HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC

3,123 karma · joined December 15, 2013

submissionscomments
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Google Street View image of a house predicts car accident risk of its resident
> No, you miss the point.

Quite the contrary.

> average

And that right there is where you are hiding all your assumptions. There is no such thing as "your risk profile", there is only your risk profile according to some risk model, which approaches what actually will happen to you individually the more detailed you make it and the better your predictive capabilities get, because as you do that, you are shrinking the pool of individuals that this average is calculcated over, approaching only you as one individual in the limit, at which point the average is the same as the actual thing.

> and with zero density on the higher end, meaning you never have a catastrophic loss.

Also, that's not a thing.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Education Is a System of Indoctrination of the Young (1989) [video]
> I don't think all individuals should become a 100% creative/original person. That would make the society very unstable. So we need some (actually, a lot of) obedient people that makes the society keep going

That seems very questionable at best, in particular the "unstable" part. An obedient population is extremely vulnerable to authority figures. The whole point of democracy is to create stability by removing that single point of failure, by involving so many people in everything that crazy or malicious individuals can not easily gain excessive power, and democracy is under no circumstances compatible with obedience: Either you think critically and vote in your own interest, or you are obedient and vote how the dictator tells you to. It's impossible to have a population that critically evaluates candidates and selects the best one and that also follows orders without regard to their own evaluation of that order.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on [dead]
The author of that article obviously fits that stereotype more than perfectly, and the general pattern is definitely a thing, functionally atheistic people who claim to be Christians and anything in between notwithstanding. So ... what is your point?
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on [dead]
> The old adage, “correlation does not entail causation”, probably holds true here as well. Unwin makes it clear that he does not know why sexual freedom directly leads to the decline and collapse of cultures [...]

Does anything more need to be said about this? Correlation does not entail causation, but right in the next sentence, let's just pretend that it is causation anyway, without any justification whatsoever.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The most copied StackOverflow snippet of all time is flawed
No, it doesn't, because it is licenced under CC BY-SA.
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Archivists Are Trying to Make Sure LibGen Never Goes Down
https://gh.de/?cat=hdx&xf=6_8000%7E840_USB+3.0&sort=p
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on 0.30000000000000004
> Most people don't realize that the IEEE-754 single precision floating point represent real numbers with 9 decimal digits (or 23 binary digits). The double, on the other hand, represents the real numbers with 17 decimal digits.

No, they don't. They merely can be converted back to decimal with those numbers of significant digits without loss of information.

That is important because (a) if this matters, you have to make sure you actually control the number of significant digits when converting to decimal, or you might end up with a different decimal, and (b) the operations that you do on the floats do not reliably behave as if there was the supposedly represented decimal number stored in them.

Now, sure, you can use floats for currency, if you know what you are doing, but the point of the warning against it is that you have to know what you are doing, and chances are you don't, or if you do, then you know where you can ignore it anyway.

(That is, unless you mean nothing more than that you can encode the information contained in an n-digit decimal in a float/double--which of course is true, but not particular to floating point numbers, as any state with a certain number of bits can, of course, encode any information of no more than that many bits, somehow.)

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
Well ... try reporting a bug without doing so and see how far you get?!
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
Sorry, but no. He is not just a random guy off the street, he is in a responsible public position, and this is already his defense, so it is reasonable to think that this is the best he could come up with to defend his decision, it's not some misinterpreted tweet that was taken out of context.

Also, I have not seen anyone advocating for hurting him, which would obviously be out of place, but you can not take on the responsibility for a public good worth billions and then expect exceedingly friendly treatment when you completely fuck it up because you didn't care to exercise even a minimal amount of diligence, in the best case.

And while "idiot" or "fool" might not be neutral terms, they are still terms that at their core describe his actions in this case (assuming it wasn't corruption), it's not just random name calling to degrade a person.

Now, if there really is an explanation how all of this is in the public interest, sure, bring it forward, and push it to the front page of HN, I certainly would want to know. But the mere fact that even the best-founded judgement could always turn out to be completely wrong after all based on new evidence is not a reason to hold back criticism when there is solid evidence supporting that criticism, because the theoretical possibility does not mean it is actually likely or common.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
> "we don't have the people to maintain PIR and decided that rather than hire people for it, we should sell it"

Except, unless I am misunderstanding something there, they had outsourced running the registry to Afilias anyway? So it's not even that ...

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
Well, they already only take bug reports from people who enter into a contract with Microsoft!?
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
They can't "sell it from under their nose", they just can demand any renewal price for it they like, and delete the domain if that price is not being paid.
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on Why I Voted to Sell .ORG
What a fucking moron!

1. No, 26$ is obviously not a sane, let alone a reasonable price for a domain registration. For comparison, you can register .de for < 4 EUR/year, so at a price of 26$ this is redirecting 220 million dollars of funds that were donated for charitable work to definitely not charitable profit for these investors--or 160 million more than right now.

2. The price increase is capped at only 10% per year? Are you fucking kidding me? Do you seriously not have a clue how exponential growth works? .org has existed for 34 years, if you add another 34 years of increases of "only" 10%, you are at 255$ per year. Or, as he himself calculated, it's more than doubling the price in ten years, which would be just crazy.

3. "They promised they'd be good!" ... seriously? You seriously can not see the problem with a transaction where a profit-seeking entity obviously explicitly avoids actually promising anything (that is: making any of those "promises" legally binding)? After all, it is possible to actually promise all those things in a meaningful way, that's what the legal system is for.

4. "Give back to the .org community through a Community Enablement Fund" ... or in other words: Appropriate charitable donations where the donors have already decided what causes they should go to and redistribute them to their liking. Can anyone really be too stupid to see through this and be in a position to make such a decision?

5. "While it's true that running .org provided a relatively steady income stream, it effectively staked most of our revenue on a single business, and required a certain amount of our resources to be spent managing that business, distracting from the broader mission." ... WTF? And running it in the future will not require any resources? Does this guy not understand basic financial math either? Like, if you buy a business, you pay for expected profits, i.e., after you you have subtracted expected expenses, i.e., if you sell a business, you still "pay" for all the future expenses? Selling a business does not magically create money, it only shifts the cash flow to the present day. The only way selling a business can increase your cash flow is if the buyer increases prices or reduces costs.

It's all so obviously from the bullshitting playbook you can hardly believe anyone would actually believe any of these "arguments" to be of any value, when the path to actually guaranteeing all of these things that we are supposed to just believe is so obvious.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
No, SLAAC is the name of the configuration mechanism, the network protocol that is used for SLAAC is NDP, specifically router advertisements (RA), and SLAAC assigns a specific address to a host, based on the information in the RA and local policy on the host that specifies how specifically to generate the host part of that specific address.
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
No, SLAAC is the name of the configuration mechanism, the network protocol that is used for SLAAC is NDP, specifically router advertisements (RA), and SLAAC assigns a specific address to a host, based on the information in the RA and local policy on the host that specifies how specifically to generate the host part of that specific address.
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
> So it does provide practical protection to use NAT in that you've reduced the set of valid attackers from "anyone on the Internet" to "people with the ability to affect the upstream router in my ISP"

Except it really doesn't because you haven't?

There are two practically relevant circumstances where the statement "NAT provides security" is made:

1. With regards to real-world home routers (which also come with a stateful firewall), in which case the statement is simply false: Adding or removing NAT makes no difference whatsoever for security. This is also the scenario that then is used to argue against IPv6, because IPv6 supposedly lacks this security, when it just doesn't, because the IPv6 router also comes with a stateful firewall, and adding NAT (or disabling IPv6 because of a "lack of NAT") achieves absolutely nothing security-wise, because there is no problem in the first place.

2. By people who falsely believe that NAT does in fact prevent all inbound connections and for that reason fail to configure the necessary firewall rules on more business-oriented routers, so the belief that "NAT provides security" keeps them from actually securing their network, and that in particular in scenarios where it is much more relevant than for your typical home user.

So, it is technically true that NAT could have security-enhancing effects under artificial circumstances. But under all real circumstances, it either just doesn't, or the belief that it has is what causes the configuration to be less secure than it easily could be, if only people didn't have the completely not-understood belief that "NAT provides security".

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
You are completely misunderstanding the purpose of IP address space. The purpose of IP address space is not to all be used, the point of address space is to enable connectivity. You enable connectivity by (a) having addresses available whereever you need them while (b) allowing for efficient delivery of messages. Both of those you achieve with sparse allocations, where it is easy to add machines and networks with minimal changes to the overall structure and minimal administrative overhead.

Designing the IPv6 address space to be filled with devices is about as sensible as designing the DNS system to be filled with domains. Like, instead of allowing for domain names with 63 characters per label, we could have just said DNS names are alphanumeric strings 7 characters long, and you get assigned a random one if you register a domain, to maximize the utilization of the address space. But that would be simply idiotic, because the purpose of that address space is to provide readable names, not to "use all the addresses".

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
It is over-engineering the same way that setting the maximum length of a database field longer than absolutely necessary is over-engineering, so not at all, except even far less so, because resizing a database field tends to be trivial, resizing the IP address size we've been working on for 20 years already and there is still no end in sight.

Really, this has absolutely nothing to do with "over-engineering", as there is absolutely no "engineering" in making the address larger, it adds zero complexity, and it massively simplifies network design because it removes constraints that really complicate the building and maintenance of networks.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
But that just isn't true. There is nothing in NAT that requires dropping inbound connections, so crappy router manufacturers might be failing to do so right now. If there is no firewall on the device, it won't prevent inbound connections, no matter how much NAT it does.
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
On the other hand, this might also give other people a false sense of security. Most people who tell you that "NAT provides security" think that NAT somehow drops packets, and if your network is actually targeted, this myth might well be the reason why someone ends up downloading all your files by connecting to your file server through your NAT gateway.
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
> They obviously can't address traffic directly to 192.168.1.0/24 over the Internet as that's a bogon address and the Internet routers will either reject it out of hand, or not know where to send it.

That's not obvious at all. Now, you obviously can't just inject a packet addressed to 192.168.1.1 anywhere on the internet and expect it to turn up on any particular LAN, but that just excludes a subset of the possible attack vectors for unwanted inbound connections.

Your ISP can still send you packets addressed to 192.168.1.1. Thus, obviously anyone compomising your ISP, or some subset of their routers can as well (hello Cisco hardcoded passwords!). Also, it has happened that ISPs failed to isolate customers from one another (think multiple customers on the same VLAN), so your neighbour could send packets addressed to 192.168.1.1 to your router's WAN interface as well. Or potentially malware on their network, if someone were to systematically exploit such a setup.

It isn't even unheard of that ISPs forgot to disable routing protocols on customer-facing interfaces and some CPE managed to advertise their RFC1918 space via RIP to their ISP's access network.

Or, for that matter, an attacker could just hook into your uplink between you and your ISP, if you are a valuable enough target, to gain access to your CPE's WAN interface.

All of those are actually solved security-wise by having a stateful firewall, which will also prevent inbound connections from anywhere else on the internet.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
> I wasn't quite precise, because there are cases where you do DHCPv6, but as Android doesn't support it the protocol is a bit dead in the water.

Arguably, it's alive and well for the use case where it actually makes sense: For prefix delegation.

> With IPv4 you are typically assigned a single IP address via DHCP.

Well, sure, and with IPv6 you are "typically assigned a single IPv6 address via SLAAC"!?

I mean, if you are talking about a controlled environment, that's not exactly difficult to achieve, by either using MAC-address based v6 addresses, or by configuring a fixed host suffix on the respective machine, just as you would configure DHCP. If you are talking about random people/devices on your network, neither case prevents them from assigning themselves whatever addresses they please.

> Filtering individual hosts by IP has always been leaky, but IPv6 makes it more or less impossible. You have to filter by subnet.

But that is what you are doing with IPv4 as well? Just because you can't see the individual addresses of individual machines, and thus have no other choice but to block the whole subnet (that is, the NAT gateway address that proxies for it), doesn't mean you aren't blocking whole subnets!?

> SLAAC didn't have a way to communicate the local DNS server address to hosts

Well, yeah, but that's been resolved, as you seem to know.

> nor a way for hosts to update the DNS with their selected addresses and hostnames.

Except it does? If you ask me, it does not make any sense for the DHCP server to update the DNS server anyway: It's the host that owns the host name and that knows where it is reachable, and also a host in principle could be getting its connectivity from anywhere, not just a particular fixed DHCP server. The host should have the credentials for updating its DNS name, should select the address to publish for inbound connections based on its local policy, and then publish that address to the DNS. It makes no sense to tightly couple naming services and connectivity: When my laptop switches from ethernet to LTE, it should just update its DNS name to point to the address it obtained from the LTE provider, and obviously that should not involve the DHCP server of the LTE provider.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
By that same logic, NAT provides internet connectivity. 99.9% of all NAT applications come with an internet uplink. Therefore, you need NAT for internet access. Not.
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
> It most certainly does.

No, it doesn't. It's a commonly believed myth among people who don't have a clue how IP works, though.

> If you have an insecure device behind a nat, say something with telnet sitting open, a port scanner from the outside won't be able to find it

Why not?

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
> How would you recommend doing it if not by ip?

Not at all, it's a stupid idea. You are trying to nail down an identity without authentication, that can not work. If you use credentials with sufficiently high entropy, which you should do anyway, you don't have a problem that this could be the solution to.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
> Another is that it changes the way you think about IP addresses,

Only if you don't have a clue of IPv4 either.

> with endpoints getting a /64 instead of a single address like you did in IPv4.

That's just wrong. And endpoint gets one address, just as with IPv4 (and can optionally assign additional addresses where address space is available, also just as with IPv4).

What gets a /64 by default is a link, like, an ethernet. Which is also exactly like in IPv4, except, of course, with IPv4 you had shorter/fewer addresses, and thus obviously also smaller prefixes/fewer addresses per link.

> This allows users to change their IP address for every connection if they want, so if you want to apply policy to them you need to apply it to the entire subnet they are on.

Which is also exactly the same as with IPv4. If your LAN has an IPv4 /24, you can also change you address for every connection.

> Granted, this also happens in IPv4 if you are doing NAT, so it's not really a change for most people.

You have it all backwards?! NAT is what makes this impossible for connections to the public internet, in that no matter how you change your RFC1918 address, you keep the same address to the outside world? But that obviously is not a property of IPv4, but of NAT.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on The Ripe NCC Has Run Out of IPv4 Addresses
Which would be about the most braindead reasoning ever?!
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on ICANN races towards regulatory capture: the great .org heist
> and Expanding a program to award .ORG prizes to promote the success and positive impact of non-profit organisations.

WTF?

So, non-profits collect donations from people who want to support their respective missions, and now these scammers come along and want to use a monopoly to redistribute those donations based on what they think who the donations should go to, and then even want to be recognized for their "work" of forcing the redistribution of donations?

If there is one thing the .org registry could do to "promote the success and positive impact of non-profit organisations", then that would be to optimize their business as much as possible and offer the cheapest domain registrations on the market, so that non-profits can keep as much of their money as possible to spend on their core mission.

Even these bullshit "promises" would still be blatant corruption, you really have to wonder how much of a moron Vint Cerf is for not seeing that.

zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on “Affordances,” a science-fiction story by Cory Doctorow
So, what, in your mind, qualifies something as totalitarian?
zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC··on “Affordances,” a science-fiction story by Cory Doctorow
Primarily, he seems to think that totalitarianism is not an acceptable solution to any problem. I happen to agree.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →