Where's the coordination? People in subreddits are talking about what they are doing and others are choosing to do the same thing.
No different from somebody on CNBC providing stock picks.
No different from somebody on CNBC providing stock picks.
We give that a free pass but suddenly a loosely-organized internet forum is a problem.
1. If Cramer said "Hey, let's all buy this stock because there is a potential short squeeze.", then that would be illegal because it's attempting to create an artificial market pump through short squeezing.
2. Cramer is LICENSED to give investment advice. A licensed doctor can go on TV and make medical recommendations. Reddit specifically bans subs that try to do that.