I’m thinking it would be more accurate (by being less precise) for BBC to describe the 1:1000 possibility as just coincidence rather than “statistical” coincidence.
Here's an old article from the time of the Higgs Boson discovery that had a great explanation:
https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/five-sigma...
> Chances are, you heard this month about the discovery of a tiny fundamental physics particle that may be the long-sought Higgs boson. The phrase five-sigma was tossed about by scientists to describe the strength of the discovery. So, what does five-sigma mean?
> In short, five-sigma corresponds to a p-value, or probability, of 3x10-7, or about 1 in 3.5 million. This is not the probability that the Higgs boson does or doesn't exist; rather, it is the probability that if the particle does not exist, the data that CERN scientists collected in Geneva, Switzerland, would be at least as extreme as what they observed. "The reason that it's so annoying is that people want to hear declarative statements, like 'The probability that there's a Higgs is 99.9 percent,' but the real statement has an 'if' in there. There's a conditional. There's no way to remove the conditional," says Kyle Cranmer, a physicist at New York University and member of the ATLAS team, one of the two groups that announced the new particle results in Geneva on July 4.
The BBC article says:
> The measurement from LHCb is three-sigma - meaning there is roughly a one in 1,000 chance that the measurement is a statistical coincidence
My interpretation of this is "If there was no new physics, then there is a 1/1000 chance the same result could be measured by coincidence."
I understand why some people may interpret this as "There is a 1/1000 chance that there is no new physics" though.
I now see your criticism and I agree the subjunctive is much clearer. I guess my brain just converts the other wording into yours whenever I read text like that.
Actual subjunctives are only rarely used in English and often sound clunky. If you did use it it would be "There is a one in a 1,000 chance that the measurement arise by statistical coincidence". Note that it must be "arise", not "arises".
I'll correct it in my comment (you're replying to someone quoting me).
"I don't think he'd appreciate you stealing his spotlight on grammatical minutia."
"I wouldn't bet on it."
You can read more about it here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_subjunctive
Also note that I'm specifically referring to the plain subjunctive. There is also something sometimes referred to as the "past/imperfect subjunctive" which is something different entirely.
I think, however, that I prefer your rigorous distinctions. Moods seem to be important to human language, even if they're atrophied in English. So keeping the gate on the subjunctive vs conditional distinction points people toward a deeper understanding of how language works.
"There is a one in 1,000 chance that the measurement would arise by statistical coincidence" uses the conditional, (implicitly) presuming a hypothesis and saying something about the chance that, under that hypothesis, such a measurement as occurred would occur. It's P(data | hypothesis).
Re “statistical”, to me, it sort of implies all sources of error or variability were provably not present (prove a negative) and the only reason for a coincidental result was a statistical anomaly. What’s got to be far more likely is some unaccounted-for variable produced the coincidental result.
I'm not statistician however so presumably I'm just as wrong