295 karma · joined August 4, 2023
I agree with you that it seems that there might be something missing from the story.
The standard response and advice of talking to a lawyer I think is still good and stands regardless of how full or truthful the OPs account of the situation is.
I don't personally think that most university staff in the US are out to get people in this way either, so either there is something about the story we are missing, or this is a really big deal and this particular university is out of control.
My experience in university in the US was never this dramatic and I didn't see actions like this taken (but I also never constructed a project of this nature that is directly related to the university beurocracy).
In other words, this is kind of weird in a US context too and I feel the same weirdness about it that you are probably feeling viewing from the EU.
So US educational institutions don't really have any hangup against treating sports any differently than they might treat a CS class.
They are a subject you have to study and train at...and sometimes sit in a theatre and have a class time about (watching scout footage or deconstructing plays, etc).
Sports are probably just as rigorous as anything else academically once you get to something approaching a division 1 level of play. The reason we don't recognize it is because we suck and are mostly casual about it on a forum like this (filled with sports failures like myself or sports non-participants). The people actually in these programs with D1 scholarships and whatnot I guarantee take it as seriously as you or I would take calculus.
It makes sense if you do the math.
Newer schools and smaller schools, typically not so much.
A lot of what we do in the US probably sounds batshit insane to outsiders so no worries about that and thanks for asking!
There are a lot of moral conundrums that are just not going to work out with this. Seems like an attempt to just offload liability and it seems like pretty much everybody has caught onto that as being it's main selling point and probably main thing that will keep it from ever being accepted for anything important.
I don't believe AGI is possible but if it was and it was as subjective as you say what is and isn't conscious, then it starts to take on an even more altogether evil character.
Akin to cloning slave humans or something for free cheap labor.
See https://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/fair-use/four-factors/
I think in particular it fails the "Amount and substantiality of the portion taken" and "Effect of the use on the potential market" extremely egregiously.
I work in a pretty niche field and feel the same way. I don't mind sharing my writing with individuals (even if they don't directly cite me) because then they see my name and know who came up with it, so I still get some credit. You could call this "clout farming" or something derogatory, but this is how a lot of experts genuinely get work...by being known as "the <something> guy who gave us that great tip on a blog once".
With AI snooping around, I feel like becoming one of those old mathematicians that would hold back publicizing new results to keep them all for themselves. That doesn't seem selfish to me, humans have a right to protect ourselves and survive and maintain the value of our expertise when OpenAI isn't offering any money.
I honestly think we should just be done with writing content online now, before it's too late. I've thought a lot about it lately and I'm leaning more towards that option.
I think they should clarify whether they want somebody that has passed a linear algebra class with high marks based on something like strangs' entry level book before...or are on the cutting edge of graduate level linear algebra research. It's not clear from the post and I suspect that might be an issue.
Give me a couple months and I could recite strangs entry level textbook. I passed that class with an A+. But I could not become a PhD level maths student with a linear algebra research focus in that amount of time.
There are multiple very different ways to interpret a requirement for being competent in linear algebra.
Knowing everything covered in strangs introduction to linear algebra is actually quite low on the potential list of requirements and could be self studied.
Totally different markets. You wouldn't be interested in that job, and they wouldn't want to hire you even if you were interested. Even the tone of your post makes that obvious.
We should be discussing early to mid career folks from somewhere other than silicon valley startup or big web tech land. Aka "meat and potatoes" tech jobs. That is what's being discussed.
I don't know what their problem is with hiring either and I agree with you that it could be partially compensation related. But not being able to compete with Silicon Valley on compensation is not where I would be going with that argument....I think it's more likely to be related to environment and interview style and notions of what "experience" means. In other words...bad hiring practices...not necessarily raw compensation issues. The compensation for non "big tech" firms can sometimes be quite good in comparison to other career paths especially when located outside of the valley, so being unable to hire talent makes me suspicious of hiring practices more than compensation (assuming they are reasonably large and hit market rate for the area and are in a reasonably large metro).
Just my two cents.
What people want or deserve is irrelevant. If you live elsewhere and feel you deserve more, then that's not America's problem.
Seems that there is no way you could possibly determine that given the circumstances besides speculating about supply and demand.
In the before times the terminology came from system 360 and descendent mainframe systems where the system programmers tended to be intimately involved with the deployment and programming of the operating system and associated "exits", and such tasks tended to presume some working knowledge of assembly language (operating systems were very crude at that time...and many shops tended to "customize" them if that makes sense...you would sometimes have serious problems with operating system level things and at that time the generic response would be "contact your systems programmer", who would either fix it or get in touch with IBM...so TLDR is basically a sysadmin that is good at assembly). Big companies could afford to have systems programmers on staff and needed them because every shop was different and computers were very custom and crude at that point in history.
That's where the terminology came from originally but now it has expanded and can mean different things.
The "systems programmers" terminology was mainly just a differentiation from the more generic "application programmers" (who would probably program in COBOL or something similar, doing business related tasks) or "system operators" (who would not usually be programmers at all, and would do a lot of what we would now consider sysadmin work).
Nowadays it just means anything that isn't bog standard CRUD or frontend web app stuff. The terminology has evolved but has a somewhat similar meaning to when it originated. It's tough to understand exactly without the historical context which is why I have included that.
For obvious reasons, this has some overlap with the more modern definition of "programmers that build systems that other programmed then use". Because the application programmers on those mainframe systems would be relying on the systems programmers to not screw up their assembly wizardry or else everything would fall apart.
In traditional web serving tasks and particularly for commercial cloud providers (usually renting out VM time), this isn't the case, and so I'm sure Ampere will be successful in that space.
You sound well aware of the fact that being able to put out working python code doesn't necessarily mean you fully understand all of the best practices and idioms that the particular community uses, and that's okay. You are aware of your weakness.
If you were stuck in "tutorial hell" but thought you knew the language, then maybe that would be Dunning-Kreuger. Or if you were unaware of your not writing idiomatic code due to coming from a different language and being new.
Eventually most seniors should come to the realization that expecting there to be a "senior" oriented platform is unrealistic for a variety of reasons (mostly, because the exercise based nature of platform learning in the beginner sense just isn't the sort of thing you need to learn to become senior level in a language and isn't super useful to seniors coming from other languages...).
A real senior that is really trying to learn a new language or ecosystem to a reasonable amount of competence should start with the docs and with a small (but sizeable, enough to have to learn the languages tooling and whatnot) project.
I shouldn't even comment on this, but if you expect there to be video tutorials for the kind of thing you are trying to learn, then maybe you have experienced some form of title inflation. Eventually, people need to learn to read the (f'ing) manual, and I hate to say it like that because it's infamously toxic when inappropriately told to beginners as advice, but it's the truth for somebody that calls themselves a senior.
But what do you think you are getting out of a "platform" when it comes to learning a language?
I agree with keyle that you'll learn more working on a real project than doing a platform curriculum that is usually designed around beginners.
Just my personal hot take. I like exercise I suppose if that's the sort of thing you really think would be helpful.
The only reason I'm giving you this answer is cause you said explicitly "for senior devs". I don't really know any senior devs personally (that would admit to) using "platforms" or exercises to learn new languages. For me, I open up the docs and start writing a project, and I think that usually gets the job done learning a new language a bit faster.
Most platforms are way too beginner oriented, and you'll rarely get anything that requires more than a small amount of code...it's tough to learn a language very well until you have more than say 1000 lines and are seeing how the tooling and modules and whatnot really work on a realistic size of project...
Totally agree about how women should go to school of course. I'm not sure there was anybody in this chat or the article really questioning that, but you made a good case for it anyway.
I think it's bad to give amphetamines to kids...full stop. But it isn't similar to castration or a lobotomy or even in the same order of magnitude in terms of long term irreparable effects.
Stimulant drugs of that nature tend to be more tolerable than opiates or benzos or a lot of other drugs often prescribed for common mental illnesses (and often to kids).
My issue with the whole discussion is not that we shouldn't take a hard look at our amphetamine prescribing tendency and try to resolve the underlying issues instead of putting on a drug band-aid...my issue is that it is implying some sort of long term catastrophic damage for kids or adults that may have undergone that sort of treatment in the past. And it's asking them to start adopting a blame mentality and potentially start using this great potential (imagined) future that was robbed of them as a coping mechanism.
They aren't mentally handicapped, and they shouldn't think of themselves as being the equivalent of somebody that's been castrated or lobotomized and therefore permanently mentally disabled in some way.
Yes, giving amphetamines on a regular basis to kids is mind blowing. It's also not the end of their lives.
I suppose I'll leave it at that.
If those don't terrify you then I guess we just don't really have similar temperament as people and that's totally okay with me. I did enjoy discussing it with you.
That doesn't make me some fancy scientist level programmer (I'm definitely not) that I often find my attempts at using AI falling into that category...a lot of the time it's just due to niche platforms and libraries and things that are specific to our shop or the regulatory environment or a thousand other issues of that nature. I imagine that similar issues are incredibly widespread for basically anybody that is not doing greenfield work that is somewhat isolated and at young companies and isn't spending tens of millions to do custom training on their specific environments.
The whole "everything web, most everything open source, ship ship ship new code" style work environments you tend to find among young start ups are not as common as I think they seem if you guage your view of technology jobs based off of hacker news. Given that most of the training of the most powerful models is basically scraping the web, it's not at all surprising that they are seriously lacking in other areas. And I'm not sure to what extent they can seriously be expected to improve there...besides the obvious issue of uploading internal documentation to give an external LLM better prompting...the thing has still got to be able to use public training data to make predictions about internal libraries and whatnot that may very well be old or anachronistic or batshit crazy, because the difference in volume of data between say your internal software and everything posted publicly on the internet is massive.