HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zumu

1,042 karma · joined March 26, 2016

submissionscomments
zumu··on It’s time to break up the Ivy League cartel
> These days it's less about meeting your spouse and more a gateway to future income and prestige opportunities; IB, MGMT Consulting, Big Tech or to Law School (Politics). Those tracks and opportunities will still be there and be attractive if more poor people were admitted.

Unless there are specific reforms to talk about it's hard to argue further. However, clearly the "Ivy League Cartel" is colluding to limit enrollment of poorer people.

zumu··on It’s time to break up the Ivy League cartel
This is a good point, and I'm not sure how it would play out. Depending on the specific reforms it may be self sustaining. But prestige and recruiting channels are not in and of themselves self sustaining.
zumu··on It’s time to break up the Ivy League cartel
I must have misrepresented my opinion then. My thesis lies not in the absence of students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds but in the clustering of students from higher socioeconomic backgrounds and the value in exposure to such circles.
zumu··on It’s time to break up the Ivy League cartel
> They are arguing that elite institution's goal is to prepare entry into polite society not to provide a liberal education.

Not quite what I'm getting at. My point is more that the value proposition of the undergraduate programs of Ivy Leagues is partly the elite social circle you buy into.

Secondly, some of these ideas of "fixing" Ivy League admissions would just send those circles elsewhere, because rich families send their kids to schools with the children of other rich families.

This tight coupling of social and economic class is the real issue and radically changing a few schools' admission policies isn't going to dismantle that.

zumu··on It’s time to break up the Ivy League cartel
> some of your premises are flatout wrong. Especially when it comes to money: it is not the majority, but a substantial portion of undergrads in these institutions are from lower middle class or lower (economically) backgrounds.

I don't find the existence of students from middle class or lower backgrounds to be contrary to any of my premises. My point is more around the network effects. The children of the elite do attend these schools. The children of the elite are by definition already elite. Exposure to these social circles, even through something like the alumni network is a massive value proposition and massively increases ones chances of becoming an elite. If the children of the elite were to go elsewhere, the social network and value goes along with them.

This is not to say Ivy Leagues don't have other merits as undergraduate institutions, such as great staff and academics.

> The higher steps of the economic ladder are overrepresented simply because having money implies better K12 education in the US, which makes it easier to get into these schools.

It's not just K12 education, it's extracurriculars, it's SAT prep, it's high schools paying recruiters to visit campus, etc. It's a virtuous cycle. But again there are also network effects to consider. Rich and powerful families want to send their children schools with children from their socioeconomic class, so they cluster.

> And while the extracurriculars available are quite great, it is not a "daycare" and the rigors of education are very high.

My point on undergrad being akin to "daycare" is not unique to Ivy Leagues. In my experience in the US, there is a certain type of student that doesn't work a job, lives in a supervised environment (dorm), doesn't pay their own bills, doesn't cook for themselves, studies occasionally and who's main focus is fraternizing with their peers. This lifestyle is what I am comparing to daycare, and I don't believe this is uncommon esp. in places that cater to those of higher socioeconomic class.

zumu··on It’s time to break up the Ivy League cartel
I think this whole debate is centered on the shallow idea that "going to an Ivy League" in and of itself is what ordains "elite-ness". To unravel this, you first must consider the actual value proposition of Ivy Leagues relative to other schools.

Firstly, undergrad in America, especially at private schools like the Ivy Leagues, is more a daycare for rich kids, than it is a place of scholarship and learning. The education is certainly good, but there are plenty of other schools with rigorous academics. At these schools the children of the rich fraternize, drink and come of age with other children of the rich. The schools themselves are well connected as well but it's in large part through these bonds with their rich and powerful peers that the graduates of these schools go on to become "the elites". If you reduce the number of kids from rich and powerful families going to these places, you are going to drastically reduce the networking potential amongst classmates and start to erode school level affiliations. In short, you can't just limit admissions to solely "academic merit" without destroying a big part of what makes prestigious schools valuable. Ultimately, if the children of the rich and powerful are excluded, they will congregate elsewhere and all the prestige and kingmakers will follow.

zumu··on Laptop Review: ThinkPad X1 Extreme (Gen 2)
When are they going to make one of these with a Ryzen?

It seems Ryzens are really rare among higher end developer laptops. Is there a technical reason or is it just Intel using their clout to block the major vendors/oems from using AMD?

zumu··on Y Combinator backed MMO metaverse game is a blatant scam
Definitely damaging to the YC brand.

I'd like to see a postmortem on how these _blatant_ con artists got through.

zumu··on Launch HN: Fig (YC S20) – Autocomplete for the Terminal
> We will never sell data. That just isn't the business we want to build

What about when that is no longer your call (e.g. the VC's want returns, you sell to Facebook, etc.)? Is there anything in place to protect us then?

> We plan to monetize in the short term by offering autocomplete for internal CLI tools and scripts.

I'd love to hear more about this. Sounds like the GHE model?

zumu··on Launch HN: Fig (YC S20) – Autocomplete for the Terminal
> 2. Less trust in you as a YC startup. What if you fail? What if you sell out?

> 3. Requirement of email.

> 4. Telemetry and privacy concerns raised by others.

Dovetailing on these...

Like why is a CLI tool VC backed? Is the business model just selling our data? Is the VC backing for another product and the CLI tool is just a PR thing?

zumu··on Sublime Text 4
I haven't had issues with plugin bloat, personally.

A nice feature is you can disable/enable plugins per workspace so you can only load your Java plugins for your java projects, etc.

zumu··on Sublime Text 4
VSCode is much much faster than the popular IDEs (namely, IntelliJ) in my experience.

I'd say it occupies a middle point between full IDE and text editor.

zumu··on An Elegant Sufficiency, or the Curious Case of a Victorian Meme (2018)
This is a meme in my family as well. I always took it as a mockery of affectatious formal speech. I never thought of it as a jab at the nouveau riche let alone of the Victorian era, but it seems plausible.
zumu··on Apple Reports Second Quarter Results
I still use mine and must say, despite being a die hard Linux person, it's one of my favorite computers ever. Silent and tiny, yet fully featured. It's great for the couch, the bed, planes, traveling, etc.

The thinness trade offs with the butterfly keyboard and USB C actually make sense for an ultraportable (as opposed to a desktop replacement like the pro).

> I had some issues with dust in the keyboard I use a keyboard cover to get around this.

> Biggest downside is that it got very hot during video calls, which wasn't as big of an issue in 2016 as it is now. Agreed, it's not great for video, esp. since the camera also kind of sucks.

I'd totally buy an updated version.

zumu··on Can you become a firmware engineer(embedded software engineer) through bootcamp?
Theoretically, a self-taught dev could get into it, if they were truly motivated and found the right opportunity, but there's not going to be a boot camp for it, at least in the West. Boot camps exist primarily because the demand for web developers outpaces the supply substantially. The same cannot be said for firmware engineers in the US.

That being said, there are accelerated CS undergrad degrees out there that may help you break into the field in the fewest number of calendar months. Though at the end, there's a good chance you wind up doing web dev anyway.

zumu··on Java for Everything (2014)
Thanks for bringing this up. I am actually very excited about these features, but they are still not quite available for most of us Java devs yet. The LTS version that contains them doesn't release until September, and it will take months (if not years) for many shops to upgrade.

My critique was more targeted to the Java of the time period this article was written in (2014), but these new additions are another point for the "Just write it in Java" folks.

zumu··on Java for Everything (2014)
Do you know anywhere that actually use it? I've heard Walmart Labs, but that's about the only place I know about.
zumu··on Java for Everything (2014)
> Java’s a pretty nice language, and when my code compiles, which is often the first time, it’ll usually also run correctly.

This is the exact opposite experience for me.

I find Java's type system to be extremely lacking (e.g. nullability, no discriminated unions, etc.), such that I write plenty of application code to mimic what a robust type system would enforce. Unfortunately, since it's not a compile time check, if you do it wrong, you get errors in production. In this way, it is the same as a fully dynamic language—what compiles has loose guarantees about correctness.

Excuse me for a moment, but I'm going to be that annoying guy—but once you get some experience with an ML style language (e.g. Haskell, OCaml, SML, etc.) it's painful to go back to these class name based type systems.

zumu··on 4chan founder Chris Poole has left Google
> Not surprised he lasted so long at Google.

Is it hard to 'last' at google? I have never gotten that impression.

zumu··on Ask HN: How can a unhireable person get a job?
> I haven't lasted anywhere longer than 2 months

You need to work somewhere, literally anywhere, for at least a year.

Hiring and on boarding is expensive, such that virtually no software companies are getting any ROI for someone who is there for two months or less. I get you may have had impact early on at these places, but I guarantee they all still lost money on you.

tldr; on paper you're a losing bet, build a history of being a winning bet and more companies will come around.

zumu··on The Kitten Programming Language
For those curious, last time it was on HN https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13345832

The author answers some questions.

zumu··on The Kitten Programming Language
They explain this in the tutorial, but anecdotally it reads really well if you speak a SOV language.
zumu··on Sensible macOS Defaults
I will try the finder changes, but I have my doubts crap won't randomly appear in my ~/Desktop folder automagically.

As for the dock, auto-hiding it doesn't disable it, it just hides it. So it remains visible in mission control, and still has bouncing icons from time to time. It also uses system resources, etc.

Ideally I wouldn't have to hack around these settings and could just turn off both these features, like I could on Snow Leopard.

zumu··on Sensible macOS Defaults
I'm already using the 'autohide-delay' trick, but random randomly icons from the hidden dock will start bouncing and I can see the dock when I do the mission control view or whatever they call it.

On Snow Leopard you could actually kill the dock and it'd stay killed.

zumu··on Sensible macOS Defaults
While we're here, there's a couple things on a mac I haven't been able to figure out how to do, and maybe some of you mac pros can give me answers.

1) Remove the dock (killing the dock automatically restarts it) 2) Remove all desktop icons (Killing Finder accomplishes this, but they reappear as soon as you need to open something in Finder)

Stuff like the above is why I greatly prefer Linux.

zumu··on YC company valuations, aggregated by initial back-end language
Those are good ones. I'd imagine there's many other relevant dimensions as well. As we all know, correlation does not imply causation.

To your point, I'd like to see when these companies were founded, their lines of business, as well as what kind of competition they were facing when they went to market.

The space Stripe in seems extremely lucrative, for example.

zumu··on Reflections on Using Haskell for My Startup
The talent pool is probably smaller, but passionate. It's many people's dream to write Haskell (or other FP) for a living, myself included.

If I may shill, if anyone is hiring for Haskell or FP roles, please let me know.

zumu··on José Valim Reveals “Project Nx” (Numerical Elixir) [audio]
> or when you're company decides to go all in on Kafka for communication between micro services.

What's the issue with Kafka and Elixir?

zumu··on An experiment in teaching a language without relying on translation
I learned Japanese without translation, but I learned it in a classroom in Japan.

From that experience, I don't know how you expect to start with reading and not listening first. You really need to hear something over and over and watch people pronounce the words to learn it properly yourself.

zumu··on How Homogeneous Is Japan?
> In fact, Masayoshi Son IS a Japanese citizen, and the only reason people think of him as being part of the Korean minority is that he’s famous enough that the media looked up and reported his ancestry.

Uh, his last name is Korean which makes it pretty obvious.

This type of base level misunderstanding deeply erodes the credibility of the author.

I agree that there is more diversity in Japan than many realize, but in my experience living there, it's still significantly more homogeneous than similarly prosperous Western countries.

← PreviousPage 6 of 15Next →