HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zeteo

7,291 karma · joined August 16, 2010

submissionscomments
zeteo··on A new report on a basic income scheme launched in Iran
> an abusive employer would be more severely punished by the labor market if the economic cost to the worker is diminished

> workers would also be more likely to create new businesses entirely if the personal financial risks associated with doing so were diminished

What kind of UBI are we talking about? If it's the one funded by dismantling the social safety net then no - you won't get more income when losing your job, because the same money is now spread among more people (most of whom still have a job). If it's in addition to the existing safety net, you'd get more of the same advantages by expanding unemployment benefits instead (make them higher / longer lasting / easier to obtain).

zeteo··on “Markets Today Are Not What We Believe” – The Façade of Competition
> The Mac/PC pricing thing was one travel site, and to my knowledge, this practice is limited to travel booking sites. Amazon prices may often be algorithmically adjusted, but not per-user.

Yeah why worry about it if it's only happening on travel booking sites? I mean, these practices would never be taken up by big companies with lots of data to really tailor prices per-user.

zeteo··on “Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell System Was in 1956″
Google Fiber is relatively small. Google itself was not a bad company when it was small ("don't be evil" and all that).
zeteo··on “Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell System Was in 1956″
Well how do we define a necessity? Running water, electricity and telephone service were all a luxury at some point. But now people have come to rely on them, to the point where it would be socially devastating to stop providing these services. Using an Internet search engine is no longer a luxury either. At the very least, Google should have a more transparent and accountable process, since a lot of people and companies have come to depend on its search engine functioning properly.
zeteo··on “Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell System Was in 1956″
Local politics might be bad, but it'd be far worse to have it run by Google. They'd never pick up your customer support calls; they'd be more concerned with using ML to figure out when you sh*t and when you shower (valuable data for advertisers, you see). Also they'd randomly remove you from the network all the time for no apparent reason.
zeteo··on “Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell System Was in 1956″
> There are other ways to build a business that don't depend on search.

There are also other ways to run a household that don't depend on running water. (Heck, my great-grandpa never complained about having an outhouse.) Are you saying your local water utility should be an unregulated monopoly?

zeteo··on The Theory of the Leisure Class by Thorstein Veblen (1899)
It's an amusing read, but he freely admits that he doesn't get Veblen and that is correct:

> Do I prefer terrapin à la Maryland to fried liver because plow-hands must put up with the liver—or because the terrapin is intrinsically a more charming dose?

This misses out Veblen's central argument in "The Theory". The terrapin is not intrinsically a more charming dose; in fact, many "uncultured" people would instinctively recoil at eating turtles. Same for other luxuries like lobster (a century ago, lobster was only fit for servants, and then no more than twice a week [1]). Ironically, fried fois gras is probably nowadays a more elevated dish than terrapin.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lobster#History

zeteo··on Ted Seides Concedes Bet with Warren Buffett
> If you have a couple million in the bank and are withdrawing 4% a year to live on, you're probably more concerned about the SP500 dropping 50%

And then you have illustrious hedge funds that go out of business when the SP500 suffers a small blip [1]. In any case, paying 2-5% to a hedge fund doesn't seem very good business when you're withdrawing 4% a year to live on.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management

zeteo··on Puerto Rico files for biggest ever U.S. local government bankruptcy
I'm not familiar with American Samoa, but generally states and countries with high minimum wages are doing pretty well economically, see e.g. [1]. States that have recently increased the minimum wage have seen higher economic growth than those that haven't [2].

[1] http://www.scholarsstrategynetwork.org/brief/evidence-higher...

[2] http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2014/07/19/332879409/...

zeteo··on Puerto Rico files for biggest ever U.S. local government bankruptcy
Minimum wage only causes unemployment if the labor market is competitive. This is not currently the case in the US as a few big companies (Walmart, McDonald's) have disproportionate market power, and most economic sectors are becoming even more concentrated. Under such oligopsony conditions, increases in minimum wage will generally come out of profits (which are at historically high levels of the GDP [1]). Since wages are spent locally, but profits not as much, minimum wage regulations should generally help the local economy.

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1Pik

zeteo··on The Ferocious Complexity of the Cell
> The "we could just simulate the whole brain down to the quarks" argument is an argument for the existence of AI. Nobody seriously suggests that it's the practical path forward to achieving it.

Yes, but you have to consider that funding will normally go to research programs that can show steady progress - even if it'll be 10 million times more work (of the same kind) to have a potentially useful result.

Here's the discoverer of the electron, J. J. Thomson, explaining it far better than I can:

“If you pay a man a salary for doing research, he and you will want to have something to point to at the end of the year to show that the money has not been wasted. In promising work of the highest class, however, results do not come in this regular fashion, in fact years may pass without any tangible results being obtained, and the position of the paid worker would be very embarrassing and he would naturally take to work on a lower, or at any rate, different plane where he could be sure of getting year by year tangible results which would justify his salary. The position is this: you want this kind of research, but if you pay a man to do it, it will drive him to research of a different kind. The only thing to do is to pay him for doing something else and give him enough leisure to do research for the love of it.”

zeteo··on Badly educated men have not adapted well to trade, technology or feminism (2015)
Tallulah, LA is 77% African American [1]. I'm surprised The Economist would publish this kind of victim-blaming about a very marginalized community:

> men like those of Tallulah [...] lack the resources of training, of imagination and of opportunity to adapt to the new demands

> poorly educated men are often much worse at things such as showing up on time and being pleasant to customers

> criminality, alas, remains an option for men of all skill sets

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tallulah,_Louisiana

zeteo··on The Myth of a Superhuman AI
> Right from the very first sentence the author seems to muddle the two, so I don't think there's much of cogent analysis in here.

If you read past the first sentence, it's quite obvious that the article is mostly concerned with claims of your type 2). Also I'm not sure why it would be so important to carefully separate the two categories of claims - they both rely on the assumption that AI can perform a wide variety of cognitive tasks better and cheaper than humans, which is addressed at length and cogently in the article. Also I believe that the economists you mention are concerned more about robotics than about AI per se, so I'm not even sure why you've brought in that point.

zeteo··on Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds
Looking at the funnel plot in fig. 3 in the linked meta-analysis [1], the high precision studies (standard error < 0.268) are clustered around an effect size of 0. The overall positive effect derives exclusively from the medium and low-precision studies, with several visible outliers well to the right influencing the mean significantly. The medium and low-precision studies had problems with one or more of the following:

"randomisation; allocation concealment; blinding of therapists (intervention supervisors); blinding of participants; blinding of outcome assessors; handling of incomplete data (use of intention-to-treat analysis); selective reporting and any other risk of bias." [1]

Also, the result was only statistically significant for poor quality control groups that didn't engage in any shared activity:

"When the control group involved either no contact (eg, waiting list, usual care; p<0.01) or education (eg, computer course, health lectures; p=0.01) the estimate was statistically significant. Where the control condition was exposed to an active control (eg, stretching; p=0.17) or social group (p=0.62), the effect size was still positive but no longer statistically significant." [1]

In summary, a few poor quality studies with large bias account for most if not all of the effect reported in this meta-analysis.

[1] http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2017/03/30/bjsports-2016-0...

zeteo··on Apple cuts App Store affiliate commission from 7% to 2.5%
"The rent of land, therefore, considered as the price paid for the use of the land, is naturally a monopoly price. It is not at all proportioned to what the landlord may have laid out upon the improvement of the land, or to what he can afford to take; but to what the farmer can afford to give." - Adam Smith

The App Store developers are now farmers on Apple's domain, and their landlord has figured out they can pay more.

zeteo··on Facebook and the Cost of Monopoly
>The result of monopoly pricing is that consumer surplus is reduced and producer surplus is increased; the reason we care as a society, though [..] is deadweight loss.

>Facebook may have a monopoly in social networking, and while that may be a problem for Snap or any other would be networks, Facebook would surely argue that the lack of deadweight loss means that society as a whole shouldn’t be too bothered.

Traditionally, the main issue with monopoly has been about suppressing competition and innovation, not about prices. Price analysis was at most an afterthought. Here's e.g. Woodrow Wilson [1] campaigning against monopoly in 1913 (he later created the FTC and signed the Clayton Act):

"Our purpose is the restoration of freedom. We purpose to prevent private monopoly by law, to see to it that the methods by which monopolies have been built up are legally made impossible. We design that the limitations on private enterprise shall be removed, so that the next generation of youngsters, as they come along, will not have to become proteges of benevolent trusts, but will be free to go about making their own lives what they will"

"Monopoly means the atrophy of enterprise. If monopoly persists, monopoly will always sit at the helm of the government. I do not expect to see monopoly restrain itself. If there are men in this country big enough to own the government of the United States, they are going to own it"

[1] https://archive.org/details/newfreedomcallfo00wils

zeteo··on Why 1866 Set the Stage for Two World Wars
It was a severe miscalculation. First, Germany already had a strategy to win the war - beat Russia first - and any attempt to knock out Britain at the cost of involving the US was a major distraction. Second, even if US troops took longer to arrive, the US Navy was ready to help defeat the submarine campaign right away [1].

[1] https://www.history.navy.mil/research/library/online-reading...

zeteo··on Why 1866 Set the Stage for Two World Wars
Agreed that the French mutinies presented a unique opportunity for the Germans but it's hard to predict how it would have played out. Would the Kerensky Offensive have done better if the Germans had sent more troops attack the French? Would the French troops have rallied if confronted with an actual German offensive?

Regarding 1918, the Germans were pushing so hard and getting stretched because the AEF was streaming in [1]. (American divisions were involved in plugging holes at the Second Marne BTW.) The Germans had a superiority of 300,000 men going into spring 1918, and inflicted 150,000 more casualties than they took during the Spring Offensive. Unlike 1914, there was no rush to beat the French before the Russians mobilized. If it wasn't for the US intervention, it would have been offensive after offensive until the Entente caved in.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Battle_of_the_Aisne

zeteo··on Why 1866 Set the Stage for Two World Wars
Correct, if Germany had continued Bismarck's foreign policy [1] then the next war (if it came) would have looked very different. Antagonizing Russia in the Balkans, France in Morocco, and Britain on the high seas were rather gratuitous moves between 1900 - 1914, driven by Wilhelm II's personality more than by any geopolitical factors.

It's amazing how much hubris it took to sink the Second Reich. As far as I can tell, Germany was on track to win the war as late as spring 1917. They had the resources and the right strategy: defensive in the West (retreat to the Hindenburg Line) and offensive in the East. The last crucial mistake was resuming unrestricted submarine warfare at the same time. This predictably drew the US into the war. By summer 1918, the benefits of defeating Russia and Romania in the East were nullified by American troops pouring in at a rate of 10,000 a day, and the war's outcome was pretty much sealed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinsurance_Treaty

zeteo··on Young White America Is Haunted by a Crisis of Despair
> Apparently you think that anything other than being at the peak of one's profession is a 'stupid job.' [...] Stop devaluing hard work just because some people choose predictability over risk.

The "stupid job" was what the kid himself called his employment making wooden pallets. It wasn't a job in sports or cooking and I nowhere implied that I agreed with his assessment. If he had been hard at work and passionate about a line cook job that didn't pay well, then we'd be having a totally different discussion.

zeteo··on Young White America Is Haunted by a Crisis of Despair
Yes, and winning the lottery is highly marketable too, isn't it? I didn't say working in sports, arts or cooking was a stupid job. The stupid job is what you get if you can't make any money using the skills you've developed.
zeteo··on Young White America Is Haunted by a Crisis of Despair
> Johnson started using opioids in high school after breaking his collarbone, first in football and again while wrestling [... T]hings slipped out of control after he graduated and found that his skills — art and cooking, but not academics — meant little in the workforce.

> At one point [... he] got a full-time job making wood pallets. [...] “It’s a stupid job. It doesn’t matter if you’re high to work it”

It's hard not to think the kid was let down by the system. It should be inconceivable that you can go through K-12 without being told very sternly that a) skills in sports, art and cooking are not very marketable, and will probably only get you "stupid jobs" b) in the current environment, even McD may require a college degree soon, so you'd better bite the bullet on those academic skills. Any adult in a position of responsibility should have known these facts. Yet for 12+ years they've failed to communicate them. The kids are allowed to drift aimlessly, and then it's somehow their fault if they end up in a very bad place at the end.

zeteo··on How the Airlines Became Cartels
> regulations that are less specific in the text of the law often yield cumbersome lawsuits and may end up with a huge volume of case law

Yes, but at least you have the chance beforehand that someone will say "this is not specific enough and will yield cumbersome lawsuits". If it's super long and complex then either a) there will be cumbersome lawsuits over parts of the law that are not completely consistent or b) the big guy with the big legal team will always win by default.

zeteo··on How the Airlines Became Cartels
Right on. The legislators who consult with lobbyists behind closed doors and then produce thousand page bills would argue that they also make "smart" regulation. Didn't they talk at length to the people who knew most about the issue? Doesn't the bill address lots of cases that would never occur to the "dumb" person?

Yes, but the bill is totally ineffective for the average person and only helps the big players.

What we arguably need is more "stupid" (as in "keep it simple, stupid") regulation. Constitutional Amendments are written in this style; also some antitrust legislation [1]. Complex regulations are vulnerable to

a) hidden flaws - that tiny exception in article 57 paragraph 30 might turn out large enough to overturn all 56 previous articles.

b) regulatory capture - lobbyists will, of course, introduce as many exceptions as possible if the text is long enough.

c) the revolving door - if only a small group of people know the intricate details, they will soon be hired by the affected companies at a multiple of their previous salary.

d) compliance cost - only large companies might be able to afford the compliance cost, which ends up concentrating the market further at the cost of the consumer (Dodd-Frank, anyone?).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act#Original...

zeteo··on Optical illusions that flummox computers
> The real issue here is that imagenet doesn't have enough funny glasses.

But we don't actually know the real issue, do we? You can't easily debug a neural network. Sure, you can throw ten times more data at it and hope that fixes it. But the more data you throw in, the less you understand what's happening - which affects your ability to anticipate the next problem.

zeteo··on 1950's tax preparation: plugboard programming with an IBM 403 Accounting Machine
Although not designed for it, old-school punched card machines were capable of pretty sophisticated computations. Here's a tidbit from Richard Feynman [1] on the crucial part played by IBM machines in the Manhattan Project circa 1945. They had even implemented a form of pipeline parallelism:

> Anyway we decided that the big problem--which was to figure out exactly what happened during the bomb's implosion, so you can figure out exactly how much energy was released and so on--required much more calculating than we were capable of. A clever fellow by the name of Stanley Frankel realized that it could possibly he done on IBM machines. The IBM company had machines for business purposes, adding machines called tabulators for listing sums, and a multiplier that you put cards in and it would take two numbers from a card and multiply them. There were also collators and sorters and so on.

> So Frankel figured out a nice program. If we got enough of these machines in a room, we could take the cards and put them through a cycle. Everybody who does numerical calculations now knows exactly what I'm talking about, but this was kind of a new thing then--mass production with machines. We had done things like this on adding machines. Usually you go one step across, doing everything yourself. But this was different--where you go first to the adder, then to the multiplier, then to the adder, and so on. So Frankel designed this system and ordered the machines from the IBM company because we realized it was a good way of solving our problems. [...]

> But one of the secret ways we did our problems was this. The problems consisted of a bunch of cards that had to go through a cycle. First add, then multiply--and so it went through the cycle of machines in this room, slowly, as it went around and around. So we figured a way to put a different colored set of cards through a cycle too, but out of phase. We'd do two or three problems at a time. [...]

> As the cards went through, sometimes the machine made a mistake, or they put a wrong number in. What we used to have to do when that happened was to go back and do it over again. But they noticed that a mistake made at some point in one cycle only affects the nearby numbers, the next cycle affects the nearby numbers, and so on. It works its way through the pack of cards. If you have fifty cards and you make a mistake at card number thirty-nine, it affects thirty-seven, thirty-eight, and thirty-nine. The next, card thirty-six, thirty-seven, thirty-eight, thirty-nine, and forty. The next time it spreads like a disease. So they found an error back a way, and they got an idea. They would only compute a small deck of ten cards around the error. And because ten cards could he put through the machine faster than the deck of fifty cards, they would go rapidly through with this other deck while they continued with the fifty cards with the disease spreading. But the other thing was computing faster, and they would seal it all up and correct it. Very clever.

[1] "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!", Los Alamos chapter

zeteo··on Optical illusions that flummox computers
Burying the lede:

> The fact that the same fooling images can scramble the “minds” of AI systems developed independently by Google, Mobileye, or Facebook, reveals weaknesses that are apparently endemic to contemporary AI as a whole. [...] “All these networks are agreeing that these crazy and non-natural images are actually of the same type. That level of convergence is really surprising people.”

zeteo··on Jeff Bezos’ Annual Letter
And how do you account for survivor bias? I don't think the CEOs of Blackberry or Nokia would have agreed that they cared less about the customer than Jeff Bezos. "Customer obsession" is not actual, actionable advice because it's not even measurable. It's nice rhetoric, but other companies were judged on hard metrics of profits and dividends.
zeteo··on Jeff Bezos’ Annual Letter
Conspicuously missing are a couple of other ingredients of Amazon's success. There are plenty of companies out there with "customer obsession" and a "day 1" mentality. There are few others with such good investor relations that money keeps pouring in after two decades of paltry or negative earnings [1]. With this kind of "infinite runway" you can sometimes afford to lose $100 million over three months to drive a competitor out of the market [2]. You can also afford to negotiate sweetheart deals with UPS and FedEx that will offer you delivery rates and speeds available to few other companies [3].

[1] http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/01/29/amazon_q4_pro...

[2] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2013/10/10/amazon_bo...

[3] https://sellerengine.com/should-you-use-amazon-discounted-up...

zeteo··on United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Failure
How many people have a) many thousands of dollars sitting around to pay for lawyers b) the requisite leisure to attend arbitrary court dates and locations c) the ability to deal with the loss of the above if the company wins the case based on some technicality? The company will happily take the proceeds from illegally squeezing the 99% who don't press charges to pay for the 1% who do.

Technically the blacks in the South had the right to vote after the Civil War. It took another hundred years of struggle to also secure the practical right. Theoretical rights don't matter much for those who can't exert them.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →