That depends on what your society values most of all. In China, "stability" is king, in the same way that the U.S. values "freedom" over everything else. This shapes what tradeoffs and sacrifices your society is generally ok with, and what course of action its government generally takes.
However, just because a country has chosen a particular value, it doesn't mean that that value is the objectively best for that country. It's impossible to have some sort of rational discussion of this, though. :)
So no, it is not true that China must censor political dissidents, and we don't know if not doing so would be catastrophic, it's just that the Chinese people prefer that their government does so.