Why? And exactly how do you mean that?
Is the safety track record of private industry worse than that of eg non-profit or state owned industry.
Why? And exactly how do you mean that?
Is the safety track record of private industry worse than that of eg non-profit or state owned industry.
Private sector hospitals, which are arguably the closest direct analog with public sector counterparts, have higher rates of workplace injury than public sector hospitals. By comparison private teachers have lower rates, but work with less at risk populations etc.
PS: Reports of illness are noticeably higher in the public sector, but that likely relates to differences in PTO etc.
I was more thinking of industrial accidents, for example.
In any case, when given the right incentives, profit seeking companies are excellent at promoting safety.
Similarly, bureaucrats working for organisations without a profit-motive don't magically follow the same preferences we might dream up in our armchairs. They also need to be given the right incentives.
If anything public sector industries are far far larger in terms of scale, so it's likely that 1 single public disaster trumps many private ones. However, private sector has shown time and time again that it can create huge issues, for example take the forever chemicals inside you right now that you didn't consent to having inside you.
I want to believe private and corporate is better. It's hard for me.
You can always ensure the profitable accident level stays above this with steeper penalties from regulation though.
> [...] the threshold most people are comfortable risking their lives for a job for [...]
This suggests that employers with a reputation for danger would have higher labour costs.
Sure, but I don't see how that relates to the topic at hand? This constraint exists for all organisations. As do budget constraints.
These types of contracts are often selected for lowest bidder. I know of one such example where the contractor was pressed during the bid process about how they could be so competitive with their quote. The retort was to the effect of "Our secret is we do more with less." Unless there really is a vast difference in capability of the competing contractors, this naturally puts downward pressure on just doing less (in the form of following certain requirements).
Even if there was a case where a bidder is non-profit, I can't fathom how they would bid on a project with the intent to be in the red. Maybe there are more exotic ways to run a lab, but it seems like the choice is to either figure out how to work with a profit motive or be a primarily civil servant lab.
The govt can sometimes try a "best value" award instead of low bidder, but that tends to make lawyers skittish because it opens up avenues for the losing bidders to protest the award.
Yes, exactly. Budget constraints exist for all organisations.
Profit isn't usually a big part of any budget.
Ok, but budget directly influence profit, no?
Do you have a proposed solution? How would one mitigate the "low bid" incentive?
My experience is that it creates an incentive to often create excessively low bids (to the point of not being profitable) in order to ensure a company gets a contract. And then ensure their "budget/profit" is made up by either a) cutting corners to reduce overhead or b) making change orders to increase revenue.
One solution is additional oversight, but it's not clear to me that is a feasible option.