Edit. I don’t mean to go against the prevailing opinions but it seems like something that merits more research. There’s a lot we don’t know about this virus.
Edit. I don’t mean to go against the prevailing opinions but it seems like something that merits more research. There’s a lot we don’t know about this virus.
TL;DW: Preventing transmission in the long term is impossible and the actual fatality rate is likely on the order of 0.1%, so general lockdowns are pointless and being driven mostly by political considerations (something must be done and this is something). Just protect the elderly and weak.
This is ludicrously optimistic. The virus has already killed over 0.1% of the entire population of New York City, and it's barely starting to wind down (i.e. will probably hit 0.2%). It's also approaching 0.1% of the entire populations of several of the hardest hit areas across the US (Bergen County, NJ; Chelsea, MA; Orleans Parish, NJ), with the most optimistic antibody and random sampling studies suggesting no more than one-third of the total populations infected at this point.
Some of the most reasonably optimistic numbers that are being bandied about nowadays are three to four times higher than that (0.3-0.4%), though I think the majority of the evidence points to a range more like 0.5-1.0%.
Wait, what? That would be one person in every 1000? Population of 8,398,748[1] that would be... huh. Confirmed deaths, 8,448[2].
Nice, as they say on another site.
I agree that this seems overly optimistic, but the high end of that range seems plausible in light of the figures we're seeing, no? That is, if we're at 0.1% fatalities at (say) 25% infected, then that would imply 0.2% at 50%.
The relevant number is excess deaths due to C19, which are hard to estimate during a pandemic. That will be much lower than these numbers being reported.
Given the catastrophic impact on nursing homes in the U.S. so far, that’s clearly something we’ve completely botched.
It's still possible it will look wiser in the long-term, but it certainly doesn't so far.