More generally, my point about video games was just that you can frequently cut their size by 50-75% just by turning on file compression on the game directory. Developers are obviously missing some easy wins in this area - including huge wins with lossless compression alone.
I tried using it in a WebGL game, but found that a) decoding was too slow, and b) the quality was too low.
PNG is much bigger, so you’d think it wouldn’t be good for a web game, but once an image has been downloaded and cached, the most important factor is the decode-and-upload time. On the web, PNG and JPEG handily beat basisu there.
In a different situation, basisu could have worked out for me. On native rather than web, maybe the decode time would have been fine. With more photographic rather than geometric assets, maybe the quality would have been fine.
1. Larger size on disk
2. Reduced quality at all MIP levels
3. Complexity of each platform wanting its own special format.
Basis fixes 1 (by adding an extra layer of compression) and 3 (by transcoding to almost any format at load time). But it doesn’t fix 2, and it adds another downside -- decompressing and transcoding is relatively slow.