HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zeteo

7,291 karma · joined August 16, 2010

submissionscomments
zeteo··on Ethics in Strategy Gaming, Part 1: Panzer General
>Imagining yourself in the shoes of an evil person is a fundamental part of fiction.

As long as it's fiction, and you know they're evil. While I've personally greatly enjoyed Panzer General and its sequels, on a moral level the game differs very little from questionable post-war spin and propaganda. There is particularly an entire genre of problematic, self-serving Nazi general memoirs with themes such as:

- Minimizing, or even completely ignoring, the Wehrmacht's essential contribution to war crimes and the Holocaust: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wehrmacht#Criminal_and_genocid...

- Effectively promoting the myth of the superhuman Aryan soldier defeating vast hordes of subhumans. The original Panzer General takes this to a new extreme by making German units vastly superior throughout the war, down to the point where it's practically impossible to win the Battle of Berlin scenario as the Allies.

- Generally treating the entire war as an abstract Kriegsspiel that they'd have won through superior strength of intellect - if it wasn't for that bumbling incompetent at the top. PG is an ultimate fantasy in this regard, with Hitler being hardly mentioned and almost inconsequential (spend a little prestige and you'll easily get over his "bad" decisions at Kiev and Gibraltar).

It is actually possible to do better in a computer game. For instance, I've heard good things about Decisive Campaigns: Barbarossa. Apparently it lets you stand up to Hitler about war crimes at risk of losing essential resources and/or being dismissed, or choose to be complicit; and, at the end, runs you through the Nuremberg trials accordingly.

zeteo··on Effect of exercise training for five years on all cause mortality
I think that's a valid point but it may not make a significant difference. Judging by the fact that the control group had a pretty decent drop-out rate it appears that the drop outs reverted to lower than average physical activity levels. I am playing devil's advocate here, but you can't rule out the hypothesis that trying a bit of HIIT convinced more people to take it easy at their age.
zeteo··on Effect of exercise training for five years on all cause mortality
There's also some potential for selection bias in the drop-out rates:

>The numbers of drop-outs after one, three, and five years of follow-up were 76 (19%), 104 (26%), and 132 (33%) in the HIIT group, 58 (15%), 76 (20%) and 101 (26%) in the MICT group, and 61 (8%), 95 (12%), and 156 (20%) in the control group.

In other words, the entire observed effect may be due to HIIT being better at making unhealthy subjects drop out of the study.

zeteo··on Strongest opponents of GM foods know the least but think they know the most
You can hold an opinion as to whether it's a sound investment for yourself. E.g. Warren Buffett was, for a long time, notoriously reluctant to invest in tech.

I'm not sure I understand the counter-argument about vaccines. The crucial point there is herd immunity, which doesn't apply to many other fields.

zeteo··on Strongest opponents of GM foods know the least but think they know the most
You don't need to know a lot about something in order to reject it. If a Finance PhD calls you with a super complex investment strategy you have no obligation to put all your money into it. In fact, it's probably prudent to reject it out of hand.
zeteo··on The Science Is Clear: Dirty Farm Water Is Making Us Sick
> But they only test once monthly

The proposed FDA rules would have them taking 5 samples a year [1]. I agree that it would be great to have regulations that made produce safer, just not sure these are the right regulations.

https://www.fda.gov/downloads/Food/GuidanceRegulation/FSMA/U...

zeteo··on The Science Is Clear: Dirty Farm Water Is Making Us Sick
> The cost difference is 9 fold between the consumer-end medical expenses vs the producer-end safety testing.

This seems to assume that all outbreaks would be prevented by mandatory testing. However, the article says that the farm involved in the latest outbreak was already doing the same type of testing (on a voluntary basis). Clearly it's failed to stop at least one major outbreak. Maybe testing irrigation water is not actually that useful in preventing the consumer-end medical expenses.

zeteo··on Technology After the Great War
> The failure of most Europeans to fathom the potential for devastation of the new weapons they were constantly devising owed much to their conviction that no matter how rapid the advances, Western men were in control of the machines they were creating

While the technology was different, I'm not convinced that WW1 was truly more devastating than previous wars. The wars following the French Revolution lasted much longer and devastated Europe from Lisbon to Moscow. The Wars of Religion before that were probably even worse.

The fate of civilians, at least, was actually better in WW1 than in previous wars, as the armies were generally well supplied and disciplined and tried to behave in a "civilized" manner. As for the impact on soldiers, an Englishman fighting in Flanders in 1685 was just as likely to experience trench warfare [1], high explosives [2] and even chemical warfare [3] as his counterpart in 1915 - with far fewer comforts (medical care, consistent supply, news from home etc.).

The real question is not how the war became so devastating (it was like many other wars in this regard) but why it was expected not to be.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_Antwerp

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hellburners

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_warfare#Early_modern_...

zeteo··on The Chemists’ War
Chemical weapons, beyond their psychological effect, were not a game changer for either side in WW1. Effective countermeasures were developed rather quickly and, in any case, a breakthrough effected by poison gas could not be easily exploited.

Although not mentioned in the article, the main contribution of chemists to WW1 was almost certainly the Haber-Bosch process [1]. It allowed Germany to produce ammo and explosives even while cut off from Chilean saltpeter [2] and also sustained its agriculture in the absence of fertilizer imports. Without the Haber-Bosch process Germany could have afforded only a very short war [3]. It's still immensely important today as it produces over half of the nutrient received by the world's crops [4].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process

[2] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-31090757

[3] https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1920/02/03/118...

[4] http://vaclavsmil.com/wp-content/uploads/docs/smil-article-w...

zeteo··on Hedge Fund Uses Algae to Reap 21% Return
Strategy A: buy one random stock per year.

Strategy B: buy two random stocks.

If the expected payoffs were mathematically different then you'd have an arbitrage opportunity. Then apply induction.

zeteo··on Hedge Fund Uses Algae to Reap 21% Return
> That's if you have one trade per year. How would you model this if you have 25 monkeys throwing, say, 300 darts at the board per day, for every day that the market is open (252 days), for five years?

If the data is reported on a yearly basis then it's pretty much the same thing.

zeteo··on Hedge Fund Uses Algae to Reap 21% Return
Get 25 monkeys to throw darts at S&P 500 stock symbols on January 1st of each year. The chance that at least one monkey outperforms 5 years in a row is about 55%. (The target areas need to be proportional to market capitalization etc.)
zeteo··on 80-year Harvard study has been showing how to live a healthy and happy life
Thank you, moderator.
zeteo··on Hedge Fund Uses Algae to Reap 21% Return
Also there's a question of how many new hedge funds are using machine learning. If you have enough different attempts, one of them will beat the market by sheer game of chance. Picking out their specific quirks afterwards (algae etc.) is just survivor bias.
zeteo··on 80-year Harvard study has been showing how to live a healthy and happy life
> This sort of snarky comment that dispenses with the life work of others by means of internet clichés [...] specialists who worked in a field for decades

So if the work is so polished then it should be really easy to defend on its merits right? I find it curious that your main argument is instead about the work's authors.

zeteo··on 80-year Harvard study has been showing how to live a healthy and happy life
This reads like someone consciously decided "Hey, let's build the ultimate poster boy for bad statistical studies!".

1. Sample bias: "Why just study WEIRD [1] subjects? Let's do male Harvard graduates!" (Yes, half the study included inner city men, and one eighth of the duration featured women. It's still super heavily biased towards Harvard men.)

2. Correlation is not causation: "Hmm, health is correlated with relationship satisfaction. Could there be a common cause for both? Or maybe people like to hang out with healthier peers? No, the clear conclusion is that working on your relationships magically makes you healthier."

3. Inconsistent data collection: "Those '30s nincompoops were measuring skulls and handwriting. We'll stop doing that and take MRIs instead. But it's still the same study!"

[1] https://schott.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/14/weird/

zeteo··on Kindness is Underrated (2014)
> Bezos talks about a lesson imparted by his grandfather on one of the cross-country road trips they would take every summer: “Jeff, one day you’ll understand that it’s harder to be kind than clever.”

Sure, that's nice rhetoric. And yet the "kind" Bezos has presided over some of the worst working conditions in the developed world [1] while the "blunt" Torvalds has kept together the very scattered Linux team for decades without controlling their income or work conditions. Apparently the more money you have, the more you can get away with a "do as I say, not as I do" standard.

[1] http://www.salon.com/2014/02/23/worse_than_wal_mart_amazons_...

zeteo··on Why Tesla Is Worth More Than GM
> How did we end up with a digital economy dominated by a few big players? The simplest explanation focuses on what are called network effects

The simplest explanation is that antitrust enforcement started to lag in the '80s and became seriously deficient after 2000. Electricity, oil, telephony also had network effects.

zeteo··on Ends, Means, and Antitrust
> Citation?

How about Bork himself in 1963 [1]:

> The incipiency theory starts from the idea that it is possible to nip restraints of trade and monopolies in the bud before they blossom to Sherman Act proportions. It underlies the Clayton Act, the Robinson-Patman Act, and the Federal Trade Commission Act. [...] The courts have used the incipiency notion as a license for almost unlimited extrapolation, reasoning from any trend toward concentration in an industry that there is an incipient lessening of competition. [...] In case after case the FTC, for example, nails down its finding that competition is injured with the testimony of competitors of the respondent that his activities and aggressiveness may or have cost them sales. [...] When the head of the Antitrust Division or the FTC reports to a congressional committee, protocol requires that he wear a suitable number of bloody scalps of businessmen at his belt.

[1] https://www.scribd.com/document/117500897/The-Crisis-in-Anti...

zeteo··on Ends, Means, and Antitrust
> The spectrum shifted towards consumer welfare very early on

You seem unaware that Bork's Antitrust Paradox only came out in 1978 [1]. Yes, it's not surprising that its views would appear in cases from the '80s. Here's prof. Orbach in the Washington Post on Bork's influence [2]:

> Antitrust was defined by Robert Bork. I cannot overstate his influence. [...] Antitrust [in 1960] was about protecting small businesses. [Bork] built a full framework about how antitrust should be more about economic efficiency than about helping small businesses. [...] He wrote a sentence: Congress enacted the Sherman act [ed - the main antitrust act] as a "consumer welfare prescription.” The Supreme Court adopted that sentence in 1979. That is the stated goal in antitrust today. It is a big deal. A huge deal. In antitrust, it’s operational. Robert Bork defined it.

> In antitrust, antimonopoly law, it is easy to think about why big is bad. The view is, "Big businesses are bad. We should protect small businesses. We should not have big businesses." So that’s what happened in the history of the Sherman Act, between 1880 and 1960.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Antitrust_Paradox

[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2012/12/20/antit...

zeteo··on Ends, Means, and Antitrust
> The United States and European Union have, at least since the Reagan Administration, differed on this point: the U.S. is primarily concerned with consumer welfare [...] The European Commission, on the other hand, is explicitly focused on competition

What is missing here is that the US has diverged from a previously common interpretation. Between roughly 1890 (Sherman Act) and 1982 (Reagan administration antitrust guidelines) the US authorities were mainly concerned with competition too (breakup of Standard Oil: 1911; breakup of Bell System: 1984). As late as 2001 Microsoft had a serious brush with antitrust law for anticompetitive practices [1]. There's a case to be made that the US is currently just going through a lapse in enforcement.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....

zeteo··on Why Not Have a Randomly Selected Congress?
The justice system is not just one jury.
zeteo··on Why Not Have a Randomly Selected Congress?
> Do we want the statistical average of us to create laws that stick around for years?

People are judged everyday by their "statistical average" with consequences that can stick around for many years (long jail terms) or be permanent (death sentences). While the criminal jury system is not perfect, it appears vastly more functional than Congress at present.

The article also mentions Aristotle, and he identified three dimensions of discourse: logos, ethos and pathos. While elected congressmen may be a little better at logic (it's not like they're all rocket scientists), they appear to be quite deficient in ethics and not similar enough to the average constituent to truly empathize. Losing a bit of logos for big increases in ethos and pathos seems like a pretty good deal to me.

> Also, this would put enormous power in the hands of lobbyists

Not really, their main weapon are campaign contributions.

zeteo··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
> [Google's site] runs on their server [...] Micosoft runs their products like Windows and Office on YOUR machine

That's not a significant difference - Google's site renders on your machine too. Google's servers send you computer code (HTML, Javascript) and Microsoft's servers also send you computer code (Windows binaries).

> [Google's site] is free to visit

The use of API calls in Windows is also free. Would you be OK with Windows servicing Chrome and Dropbox several times slower than Microsoft products? There was a huge antitrust case about this in the '90s.

zeteo··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
> this result scares me [...] I never questioned that they had a right to do that. It is their website

Are you serious? By this logic Microsoft could do whatever they wanted with Windows. Yes, when you're big enough to absolutely dominate a market you can't just use that to make rules that kick out everyone else.

zeteo··on A ‘very credible’ new study on Seattle’s $15 minimum wage has bad news
Sure, but when the nominal increase is 18% and the selected group only shows 3% there's a big question about group selection. If you can cherry pick groups and variables then you can use phenomena like Simpson's paradox to prove pretty much anything with statistics.
zeteo··on A ‘very credible’ new study on Seattle’s $15 minimum wage has bad news
> raised the minimum wage from $9.47 to $11 per hour in 2015 and to $13 per hour in 2016.

> we conclude that the second wage increase to $13 reduced hours worked in low-wage jobs [...] while hourly wages in such jobs increased by around 3 percent.

Sounds like some pretty intense statistical manipulation. The second wage increase was ~18% ($2/$11) not 3%. So they've fished for a larger pool that only had a 3% increase in wage and arbitrarily designated these as "low-wage jobs". Also very conveniently they've chosen to highlight only the second wage increase; it sounds like no data massaging could make the first one look bad. If they were honestly aiming at statistical significance the best approach was of course to bundle the two increases together. An overall 37% change in minimum wage should have much clearer effects than its individual halves.

zeteo··on Social Cooling – How big data is increasing pressure to conform
> People are starting to realize that this 'digital reputation' could limit their opportunities. (And that these algorithms are often biased, and built on poor data.)

That's interesting of itself, but the bigger underlying issue is that opportunities are becoming more concentrated. When only a few companies dominate hiring in many fields, their mistakes get seriously amplified. Back in the day you were fine if Google's hiring process misjudged you - you could work for Excite or Altavista instead. Nowadays if some ML algo decides that people wearing blue sneakers are worse job performers you can get screwed (without even knowing why). And even worse, the major companies (where the jobs are) often share algorithms.

zeteo··on Amazon to Acquire Whole Foods for $13.7B
> How many companies have been "the unstoppable juggernaut" for 50+ years? AT&T isn't the AT&T from 30 years ago. [...] Microsoft was the unstoppable juggernaut... and then Apple and Google came along.

These are very good examples. However in both cases the decisive action was taken by federal antitrust enforcement. The Bell System was broken up by a consent decree [1] and Microsoft only dropped its aggressive Browser Wars tactics (e.g. giving IE special API access) after a major antitrust case [2]. It makes for a nice story, but in practice big companies are rarely (if ever) defeated by scrappy competitors / market forces.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakup_of_the_Bell_System

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....

zeteo··on Verizon closes $4.5B acquisition of Yahoo, Marissa Mayer resigns
> Our market cap has gone from $18B to $51B

> approximately 15 percent equity stake in China’s Alibaba Group Holding Ltd

15 percent of Alibaba is about $52.5 billion. I'm not sure why we're even discussing anything else. It's like saying that my contribution to family finances is:

a) not selling my parents' house, which is now worth half a million.

b) having $1.32 in change in a little ashtray by the door.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →