HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zeteo

7,291 karma · joined August 16, 2010

submissionscomments
zeteo··on United Passenger “Removal”: A Reporting and Management Failure
The subtext here is that customers don't have any actual rights when dealing with a large corporation. The terms of service have become so lengthy and obscure that it's virtually certain for a corporate lawyer to find some justification somewhere for almost anything. The corporate employees and the police both operate on this assumption. As a customer, your only recourse is to meekly accept whatever treatment is coming your way.
zeteo··on Twitter allegedly deleting negative tweets about United Airlines incident
The broadcaster has also spent billions for their network [1] but that doesn't absolve them from responsibilities. Like it or not, Twitter has become a major platform for public speech and it's practically impossible to pack up and take thousands and millions of followers elsewhere. So yes, they have a monopoly on a scarce public resource and should act accordingly. At the very least they should have transparency for their deleting and shadowbanning process. The people who've brought in thousands of followers and kept them on Twitter should have a minimum of rights too.

[1] https://www.cnet.com/news/fcc-rakes-in-45-billion-from-wirel...

zeteo··on Twitter allegedly deleting negative tweets about United Airlines incident
I think we should expect more, the same way we'd expect food producers to not poison us and truck operators to not run us over. Twitter has become a major platform for public discourse (including elections) and needs to at least have some transparency into their deletion and shadowbanning decisions.
zeteo··on Twitter allegedly deleting negative tweets about United Airlines incident
Twitter is a platform for people to communicate and you can't easily move your followers. This would be more like the giant local mall booting out shop operators based on their political views.
zeteo··on Twitter allegedly deleting negative tweets about United Airlines incident
> Tweeter and all others you mentioned are private corporations. Their goal is to turn profit to their shareholders - NOTHING MORE.

Not sure what that's supposed to mean. Would it be OK for a food company to use expired ingredients if it increased their profit, or for FedEx trucks to run over people if it helped their bottom line? Private corporations have various degrees of responsibility to the general public, depending on how much harm they can inflict. Twitter has become a major platform for public discourse and it's not like people can move their followers elsewhere. Using Twitter's power to suppress certain kinds of (otherwise acceptable) public statements should be a big no-no.

zeteo··on Twitter allegedly deleting negative tweets about United Airlines incident
How about some form of transparency at least when deleting undesirable statements? It's not like you can go and tweet to your followers somewhere else.
zeteo··on Twitter allegedly deleting negative tweets about United Airlines incident
Imagine if the local water or electric monopoly could vary your service by how much they liked your views. It's time for some antitrust regulation of the big tech companies. If you control a platform then you have an obligation to be fair to the general public.
zeteo··on Fact Check now available in Google Search and News
This is pretty naive. Do you think Google is now cross-checking news stories with the encyclopedia entries on vice presidents and nuclear fusion? Please go to factcheck.org, which is what they'll actually use. They're dealing with stuff that's almost exclusively like your item #4, and they'll definitely give it ratings. #3 and #5 are also much more open to argument than you want to admit here.
zeteo··on Fact Check now available in Google Search and News
Remember, we're talking about Google introducing fact checking. In this context, "fact checking is not enough" is a very different position from "fact checking is subjective".
zeteo··on Fact Check now available in Google Search and News
You can put spell checking into an algorithm. You can't reduce fact checking to an algorithm. How is this besides the point? The algorithm they have is "whatever websites X, Y and Z say".
zeteo··on Fact Check now available in Google Search and News
> Fact checking is like spell check.

No it's not. Spell checking relies on very precise rules. Fact checking relies on assessing context and, more often than not, the speaker's intention.

For example, let's take the statement "There are 300 million people in the US". Is this false? Well, it depends where I'm going with it.

If I was only relying on the figure as an approximation, I can say something like "therefore deaths from terrorism only affect 0.0x%, which is not something we should worry a lot about". This is obviously a factually valid argument, even though you might disagree with the conclusion b/c you think other facts are more relevant etc.

On the other hand, my argument can also be "and there were 300 million in 2007, therefore the population has been stagnant and we need to do something about it". This is factually quite false, since the population has in fact increased by ~18M.

Now should the original statement "there are 300 million people in the US" be rated true or false? A hostile fact checker may rate the first instance false, since there are actually 318+ million. A friendly fact checker will rate the second instance true b/c I obviously meant the rate of growth was low by historical standards etc.

zeteo··on The End of the Past
> Was the Roman economy only as developed as that of Europe circa 1300 or was it as advanced as that of western Europe on the eve of the Industrial Revolution in say 1700.

