Myself I was thinking it’d make sense with some variation of Dutch auction in rounds, where all participants in a round get the same price. What would you say the upside of VCG is? Dutch seems simpler and fair to me.
The advantages of VCG over that would be:
- it's easier to implement. Dutch is admittedly easier to understand, but with VCG your average buyer would only need to fill a box in a form.
- there is provable dominance of truthful bidding
There are also downsides, admittedly:
- it doesn't maximize seller revenues
- it doesn't work if all bidders collude (unlikely in this scenario)
- a dishonest seller could use shill/fake bids to increase the going price