HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yourbandsucks

180 karma · joined August 22, 2018

submissionscomments
yourbandsucks··on What You Can't Say (2004)
My comment was that accepted speech and representation are different things, so saying "but representation" isn't really speaking to it, imo.

And you're not even right about the demographics unless one ignores east and south Asians. Plurality != Dominance.

yourbandsucks··on Apple told some Apple TV+ show developers not to anger China
You're eliding the part where said employees are often one generation away from subsistence farming and this is a step up for them.

That's how it happened in the west, too, no? Textile mills? I'm not saying anything about morality but it sounds standard to me.

yourbandsucks··on What You Can't Say (2004)
Sorry, I thought you were implying something nasty.

I like TheMotte, although there's a few opinions I see that make my blood boil.

yourbandsucks··on What You Can't Say (2004)
That's not at all how he described it in his Scott alexander-length blog post on the matter.
yourbandsucks··on What You Can't Say (2004)
It's possible that such comments are popular here specifically because there are a lot of people who feel they can't say it at work. Catharsis behind pseudonymity.
yourbandsucks··on What You Can't Say (2004)
Different arenas.

You're talking about representation among the powerful in mainstream America, but OP was talking about accepted speech in tech/academia.

You can both be right.

yourbandsucks··on Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store
'pro-China' was a little confusing on that score, but I did misquote you, so sorry. Cheers.
yourbandsucks··on Atari VCS Lead Architect Quits, Claims Six Months of Design Work Went Unpaid
Related: There are multiple vintage typewriter stores in NYC.

https://www.google.com/search?q=nyc+typewriter+stores

If those stores can stay afloat, there's a decent chance this Atari could sell. (Assuming it's actually built).

yourbandsucks··on Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store
It has upsides and downsides.

You realize that you're criticizing someone right now for having a take on relative weaknesses of the US system? Going so far as to immediately accuse them of loyalty to another country?

Not to snark too hard, but 'physician, heal thyself' comes to mind.

yourbandsucks··on Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store
Their only mention of China used the word 'repugnant', so I'm not sure how you reached that conclusion.
yourbandsucks··on China and Taiwan Clash over Wikipedia Edits
.
yourbandsucks··on NBA Events in China Disrupted over Hong Kong Tweet
You've got a balance of hundreds of comments calling for civilizational confrontation. With dozens of actually racist comments in the mix as well. Over, what, 2 dozen threads in a few days?

Go ahead and ban me if you like but I'm not your problem here. That comment was, if I do say so, mind expanding compared to the raw emotion on display in these threads.

yourbandsucks··on NBA Events in China Disrupted over Hong Kong Tweet
Ok. Cheers.

For the record, I wasn't assuming anything about your exposure to various ideas. Just didn't want to belabor the points. I was snarking the one-sidedness of the board a little bit.

If you wanted to hear what I was thinking:

1) Installing western-friendly government in HK achieves full naval encirclement of China (SK, JP, Phillipines, Taiwan, HK).

2) As you say, there's the history of colonialism, which gets compounded by the importance of 1).

3) We consistently ignore these things from our allies and then get all moralizing when it's strategically advantageous for us. 12 hours ago we let Erdogan invade kurdish syria, and that's just today. I could list another dozen countries/disasters that we're enabling right now.

4) Almost every time we have gotten involved in 'liberating' countries because our values are so great, it's not only had ulterior motivations but it's also been an absolute humanitarian disaster. We did this on their borders twice in the latter 20th century.

When you add all of that up, and mix in the post-colonial resentment.. I can see a reaction of "America in particular can kindly shut up about it". It's not that they can't comprehend democracy, it's that they specifically don't want any American involvement whatsoever.

I'm not saying you have to agree with them -- feel free to join a divestment movement or something -- but they do have their reasons, the issue isn't completely one-sided.

yourbandsucks··on NBA Events in China Disrupted over Hong Kong Tweet
I think the NBA shouldn't take a stance because shared love of basketball shouldn't be an international battleground. Even if you're taking a purely American POV, there's a reason we don't weaponize the Peace corps.

From a more global viewpoint.. there are reasons why a lot of Chinese get mad at the idea of westerners expressing an opinion over Hong Kong's system of rule. And it's not because they're brainwashed. Silver probably listened to their perspective, based on his wording.

One could be forgiven for not knowing such a perspective exists, given the HN threads on the matter.

yourbandsucks··on NBA Events in China Disrupted over Hong Kong Tweet
Yeah, I'd call that type of statement being the vanguard, considering the US government is very much not getting involved in the HK matter.

Silver doesn't even have the right to speak for all NBA employees on the matter, which he wisely recognized. He should definitely not be getting out ahead of the State Dept.

yourbandsucks··on NBA Events in China Disrupted over Hong Kong Tweet
I'm glad Silver took his time and got it right. The response was perfect -- de-escalating, respectful, yet firmly refusing to get into policing their employees, as you say.

