HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yks

1,327 karma · joined December 9, 2015

submissionscomments
yks··on Mikhail Gorbachev has died
Yep, serfdom was abolished in England in 1574 and in Russia in 1861, almost three hundred years later.
yks··on How messed up was Germany's energy policy?
Ukraine has been a pain in Germany's neck, Nord Streams are the most visible result of that but then there are also anecdotes of Merkel ignoring Yushchenko, German delegations not attending Ukrainian independence parades and so on. Even now Merkel is openly saying "no regrets" in the face of the bona fide genocide, that's how little empathy German leadership has for Ukraine.

I think the calculus was that Ukraine is never going to be in NATO and so its future is at best irrelevant for Germany, and at worst they'd prefer it absorbed by Russia who Germans enjoy dealing with. But in the meantime Eastern European countries gained power, and they are really not okay with Russian imperial project (Hungary aside). So now Germany, being an ally with Eastern Europe on paper, has to do something, so they are reluctantly doing the bare minimum.

yks··on Slab City reaches its boiling point
Imagine Burning Man but on meth
yks··on Ask HN: What makes you pessimistic about the future?
This war has also weaponized civilian nuclear tech, e.g. Russians use a huge nuclear plant as a weapon depot [1] while at the same time torturing personnel [2]. What could go wrong. Humanity haven't really dealt yet with the terrorist entities of the scale and ambition of Russia.

[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/russian-army-turns-ukraines-lar...

[2] https://kyivindependent.com/news-feed/mayor-russian-forces-t...

yks··on Ask HN: What makes you pessimistic about the future?
Nuclear weapons will 100% be used again. All it takes is one sociopathic dictator who thinks everyone else is weak, and we know that the power is a magnet for sociopaths and any country can be turned into dictatorship within a decade give or take. Putin of today or another dictator of tomorrow, does not matter. It does not even matter which country is going to pull the trigger, the invasion of Ukraine has started the race to acquire nuclear weapons and all countries have to participate or perish. The gun is on the stage and therefore it will go off.
yks··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
> a treaty that designates the United States as the guarantor of Ukrainian independence

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Securit...

> there's at least a dozen other conflicts around the world right now where you can make the same argument

Which other conflict is waged with the goal of eliminating the country completely and destroy its culture?

There were no major conflicts of this kind since WW2. Changing the government, plenty of times, but not erasing borders with the cultural genocide and some forced children "relocation" on top of that.

I didn't say anything about the US as a global empire or whatever, it's the collective World's responsibility to maintain peace and it's failing. But I say that there are clear "good guys" and "bad guys" here, regardless of the history of the US.

yks··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
Putin himself tells everyone that his goal is conquering territories, Eastern Europeans tell everyone that Russian goal is conquering territories, yet people on the internet are still parroting "NATO's fault". I wish everyone read the book Bloodlands first before supporting Russians in their cruel conquests.
yks··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
You either accept a moral responsibility to protect sovereign nations from elimination, and elimination at this point was stated by Russian officials and media as a goal numerous times, or you accept the Russian position of "lands and peoples belong to the strong men" and we're back to the age of conquest, but now with nukes. Not only the former position is morally right, but it also prevents or at least postpones the nuclear proliferation.

This is not only about Ukraine, this is about the whole Eastern Europe, and literally about post WW2 order that you seem to be enjoying the fruits of, if only by hanging out on Hacker News.

yks··on Does the Tank Have a Future?
The line of engagement barely moved in 3 months all the while Ukraine is hopelessly outgunned, Russians are doing quite well indeed /s. In reality UAF wasn't even a really modern army, just more modern than Russia, and all their "NATO" training in effect started in 2014.

Where do people get the impression that Russian army is strong and capable is beyond me, they just throw people into the meat grinder and sit on top of the infinite Soviet arsenal of old equipment.

yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
Nuclear powers lost wars before, nuclear powers lost proxy wars before, and yet we are not living in the Fallout world.
yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
What is the wall there? Pre-Feb 24 status quo? Why does Putin need to commit suicide in that case? He didn't need to commit suicide before February.
yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
You're arguing my point! Which is that people knew about this invasion, US intelligence knew, Ukrainians were preparing as well despite the rosy rhetoric of Zelensky.
yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
What do you expect him to say, "Putin bring it on?". In some random interviews he said Ukraine is prepared [1].

And yes, no one was sure that this Feb military build up results in war cause there was already a build up in April before that. But this invasion was inevitable with the current Russian leadership, UAF underwent a series of reforms since 2014 to prepare for it.

[1] https://www.npr.org/2022/01/29/1076699748/ukraine-russian-at...

yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
Invasion started in 2014, when diplomacy was okay. Russia kept rotating their knife in Ukrainian back all this time, you can't with a straight face victim blame Ukraine here.
yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
First, letting Putin run over Ukraine is a guaranteed destruction of Ukrainian culture and identity, or at least a setback for several decades or centuries until Russia collapses again. Another generation of poets, writers, citizen sent to mass graves. Fine, you might think that physical safety of a majority outweigh such ephemeral concepts and the minority of cultural elites can be sacrificed to Putin but not everyone thinks that way. Many Ukrainians, for instance, are willing to sacrifice their physical safety for the survival of Ukrainian culture.

Second, letting Russia win will not stop further death and destruction when Putin continues his expansion westward, only then with Ukrainian conscripts as a cannon fodder.

yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
> This is exactly what everyone said about Putin invading Ukraine.

First, not everyone, Ukrainians knew. Second, after the end of WW2 we lived (wanted to live) under a spell that conquering whole countries with some opportunistic genocide on top is not going to happen anymore, or at least not in the "civilized" Europe. Now, I hope the spell is off, we can see the world more clearly, and it's a raw power competition in which Putin thinks he has the winning cards or can at least out bluff everyone.

yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
> Russia wins this war no matter what

As they say, citation needed.

yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
Even if true, it's just not smart cause the Biden administration will be voted out due to consequences of the drawn out conflict.
yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
He's not unhinged, he's essentially a boss of a drug cartel, flaunting his strength and cruelty but respecting the power of others. There is no real value for him to launch nukes unless he thinks the West is absolutely weak and I'm afraid that conviction is actually growing.
yks··on US quietly urges more use of Russia fertilizer to ease food crisis
The West could've ended this war by now if they just went all in on sending howitzers, MLRS and other heavy equipment into Ukraine but they keep slow dripping it, or just doing nothing like Germany. The most powerful societies in the world history just twiddle their thumbs while negative consequences keep mounting.
yks··on Letter in Support of Responsible Fintech Policy
You can send money to any Ukrainian bank account via SWIFT. This includes all personal bank accounts. A recipient needs to lookup the bank's SWIFT code and IBAN which can be non-obvious but working with crypto is also non-obvious. Fees vary as do crypto fees. Crypto is not a qualitative improvement here, it's just one option out of many with pros/cons.
yks··on Musk SEC Filing
> he has actually significantly changed the landscape for global warming

Oh yes, by shilling proof-of-work cryptocurrencies he definitely made a contribution. I'm not even sure if his Tesla venture would offset this damage long term.

yks··on Nearly half of Mariupol has suffered grave damage
It's a soundbite to spurt the idea that pro-Ukrainian position or any conclusion that Ukrainians have successes on the battlefield is simply a "propaganda".
yks··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
You are correct in some immediate sense but this war is a bit different because it is actually revealing what using nukes or threatening to use nukes means in the context of war of conquest/genocide in 21st century. If the US completely abandoned Ukraine day one, then Russia would attack a NATO country next cause they would feel the nuclear threat is too much for the US to handle.
yks··on Americans’ views on the war reveal a striking generational divide
Their war equipment is not "last-gen", they basically keep upgrading whatever was left of the USSR and they do sit on the huge stocks of non-modernized Soviet equipment, but eventually they will be left with a useless old and vulnerable hardware. Yes, they made some next-gen tanks and planes which are not combat ready yet but modern Russian industrial capability would be able to churn out only token numbers of those anyway, under sanctions and brain drain.

Russian equipment loss in this war won't be replaced for decades if not longer.

yks··on Moskva cruiser sank while being towed in a storm – Russian Defense Ministry
Their current war is based on the propaganda of Russian superiority over Ukrainians, military superiority specifically since Russians built their whole modern ideology on winning WWII. Admitting that Ukrainians are capable of anything is therefore undercutting this foundational national idea.
yks··on Killing Robots and Just War Theory
Well, essentially they are given carte blanche for war crimes, because if they become prisoners of war, they won't be tried as a regular criminal anyway so it does not matter how many civilians they torture beforehand
yks··on Killing Robots and Just War Theory
But then individual soldiers from the attacking side are granted "protection" against mistreatment as prisoners of war, even when that war itself is a crime (against peace) and even when those soldiers themselves commit all war crimes under the sun. Obviously vendetta culture does not bring humanity to the bright place but this protection line, drawn at the possession of the regular army soldier ID, is a rather absurd one.
yks··on Russia War Crimes
When people say they will never trust official/conventional sources again, usually that's a code phrase that signals them trusting egregiously untrustworthy sources. It's a generalization of course but unfortunately works like a clock.
yks··on Russia War Crimes
Please do not donate to Red Cross! They spend money on bureaucracy and photo ops of their leadership with Russian officials and are all around ineffective, e.g. bringing a truck full of water to a well functioning and protected Ukrainian city located on the biggest river in Ukraine. If you cannot or would not donate to the military, consider donating to the numerous effective Ukrainian humanitarian aid organizations, one example: Nova Ukraine [1]

[1] https://novaukraine.org/

← PreviousPage 7 of 14Next →