The question is ill posed. It assumes that economies move on a linear scale - with definite positive and negative directions. Was the economy of the Soviet Union in the 1930s more advanced than that of the Dutch Republic in the 1600s? Well, the USSR could produce tractors and icebreakers. But the Dutch had a stock market and a really good internal transportation network.

zeteo··on Every attempt to manage academia makes it worse
Kelvin taught at Glasgow, Brahe was a cathedral canon, and De Broglie did his best work for his PhD thesis.
zeteo··on Every attempt to manage academia makes it worse
I don't have a good theory - it's just based on reading biographies. Almost no famous thinkers lived on passive income (although, as I've said, annuities and bonds have been widely available for over 500 years). And probably not any kind of job will do. The most plausible explanation I've read belongs to Richard Feynman:

> I have to have something so that when I don't have any ideas and I'm not getting anywhere I can say to myself, "At least I'm living; at least I'm doing something; I am making some contribution" -- it's just psychological. When I was at Princeton in the 1940s I could see what happened to those great minds at the Institute for Advanced Study, who had been specially selected for their tremendous brains and were now given this opportunity to sit in this lovely house by the woods there, with no classes to teach, with no obligations whatsoever. These poor bastards could now sit and think clearly all by themselves, OK? So they don't get any ideas for a while: They have every opportunity to do something, and they are not getting any ideas. I believe that in a situation like this a kind of guilt or depression worms inside of you, and you begin to worry about not getting any ideas. And nothing happens. Still no ideas come. Nothing happens because there's not enough real activity and challenge

http://www.pitt.edu/~druzdzel/feynman.html

zeteo··on Every attempt to manage academia makes it worse
Well, Lavoisier's tax farming was not passive income: "Lavoisier's researches on combustion were carried out in the midst of a very busy schedule of public and private duties, especially in connection with the Ferme Générale." [1] The gentleman scientists were also usually involved in some sort of business, even if it was just administering their estates. The people who truly had a passive income - relying on annuities or government bonds, mostly inherited - are hard to spot in the history of science. They were a pretty numerous class though [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antoine_Lavoisier#Gunpowder_Co...

[2] https://douthat.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/04/25/piketty-and-the...

zeteo··on Every attempt to manage academia makes it worse
Note that having a job seems necessary though. Maybe it's a case of the golden mean? On one side you have people whose job absorbs all leisure. On the other you have some who draw sufficient income without having a job at all. These are Marx's infamous "coupon clippers", and historically they're not as prominent in intellectual history as people with undemanding jobs (personally I'm not aware of many philosophers / scientists who were rentiers). If leisure was the only variable, we'd expect people with guaranteed incomes (annuities, for example, have been sold since the Middle Ages) to have been the most prolific thinkers of history.
zeteo··on Every attempt to manage academia makes it worse
There's a long tradition of important advances in knowledge being made by people with an undemanding job [1] [2]. The 19th century university became a hotbed of research because the teaching workload was relatively light and they didn't require that you also did research.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parson-naturalist

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baruch_Spinoza#Lens-grinding_a...

zeteo··on Men Without Work
In addition, "workfare" is a well-tested approach that has given good results in the past [1] [2]. What's to stop someone on UBI from joining a gang, anyway?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Works_Administration

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Writers%27_Project

zeteo··on Harvard Thinks It's Found the Next Einstein – And She's 23
At the age of 23 Einstein had just found a boring job, out of the public eye, that left him plenty of time to dream and think big thoughts [1]. Untimely attention from Harvard might well have ruined all gifts he was about to give to physics.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annus_Mirabilis_papers#Backgro...

zeteo··on An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments (2013)
I've never found these lists particularly constructive. If someone makes an error in logic you should be able to take it apart from first principles. Memorizing dozens of vague "fallacies" seems more like a cheap way to try to "win" debates. It will not lead to better engagement with an opposing argument. Existential Comics had a pretty funny take on it: http://existentialcomics.com/comic/9
zeteo··on Amazon, the world’s most remarkable firm, is just getting started
> Monopolies are not illegal in the United States. Monopolization is illegal

Next up: the 18th amendment did not implement Prohibition, since it still allowed alcohol consumption; it merely forbade obtaining it.

The links present a unilateral view of the issue, mainly from lawyers defending big companies. Here's the other side from our longest serving Justice, William O. Douglas [1]:

"We have here the problem of bigness. Its lesson should by now have been burned into our memory by Brandeis. The Curse of Bigness shows how size can become a menace - both industrial and social. It can be an industrial menace because it creates gross inequalities against existing or putative competitors. It can be a social menace - because of its control of prices. [...] That power can be utilized with lightning speed. It can be benign or it can be dangerous. The philosophy of the Sherman Act is that it should not exist. For all power tends to develop into a government in itself. Power that controls the economy should be in the hands of elected representatives of the people, not in the hands of an industrial oligarchy. Industrial power should be decentralized. It should be scattered into many hands so that the fortunes of the people will not be dependent on the whim or caprice, the political prejudices, the emotional stability of a few self-appointed men. The fact that they are not vicious men but respectable and social minded is irrelevant. That is the philosophy and the command of the Sherman Act. It is founded on a theory of hostility to the concentration in private hands of power so great that only a government of the people should have it."

[1] http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/334/495.html

zeteo··on Amazon, the world’s most remarkable firm, is just getting started
I'll try again to restate the big picture and see where we disagree:

- monopolies are illegal since 1890

- excepting natural monopolies (utilities), which are strictly regulated instead

- since the 1980s, also excepting companies that keep prices low for the end consumer. This is the space where Walmart, Amazon and Uber have grown. But, if they try to raise prices substantially OR if enforcement guidelines become more strict again (b/c politics), these giant companies can get into giant legal trouble (see: break-up of AT&T).

Are we in disagreement an any of these points? If you think unregulated monopolies were OK before 1985, can you give any examples? Same for post-1985 unregulated monopolies that raised consumer prices?

zeteo··on Amazon, the world’s most remarkable firm, is just getting started
You are correct that natural monopolies are allowed to exist under US law, but the trade-off is that they're strictly regulated. Each state has a utilities commission, usually appointed by the governor.
zeteo··on Amazon, the world’s most remarkable firm, is just getting started
There's nothing in the FTC link that says monopolies are not illegal. In fact they say this:

> The Sherman Act outlaws [...] any "monopolization, attempted monopolization, or conspiracy or combination to monopolize."

If you look at any felony e.g. selling hard drugs there are always mitigating circumstances and exceptions - but they don't invalidate the general rule. The text of section 2 is pretty clear that monopolies are generally illegal.

zeteo··on Amazon, the world’s most remarkable firm, is just getting started
The laws are very strong. Back in the day, they would block a merger if it affected 7% of a market, and vertical integration was a big no-no. None of those laws have been repealed. The enforcement guidelines were weakened during the Reagan administration (a big factor in the rise of e.g. Walmart) but they're still strong enough to block plenty of mergers and allow the occasional Sherman Act prosecution. I agree with you that it's a lack of political will, but politics has been very unpredictable lately.
zeteo··on Amazon, the world’s most remarkable firm, is just getting started
Maybe some people think monopolies are OK but the law says they aren't: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act#Original.... Are you suggesting a legalization campaign for monopolies?
zeteo··on Amazon, the world’s most remarkable firm, is just getting started
What people also don't seem to realize is that the US has serious anti-monopoly laws on the books (even if enforcement has been kinda lax lately). Remember Microsoft in the 90s? With Amazon running many competitors' infrastructure (e.g. Netflix is on AWS, FBA shenanigans etc.) I wouldn't be surprised if it got hit with some legal action aimed at breaking it up at this point.
zeteo··on Modern JavaScript for Ancient Web Developers
> The sheer number of tools and plugins and packages and dependencies and editor setup and build configurations required to do it “the right way” is enough to stall you before you even get started.

At some point you have to ask yourself how much of this is good engineering (does it help the end user?) and how much it's just having fun and impressing fellow engineers. Is the complicated build process worthwhile just to obtain a nicer syntax (for the current definition of "nicer")?

zeteo··on The US Supreme Court is hearing a case about patent law’s “exhaustion doctrine”
For another famous example, the Wright brothers spent most of their latter life litigating patents [1]. Who knows what other great things they might have invented otherwise.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_brothers#Patent_war

zeteo··on Aristotle's influence on computational thought
> The history of computers [...] is better understood as a history of ideas, mainly ideas that emerged from mathematical logic

I have an advanced degree in CS and have done my fair share of theory, but ideas from logic are the cherry on the cake and did not create the computer. The real unsung heroes are those who invented relays, amplifiers and punched card machines. Babbage had a design in 1840, Boole had a theory in 1850; but without components neither of them made practical impact, and became nearly forgotten.

Once relays etc. became widely available in the 1930s it was anyone's game. Konrad Zuse built his first machine in his parents' apartment [1]. Feynman did complex computations at Los Alamos with punched card machines. And, as the article mentions, Shannon created a theory of relay circuits because they were already building complex circuits.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Konrad_Zuse

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →