Hacker News Reader

Comment by Kayou | Hacker News Reader

Nice one, you compare second hand prices to brand new prices. Anandtech's goal is to guide you in the chip market buying it brand new, not hunting it on ebay. Also, what they say with the 1950x being the best compromise between number of PCIe lanes, processing power, maximum memory etc. If you didn't notive, performance is not their only criteria.

View on HN

I listed dual/quad 8180 as a good option. I don't think you can get second hand 8180 on ebay.

For 1950x, details explanations were provided in my post -

1. too sloow, cinebench score is 3k, you can get it from 4-5 years old ancient processors already declared as EOL. 2. no official ECC support

I can list more actually - single socket system with 8 DIMMs only. As explained, it is a good platform for kids to game/overclock.

Sure, but as you say yourself, the 8180 isn't the same budget at all, so I excluded it from your price comparison. Also, it's not a competitor to the 1950x. I guess in the end it all depends on what you need to do. Your need seems to be maximum performance, why go for the best "compromise" CPU and then criticize their choice? Clearly you should go for either of the 3 recommended CPU for performance. (which are also better for PCIe lanes and memory, but have a poor performance price ratio).

if it is about budget, or performance per $, surely you'd be buying Xeon from ebay. you don't lose anything as the likelihood of having a dead processor 18 months from now is pretty much 0, no warranty required.

if it is about PCIE lanes, you should at least be buying dual socket systems, that gives you more PCIE lanes than 1950x.

if it is about memory, well, 1950x is limited to 8 DIMMs.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com