2,071 karma · joined August 8, 2017
meet.hn/city/ca-Kelowna
Socials: - github.com/ziofil
Interests: Science, Startups, Technology, Research, Programming, Philosophy, Jazz, Chess, AI
---
Unfortunately the typical CHSH inequality is not beginner-friendly because there are a few conceptual steps chained together before one can understand the whole idea. However one can rewrite it in terms of a game. Here's the GHZ game, which is about 3 particle entanglement and the classical/quantum separation is much more clear. Here it is.
There is a team of three players and a referee. The players can agree on strategies all they want, but during the game they cannot communicate. The referee sends a challenge bit to each of the players, so the referee emits the three bits (r,s,t). They all have to reply with a bit, so the referee receives the three bits (x,y,z). The players win the game if r AND s AND t = x XOR y XOR z. The best they can hope to do if they have access to classical resources is to win 75% of the time. BUT if they share a certain 3-qubit state, they are allowed to make measurements of their qubit and base their answer on the measurement outcome. Well, there is a quantum strategy that lets them win 100% of the time.
There is no collection of 6 bits (challenge and reply) that makes you win 100% of the time. So the utter magic of entanglement is that the VALUE of the outcomes of the measurements cannot be thought of as pre-existing the measurement. Because if it did there would be no way to win 100% of the time.
The two questions to ask are "Are you the lying coin flipper?" and "Are you the honest coin flipper?". These are answered as (NO, YES, NO) and (NO, YES, YES), respectively, by the (honest, lying, coin flipper) goblins.
In the best case we identify a non-flipper goblin on the first try (depending on which question we choose to ask) and then we can assign all three identities with just another question. In the worst case, we need to ask the same question to a second goblin in order to identify a non-flipper goblin, and then the other question to one of the two unidentified ones.
I have the gut feeling that until a model allows for a small probability that 2x3 is 7, there will always be hallucinations. Probabilities need to be clamped to zero to emulate symbolic behaviour.
I can post the solution in 24h. Have fun! ^^
While I appreciate the blog post, it seems a bit disingenuous. I hope everyone understand that if you take two entangled photons A and B and detect A before B, then the outcome of the measurement of B must depend on the outcome of the earlier measurement of A, because measuring A causes the collapse of the joint state and determines the wavefunction of B undergoing the later measurement.
The MAGIC about delayed choice measurements is that they work even when the temporal order is UNDETERMINED. By this I mean that the two measurements of A and B can be set up to occur so close in time to each other that there is no time for a signal travelling at the speed of light to travel between the two events. Under this condition, you can witness both orderings (A measured before B and B measured before A) just by changing your reference frame. Under these conditions, the delayed choice experiment STILL WORKS!
In this case, there cannot be any argument like "but the idler was measured first", because "first" does not make any sense.
You’re welcome.