Well, at the very least, "the sixth was nearly a match" is pretty damning.
"Nono, you've got it wrong, MY password is hunterTHREE - you see there was this incident..."
"Nono, you've got it wrong, MY password is hunterTHREE - you see there was this incident..."
But realistically I think your right. People will gladly handout passwords to people who sound authoritative. It's amazing to me how many DEFCON talks begin with: "So we just pretended to be X and asked for their password and got it."