HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zkldi

1,734 karma · joined March 10, 2021

aspirant
submissionscomments
zkldi··on Exploring System76's New Rust Based Desktop Environment
That padding is genuinely terrible.
zkldi··on What NPM should do to stop a new colors attack
To be clear, you can't edit an existing published version of a package on NPM, nor can you delete packages (havent been able to for 5 years-ish).
zkldi··on What NPM should do to stop a new colors attack
This is following semver correctly. A PATCH update may be a MAJOR update (since its a superset) and it may be considered a breaking change.
zkldi··on What NPM should do to stop a new colors attack
What if the patch for the buggy `2.14.0` library was released as `3.0.0`? In semver MAJOR can be a superset of MINOR and PATCH, so this is a perfectly logical semver operation.

You still have the exact same problem you described with `^2.14.0`. Someone would have to manually update the package to get the security fix in 3.0.0.

Unless you're suggesting code should also automatically update major versions aswell?

zkldi··on Dev corrupts NPM libs 'colors' and 'faker', breaking thousands of apps
Yes, but it's not granular. You either let all modules have permission X, or none of them.
zkldi··on Systemd, 10 years later (2020)
I mean, emacs doesn't respect the UNIX philosophy either, but that's one of the most praised pieces of software to come out of the UNIX space.

The UNIX philosophy isn't meant to be taken as gospel - hell, it's very hard to define what "doing one thing" even means.

zkldi··on Ask HN: Why is today's Internet experience so user hostile?
> There was a movie where a guy got out of prison after a lengthy sentence and his words seem to ring more true to me each and every day: "The world got itself in a damn hurry and it seems there is no place now for a feeble old man like me"

Shawshank?

zkldi··on Running your own email is increasingly an artisanal choice, not a practical one
> To say the biggest source is Gmail might be technically wrong though - I suspect there's a large volume of spam that Migadu (my provider) is dropping before it even reaches my inbox, i.e. emails that it is 100% sure are spam and it can just drop. Nevertheless, an overwhelming amount of spam I observe/have to deal with is coming from Gmail. Second to that is outlook/hotmail.

This. It's more likely to be survivorship bias -- the gmail emails happen to survive because gmail is more trusted.

zkldi··on /tap – Powerful and customizable note-taking system
This has to be one of the most overdone comments on this site -- Not everything even slightly critical of a product is like the dropbox reply.
zkldi··on An NFT without a blockchain
The benefit of no store commissions is immediately negated by gas fees.

Public Metrics on usage is already possible without the blockchain, you can do this with a centralised database and an API. If your retort to this is "what if steam change your progress underfoot?", that is nonsense because they gain absolutely nothing from doing that except annoying users.

No country, age or identity restrictions is a disaster. The age one primarily, since it is necessary to require age restrictions on things like online gambling for ethical reasons.

Also, what the hell do NFTs have to do with implementing joystick input?

zkldi··on An NFT without a blockchain
> Yes? Why wouldn't that work?

Because videogames are different? There's absolutely no logic connecting items in one game to another in almost all cases. As such, the set of items the developers would actually want to implement (ever) would be only those that make sense inside their game, and they'd have to reimplement the models and statistics.

Even more so, the effort necessary to implement new items in any game means that they'll only ever bother with the most expensive items (that also happen to make sense within their world), which restricts the set of items *massively*. Oh, and the developers get absolutely nothing back for doing this except a PR disaster.

Furthermore, it's entirely centralised anyway. You have to trust the game client to interpret 0x1fabc3... as $ITEM when the game client could completely lie and change what item that corresponds to, or how useful it was. This is quite literally just an expensive API call.

NFTs serve literally no purpose here. There's no decentralisation, there's no reason why items in videogames should ever be cross-compatible anyway (It's literally like asking why you can't write C# and Haskell in the same file and just have it work).

zkldi··on An NFT without a blockchain
Do people on HN not play videogames at all?

Shovel Knight didn't get popular because it was crossed over into so many games, Shovel Knight got incredibly popular for being one of the best platformers of the decade that kept releasing high quality free DLC.

It was notorious for being a kickstarter that actually gave back. The reason it ended up in so many other games is because it was so popular. The exact same thing happened with UNDERTALE.

> Now imagine an NFT collection that's popular enough to have multiple games wanting to incorporate it into their games(...)

This was *already done* with amiibos. They just weren't NFTs, and were infinitely more efficient. Literally any game developed for the switch has an api to interact with amiibos, the names in amiibos are some of gamings largest characters, and barely anybody uses it.

You are seriously detached from what gamers actually want if you think they'd react positively to Bored Apes being put in WoW. Not only would it be a PR nightmare for the developers of WoW, but they would quite literally gain nothing from it except an expensive, comically inefficient lookup table of hashes to items they don't care about.

zkldi··on An NFT without a blockchain
This idea doesn't work at all. For your dota skin to work in world of warcraft, the developers of WoW would have to acknowledge that 0x1fab... corresponds with $ITEM in $GAME and then spend the time actually implementing that item in the game.

Since that would take an inordinate amount of effort for *absolutely no benefit for WoW or Dota*, this would only ever feasibly be used *between games made by the same company*, which at that point they would just use a centralised database for obvious reasons.

The Movable-Game-Assets thing has been done before on a huge scale by the biggest gaming company in the world, with nintendo's Amiibos. Look at how they turned out! Barely any games on the switch actually support the full set of amiibos, and those that do don't give much. Amiibos already implement the exact thing you're talking about without any blockchain at all.

zkldi··on The Fastest FizzBuzz Implementation
Did you even read the OP?
zkldi··on Some thoughts on microservices
Reminds me of this classic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8OnoxKotPQ
zkldi··on Why is an obfuscated JavaScript payload part of an NPM command?
OP of the issue here - I literally talk about this in the thread. Easter eggs are cool, but obfuscated payloads in critical code is not.

> Hi, While I appreciate easter eggs (and think others have it a bit too much out for them), the fact that this easter egg is obfuscated sets off multiple alarm bells. The automated code scanners were right -- this looks like malware!

> [...]

> If this easter egg was unobfuscated, I would've just looked at it and gone "thats neat", but the fact that this was obfuscated to look like malware means I have to spend 10 mins checking that it isn't actually malicious. It would be nice if the easter egg was kept but de-obfuscated so others aren't concerned by it.

zkldi··on Ten Thousand Mistakes
Couldn't find the year this was posted, but it isn't recent. If anyone knows, let me know so I can fix the title.
zkldi··on Ask HN: Is discrimination to promote diversity okay?
Out of genuine interest, what is your opinion on the OP?
zkldi··on Ask HN: Is discrimination to promote diversity okay?
Same in the UK.
zkldi··on Why Emacs: Redux
> If it turns out that Types really are the way forward, then these will eventually be included in the JS core.

Not necessarily? TypeScript could easily continue being its own thing as it is now, and ECMAScript have shown absolutely 0 interest in adding types to the core language a-la TypeScript. Infact, the amount of work needed to enable types (supporting new syntax) would result in so much backwards compatibility breaking that it wouldn't even be feasible.

TypeScript is way more likely to remain its own thing.

zkldi··on Decentralized Woo Hoo
Ethereum has been moving to proof of stake for the past 4 years. Everytime these threads come up people bring up that ETH is *just about* to move to PoS, but it never happens.
zkldi··on YAML: It's Time to Move On
JSON5 keeps coming up in these discussions, and I've personally had a great time with it. Hopefully some larger projects pick it up and it eventually becomes a common occurance, or something.
zkldi··on Hop: Faster than unzip and tar at reading individual files
If I had asked them what they wanted, they would've said faster filesystems.
zkldi··on Making the dislike count private across YouTube
> "hide the like bar, and nobody watches my videos because most people who hide their like bar are asshats."

Why do you think that is the case? It's probably because the actual cases of people being dislike mobbed are *way* rarer than the case of people wanting to hide that their content is garbage.

zkldi··on Making the dislike count private across YouTube
Nonsense, Creators have been able to hide their likes and dislikes for years. This is a global change that cannot be opted out of.
zkldi··on NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art
> I know people that play games to sell their gold for real money, against the platform blessing, risking getting banned.

Why would game developers ever implement a system that lets you circumvent the rules?

> Also the same NFT can be used in different games, no need to change anything from game developers, just reuse NFTs.

What? They still have to write code to interpret the NFT in their game. They still need specific integrations for every single token they need to support, and they also control what that token is. If they choose to interpret your really expensive sword as a common one, well, tough luck.

This is just centralisation -- entirely.

zkldi··on NoFILTER – free speech blogging app and content on IPFS
So it's not free speech?
zkldi··on NoFILTER – free speech blogging app and content on IPFS
What happens if someone uploads child pornography? Does it just stay there and everyone has to deal with looking at it?
zkldi··on NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art
> Zuck makes your pentouse smaller you are going to be pissed.

And what the hell are you going to do about it?

How is this any different to the arguments against centralisation that they could ban you/remove your belongings at any time?

This is just centralisation again!

> a dev with a similar game could say that some other NFT from some other competitor game will unlock equivalent items in my game

Firstly, gamers absolutely do not want to constantly have to jump ship between clients -- that is a horrific inconvenience and you completely underestimate the network effect.

Secondly, why would any developer ever implement NFTs if the benefit of them is that another developer could pluck your customers?

zkldi··on NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art
And who determines who can distribute those NFTs?

Can I mint my own land ownership token? Obviously not, which means there's still a centralised authority on who owns what.

The game client could just change how it interprets address 0x32c12... as a plot of land and point it somewhere entirely different. This is still completely centralised!

The client for the game still has to explicitly only acknowledge a set of NFTs. Why do you even need the blockchain when the client already has a hardcoded list of NFTs it's willing to accept?

An SQL database, some APIs for trading, and the same set of things you can buy solve the problem infinitely more efficiently.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →