Radiology-specific foundation model
It's a bike shed. It's easier to argue the definition or terminology than the technology, so it's the thing people go for.
ygjb··on A Massachusetts town closes its parks to stop a mosquito-borne disease
If you don't know why society is dragging it's feet on wiping out, you should probably educate yourself before making such a suggestion.

Mosquitos suck, literally, and I despise them, but they are a critical link in the ecosystems they live in.

Everybody wants to save the bees because they make honey and aren't assholes like Wasps, but bees are far from the only pollinators.

Without Mosquitos, a lot of animals a few steps up the food chain suffer, including bats, birds, larger insect predators like dragonflys, but also frogs and fish.

Female mosquitos are the ones that are most problematic, since they need to consume blood for nutrition for reproduction, but mosquitos also consume nectar and are pollinators.

Wiping out mosquitos would probably be achievable, but it would also kick the ladder out from under ecosystems that are already extremely fragile at a time when we are in the middle of the largest extinction event in human history (and potentially mammalian history, depends how far the holocene extinction proceeds).

ygjb··on Inside the "3 billion people" national public data breach
> all because British people think an ID card means you'll get stopped on the street to show your papers.

That's probably because all of the anti-immigration and anti-foreigner people who are asking the government to stop people and ask them for their papers... this is not unique the the UK, Canada, or the United States either, and some of the countries plan to do more than just deport people.

Strong identity is increasingly a meaningful technical requirement, but glossing over the human impact of strong identity controls by the government is not going to have good outcomes either.

ygjb··on Google loses antitrust suit over search deals on phones
Yeah, less golden eggs, and more golden funnels (Chrome, Android).
ygjb··on Open source AI is the path forward
Yeah. There is alot of over hyped and over funded nonsense that comes out of NASA. Some of it is hype from the marketing and press teams, other hype comes from misinterpretation of releases.

None of that changes that there have been major technical breakthroughs, and entire classes of products and services that didn't exist before those investments in NASA (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spin-off_technologies for a short list). There are 15 departments and dozens of Agencies that comprise the US Federal government, many of whom make investments in science and technology as part of their mandates, and most of that is delivered through some structure of public-private partnerships.

What you see as over-hyped and over-funded nonsense could be the next ground breaking technology, and that is why we need both elected leaders who (at least in theory) represent the will of the people, and appointed, skilled bureaucrats who provide the elected leaders with the skills, domain expertise, and experience that the winners of the popularity contest probably don't have.

Yep, there will be waste, but at least with public funds there is the appearance of accountability that just doesn't exist with private sector funds.

ygjb··on Open source AI is the path forward
Sure, just on the training front, building and maintaining a broad corpus of properly managed training data with metadata that provides attribution (for example, content that is known to be human generated instead of model generated, what the source of data is for datasets such as weather data, census data, etc), and that also captures any licensing encumbrance so that consumers of the training data can be confident in their ability to use it without risk of legal challenge.

Much of this is already available to private sector entities, but having a publicly funded organization responsible for curating and publishing this would enable new entrants to quickly and easily get a foundation without having to scrape the internet again, especially given how rapidly model generated content is being published.

ygjb··on Open source AI is the path forward
Of course they won't. The investment in the Heavy Press Program was the initial build, and just citing one example, the Alcoa 50,000 ton forging press was built in 1955, operated until 2008, and needed ~$100M to get it operational again in 2012.

The investment was made to build the press, which created significant jobs and capital investment. The press, and others like it, were subsequently operated by and then sold to a private operator, which in turn enabled the massive expansion of both military manufacturing, and commercial aviation and other manufacturing.

The Heavy Press Program was a strategic investment that paid dividends by both advancing the state of the art in manufacturing at the time it was built, and improving manufacturing capacity.

A GPU cluster might not be the correct investment, but a strategic investment in increasing, for example, the availability of training data, or interoperability of tools, or ease of use for building, training, and distributing models would probably pay big dividends.

ygjb··on Alexa is in millions of households and Amazon is losing billions
Yes, most consumer home security products have a security subscription attached because they require monitoring (and many jurisdictions require monitoring for alarm permits to help reduce false alarms). For Ring, that also means the features listed on their product page (cloud video access and history, etc).
← PreviousPage 7 of 24Next →