The problem is that it's selectively enforced, which makes the legislation dubious at best. There are hundreds of monopolies or quasi-monopolies out there that will never be challenged.
The problem is that it's selectively enforced, which makes the legislation dubious at best. There are hundreds of monopolies or quasi-monopolies out there that will never be challenged.
Not having anti-trust legislation isn’t going to increase competition. Say you need more competition, also isn’t going to increase competition. Real markets naturally tend towards monopolies, only governments putting a thumb-on-the-scales to prevent monopolies keeps competition alive long term. Something the US seems to have forgotten in the past couple of decades.
I don't think it is an issue with enforcement alone, but with laws that do not sufficiently obligate enforcement. Such laws are not created because politicians are corrupt.
Concluding that regulation dosn't help when what we're observing is non-enforcement is a bit disingenuous. If I'm being charitable.
But they haven’t been used for decades, because regulators have decided not to use them. There are of course many reasons for that, including political pressure and regulatory capture. But to say the laws don’t exist, is just wrong. They exist, they just haven’t been used for a long time.
Also writing law to obligate enforcement is tautological. All law is meant to be enforced. Who’s gonna enforce the enforcement of enforcement laws? And why would they not be subject to same pressures to under-enforce as well?
> Concluding that regulation dosn't help when what we're observing is non-enforcement is a bit disingenuous. If I'm being charitable.
Why do think I came to that conclusion? My comment argues quite the opposite.
See eg https://fee.org/articles/the-myth-that-standard-oil-was-a-pr... or https://www.econlib.org/archives/2013/01/great_moments_i_6.h... or https://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2017/Hendersonpreda...
> Furthermore, and also in contradiction to monopoly theory, Standard Oil’s share of the market had declined from close to 90 percent in the late 1800s to about 65 percent at the time of the court’s ruling. These facts, however, did not faze the judiciary. The court ruled that because Standard Oil had consolidated some 30 divisions under one single management structure it counted as a monopoly. In other words, Standard Oil did precisely the opposite of what monopoly theory maintains—it reduced rather than raised prices, it increased rather than cut production, it lost rather than “controlled” market share, and it paid its employees more rather than less than its competitors—yet the theory that Standard Oil engaged in “predatory practices” and “exploited” consumers has prevailed in our history books.
Are you suggesting that all legislation is equally prone to abuse through selective enforcement? That's wrong. Legislation differs a lot in how straightforward it is to enforce universally.
Eg legislation about what people do in the privacy of their own bedrooms is almost impossible to enforce. Legislation about which side of the road cars should drive on almost enforces itself: you don't need the police to write you a ticket to figure out that driving on a different side of the road than everyone else in your country is a bad idea.
Would really like to see a credible source for this statement. There are industries where this happens (natural monopolies which is stuff like raw commodities, as competitors cannot mine at the place where you mine) but I don't think this holds in general at all.
given that all industries consolidate and end up with 2-3 major players in every field, your assumption does not seem to hold at all.
No because the legislation does not clearly define what a monopoly is, making it easy for politicians to hijack it for any reason they want.
Some of the purpose of antitrust enforcement is to establish a baseline to "warn" other companies. They've only really interfered with a handful of tech acquisitions in the last year, but it sure sounds like everyone doing M&A is being very careful right now.
Sometimes a credible threat of enforcement is enough.