The NBA shouldn't be the vanguard of American foreign policy.

yourbandsucks··on China attacks Apple for allowing Hong Kong crowdsourced police activity app
You might like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs
yourbandsucks··on China and Taiwan Clash over Wikipedia Edits
But do you think it's likely that the PRC actually invades Taiwan?

I'm not taking a side on PRC vs ROC, maybe you're misunderstanding me. I just honestly thought it was taken for granted that that's pretty unlikely. All the talk about who's sovereign has been polite fiction for some time now.

(and, I'll admit I haven't done a ton of research on Taiwanese public opinion, but unless/until I do so, I'm going to take 'taiwansecurity.org' in English's takes with a grain of salt - Ahmed Chalabi sounded good too)

yourbandsucks··on China and Taiwan Clash over Wikipedia Edits
The part where anyone thinks it's a credible threat? I honestly thought that went without saying.

You really think China's 5 seconds away from a bloody invasion? China is Taiwan's largest trading partner. Everyone's getting rich, in both countries.

Taiwan is and will remain independent, everyone knows this, China doesn't care.

yourbandsucks··on China and Taiwan Clash over Wikipedia Edits
But we agree that that's the background and Taiwan hasn't reached consensus to change the official policy, right?

OP is getting dogpiled for pointing out the grade school history overview of the topic.

As for whether the threat of invasion is the deciding factor on the official ROC policy.. I think it's better explained by the fact that everything is going fine with two Chinas. They trade a ton, everyone's happy.

Why mess with that just because the diplomatic positions don't make logical sense?

yourbandsucks··on China and Taiwan Clash over Wikipedia Edits
They don't call themselves part of China under threat.

Their official position is that they're the rightful government of all of China. Abandoning 'Taiwan is part of China' would mean abandoning that claim.

It looks quaint now, yes, but that's the official position. And it wasn't quaint when they were holding China's security council seat.

The fact that both countries have reasons to say 'Taiwan is part of China' while each claiming to be the rightful government of China is the most basic fact of the relationship. It's embedded in the names of the countries, even. ROC and PRC. I'd submit that anyone with strong feelings on the matter should really already know this.

yourbandsucks··on The China Cultural Clash
I wasn't trying to take sides on the HK situation itself, though, so it can't really be a straw-man on that topic.

The topic was whether the outpouring of sentiment from mainland China could be 'organic' rather than some immediate government dictate.

yourbandsucks··on The China Cultural Clash
This has already been going on for months, though. It's gotta be front-of-mind over there.

The image of English-speaking westerners talking about "liberate hong kong" is a bit triggering for the average Chinese person, due to Hong Kong and England's history. It must be incredibly easy for CCTV to point at that and say that it's just the western imperialists trying to take HK away.

yourbandsucks··on NBA's China dilemma: $4B at risk as Chinese TV cancels game broadcasts
It's a dilemma in that neither the NBA nor their Chinese fans necessarily want to be dragged into this particular crossfire. Even if you're pro-confrontation over various issues, shared enjoyment of basketball is like the last battlefield I'd choose.

I liked Silver's response. Respectfully but firmly refusing to get into regulating the politics of however many players and employees.

yourbandsucks··on Scissor Statements: Sort by Controversial
I read a bit about postmodernism recently. I think the difference between yourself/Scott and the 'X studies' traditions is that they're not into classically philosophical arguments like you're making here. It's all about implied power relationships, the identity of speaker and listener are as important, maybe more important, than the content.

Whereas for you and Mr SSC, the identity is to be studiously ignored in favor of only focusing on the argument, to treat it fairly.

So everyone is using wildly different metrics and then wondering why their interlocutors seem crazy.

yourbandsucks··on Blizzard Suspends Professional Hearthstone Player for Hong Kong Comments
Lots of Americans express admiration for our founders and institutions too, though. Flags and conspicuous patriotism are everywhere in our country.

It's possible that that's just normalized for you but it seems jarring when you see someone revering a 'commie'. The programming runs deep on all sides.

yourbandsucks··on Blizzard Suspends Professional Hearthstone Player for Hong Kong Comments
I don't think you're disagreeing with the poster.

They're saying that cancel culture has normalized private sector political censorship in the west prior to this, making it a smaller reach.

The $ considerations are certainly there in all cases.

yourbandsucks··on China’s Millennials
Cheers and appreciated.

FWIW, my basic angle here is 'people are people'. If the board were overloaded with anti-American or anti-Russian stuff, I'd be making mostly the same points.

yourbandsucks··on Adobe deactivates all Venezuelan accounts
Their stock quadrupled since doing so, though.

You might be proposing a bigger rebellion against capitalism than just illegally selling to Venezuela :)

yourbandsucks··on Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong
I'm relating perspective to facts.

Palestine has a UN seat, Taiwan doesn't. Taiwan has control of their territory, Palestine doesn't.

Which one is more 'a country'?

← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →