HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zazen

394 karma · joined November 5, 2014

submissionscomments
zazen··on Oil droplets guided by pilot waves do not give rise to double-slit interference
So, you don't actually have to regard BG and GB as separate cases if you don't want to.

People like to write the outcome space as ordered pairs BB, BG, GB, GG (ordered by age or whatever else), because this has the advantage that all four outcomes are equiprobable, so you can calculate probabilities just by counting.

If you prefer to regard the outcome space as unordered pairs {B,B}, {B,G}, {G,G} this is absolutely fine: you just have to bear in mind that the prior probability of {B,G} is 1/2, whereas it's 1/4 for the other pairs, so a tiny bit more calculation might be required.

P({B,G}| not {G, G}) = P({B,G})/(P{B,B} + P{B,G}) = (1/2)/((1/2) + (1/4)) = 2/3 as with the other method.

zazen··on The growth in passive funds has caused markets to become more correlated?
> I don't have time to explain it to you

Just read that phrase again and think about how it comes across.

zazen··on Raised by YouTube
I really like this idea, but there's one question that I always wonder how people doing this handle.

If your kids are not yet school age, and you plan to send them to school rather than home-school when the time comes: what's your plan for when your children and the other children realise this stark difference between their home environments? Your children will feel they're being denied wonderful entertainment that the other children are getting. Other children will mark out your children as outsiders. Based on my own childhood, I'm afraid I find it easy to imagine your children being ostracised and bullied over a thing like this. But even if they're not, won't they be screaming for TV every night?

(No children myself, I could easily be wrong about everything, honest question.)

zazen··on Niels Bohr’s Argument for the Irreducibility of Biology to Physics (1994)
The headline's use of the word "argument" rather implies that he did think he had a reason backed up by rational thought.

Like GP, I'm hoping someone with the time and inclination will summarise that argument for us.

zazen··on Proof Without Words: Gregory’s Theorem
I haven't previously come across the idea of trying to make wordless proofs. I guess this is the mathematical equivalent of code golf: a clever game for insiders to play, but basically the opposite of good practice from a readability perspective.
zazen··on Things I Never Knew About Las Vegas Until I Ran a High-Roller Suite
> some of this money will make it into hands of other people, but most of this is just removing value from society.

I'm not an economist, but... surely near-as-anything 100% of this money is going to other people? Some tiny fraction is paid to the electricity company to keep the lights on at the casino, and some tiny faction of that is the cost of the fuel that is literally burned for that purpose. I think basically the same goes for the various luxury consumables the casinos are comping to these guests. The actual cost of the base raw materials that are consumed is going to be tiny (relative to the huge sums being gambled, anyway).

Sure it would be better if these gamblers gave their money to science/charities instead. If you think you know how to convince them to do so, then go for it.

zazen··on How the City of London invented offshore banking
It doesn't mean greater London. It means the second and third things on your list.
zazen··on Survival Tips for Women in Tech
> how bad they are as measured by how much complaining we see about them. > common enough that ... people uovote them.

But you must have noticed that social media feeds on outrage? People amplify the extent of things they are shocked by, by sharing and upvoting. Looking at the amount of noise generated in media/social-media would be a very poor way of measuring the true extent of anything, but especially of something so politicized as harassment of women.

zazen··on Survival Tips for Women in Tech
Whether this is the norm for a large population of employers is a statistical question that you cannot "personally witness" even in principle. We desperately need a better way than anecdata to look at this.
zazen··on Mercedes Readies First Tesla Rival in $12B Attack
This sounds like a reasonable point to me, and I'm not sure why this and your other post in this thread are being down-voted.

Elon Musk might well be OK with Tesla cratering, provided he gets to make an electric-car-shaped dent in the universe in the process. But Tesla, the still-publicly-traded company, can't plan to fail.

zazen··on Meet the busser who’s worked at the same pancake house for 54 years
I'm sure that what he's saying is that this is a feeble way of complying, not that it's non-complying. The site has apparently chosen to simply block European users, and then to display the insultingly evasive and insincere corporatese message that GP quoted. If the site doesn't wish to take on the burden of complying with the GDPR in a meaningful way that allows access, they should say so honestly.
zazen··on Mastodon Is Better Than Twitter: Elevator Pitch
Yes, this seems to be broadly true. TIL about benefit corporations. I deeply apologize for my repeated rudeness towards your original post.
zazen··on Mastodon Is Better Than Twitter: Elevator Pitch
Ah, I finally begin to see what you mean. Sorry if I've been a bit boneheaded in this thread. I finally started googling instead of speculating, and I found this thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/law/comments/3pv8bh/is_it_really_tr... which seems to confirm your ideas about the significance of benefit corporations. It looks like the key legal case happened surprisingly recently - 2010.

Apologies again: you were right and I was blinkeredly literal.

zazen··on Napoleon Was the Best General Ever
I think you know that's not a reasonable thing to ask for a "proof" for.

On the other hand, anything which someone claims to have proved is a reasonable thing to expect a proof for.

I'm not the one throwing clickbait headlines around.

zazen··on Mastodon Is Better Than Twitter: Elevator Pitch
> A company is not legally obligated to maximize profit.

Well, if we agree on that core point - which I think is all the point that wool_gather was trying to make - then that's great! And I think there's no point in the two of us investing any more time in picking over quadrangle's slightly confused reply.

I'm afraid I can't resist pulling on one more little thread, though :-) You've sort of hand-waved "legal or financial trouble" together, but it seems to me that legal consequences are very different from other consequences, in that there has to be a legal basis for legal consequences. "agency theory and the norms of ordinary business" can't condense and resolve themselves into a law: there either is a law on the books or there isn't.

I understand that shareholder lawsuits are a thing that can happen under some circumstances. But if the law doesn't make "not maximizing profit" sufficient grounds, then it doesn't, surely?

zazen··on Mastodon Is Better Than Twitter: Elevator Pitch
Well, your wikipedia link seems to confirm my layman's understanding of the term "standing", which is that it is about a party's right to participate in a court case. I am no closer to seeing how the English phrase "you aren't prioritizing profit" could "have standing". I think quadrangle is confused in his phrasing, if not in his underlying ideas.

Of course investors may do various things. But we're particularly interested in the question of whether the company must legally maximize profit, even if not directed to do so by a majority of shareholders. wool_gather says no, quadrangle says yes, I wonder whether quadrangle in fact knows what he's talking about.

You say "Many of these don't involve the court, but some may." But the "some may" is kind of what we're trying to get into: if you like, the question is "can a shareholder successfully sue the company for not maximizing profit, even if a majority of shareholders haven't directed it to do so?". As far as I know, that's equivalent to asking whether the company has a legal duty to maximize profit.

zazen··on Mastodon Is Better Than Twitter: Elevator Pitch
"Legal standing" isn't quite the right phrase. I think you're saying the board does in fact have a legal duty to prioritize profit above all else?

If so, are you sure, and do you have sources? wool_gather said that "There's no categorical legal requirement for a company to make share value the absolute, #1 priority", despite a widespread belief to the contrary. And you seem to be just flatly contradicting him, without making any argument or providing any sources, which is... not the most helpful way of moving the conversation forward.

zazen··on Napoleon Was the Best General Ever
Well, if it's not a proof, then it's not a proof, right? You see more interest and creativity than I do in the article here, and that's fine. But surely that doesn't affect the fact that the title's claim to have proved Napoleon was "the Best General Ever" is a) a gargantuan overstatement, and b) unhelpfully provocative. People would probably be more charitable to the article if it hadn't totally misrepresented itself in this way.
zazen··on Napoleon Was the Best General Ever
Perhaps we could change the title to something less baity? I'm tempted to suggest "Military-themed toy data science project". But if there is more interest than that in there somewhere, then maybe a title that reflects whatever that may be?
zazen··on Bail has become a way to lock up the poor regardless of guilt or threat
OP does use the word "imprisonment", but I think it's possible he's actually asking about pre-trial incarceration. OP says he's from Europe, and a lot of countries don't have the jail/prison distinction as in the USA.
zazen··on New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving Isn’t So Easy
I think we have similar hopes for quality discussion in forums. And I certainly agree that a thoughtful response giving reasons why it's not as simple as "why can't we just" is more useful - assuming anyone feels inclined to write that response.

The problem I see is the following. The person who wrote the "why can't we just" has done next to no thinking of his own as to why the situation might be more complicated than his first thought suggests, but it goes beyond that. Someone who writes "why don't we just" is sending the signal that they're emotionally committed to the position that the solution _should_ be simple. If I take a deep breath and write a long, careful reply in response to the short, lazy "why don't we just" post, I'm not only taking on all the burden of thinking about the topic at hand, but there's every risk this will just be thrown back in my face by the poster who wants a shortcut to a simple answer. A "why don't we just" post has a poor chance of leading to a good discussion, and I think there will be overall more beneficial discussion on a forum if they are discouraged.

Some people are intellectually lazy. I think this is because it's easier to feel smarter when you think less. If there's a solution that seems obvious to Mr. A and he assumes everyone who missed it is a bozo, then Mr. A feels like a smart guy. If someone else comes along and starts telling Mr. A that actually it's not so simple, and there are reasons why the "obvious" solution isn't actually a full applicable solution, then Mr. A has to think harder, only to feel less smart as a result. A lot of people resist that. I don't know the full solution of how to inspire such people to start thinking more, but I think some push-back some of the time is part of the answer. A bit like when people come to stack overflow and ask for their homework to be done for them: it's good if they're prodded to try _something_ for themselves. Being "nice" and just doing their homework for them wouldn't be optimal.

Yes, "the world is complex" might not be ideal phrasing if you think it implies someone needs to grasp the entirety of that complexity. But I'm sure the poster who wrote that only meant to encourage Mr "why don't we just" to _start_ considering the complexity of the world.

zazen··on Ernst Dickmanns, a German scientist who developed self-driving cars in the 1980s
Well, you probably won't have to wait 10 years for another non-peer war like that.

I think he's envisaging a big peer war with mass mobilization ala WW1/WW2, but he imagines such a war would be like a big Iraq/Afghanistan. It wouldn't.

zazen··on Ernst Dickmanns, a German scientist who developed self-driving cars in the 1980s
You seem to have a war like WW2 in mind. But a war between big powers in the 21st century couldn't drag on for five years while you frantically work on new technology. Even without use of nukes, one side or the other is going to be flattened a lot faster than in the days when bombers used propellers.

Now, a new Cold War, that might push technological competition, although you won't get that "reset" of people's attitudes that you're after.

zazen··on New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving Isn’t So Easy
Perhaps it is used to stop thinking in some other circumstances, but I don't think that's what's happening here. When people make three-sentence internet comments featuring the phrase "Why don't we just", they often appear to have not yet _started_ thinking about the answer to their own question. I think it's fair to prompt them not to outsource all their thinking to the forum.
zazen··on 60 Years of Urban Change (2015)
> Maybe my browser is just not displaying things right.

Yah, there should be a slider... Initial view shows left half of the area from before, right half from after, and you drag the slider to change the ratio. You might want to reconsider your browser choice if it also failed to display the "how to use" instructions at the top right.

zazen··on Why I Don't Love Gödel, Escher, Bach
I was briefly very confused until I figured out you were correcting Themes to Themas, and the dropped "l" was just an accident!
zazen··on Thanks Economist, You Really Know What Has Gone Wrong with the Internet
HN is a fairly rare exception among news-commenting forums, in having a reasonable level of polite and intelligent discussion. Perhaps the Economist's forums were another such exception, I don't know. But I know that most newspapers' online comments sections are cesspools. I earnestly wish that ft.com, for example, would just eliminate its comment section. Every time I make the mistake of scrolling past the end of an ft article and into the comments, I regret it. Thoughtful articles are regularly followed by mindless dismissals from arrogant users. Questioning of the editorial stance is only valuable if it's done with a bit of intelligence.

Maybe the newspapers should decide to either "go big or go home" with their comments section. Either work hard to establish a HN-like community, with a working community moderation system and meaningful reply nesting, or abolish the comments section. I think abolishing comments is better than trying to have a comments section "on the cheap" which gets filled with low-quality content.

zazen··on Cities don't have to offer huge subsidies to companies like Apple and Amazon
> Let's just ban

It's rarely that simple. I don't know exactly how local government works in the USA, but I presume the federal government can't just summarily revoke powers from cities and states?

zazen··on I Wore an Expensive Watch While Traveling and People Treated Me Differently
This reeks of confirmation bias. The guy started with a stereotypical belief that rich people are really impressed by expensive watches, and by considering the times that he _just felt sure_ he was impressing people with his expensive watch, he felt able to conclude that his belief was correct.

On top of which, he kind of had to come to the conclusion that the watch makes a difference, in order to have an article to write. If he reported a negative result, he wouldn't get a lot of clicks for that.

zazen··on Useless design features in modern products
Yes, snopes is strange like that. You'd think a site dedicated to debunking stories would take care to be precise with the arguments it makes, but snopes often comes across a bit sloppy. But here they still are, after all these years, apparently king of the funny little niche of debunking urban myths!
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →