But reselling is always allowed. I wonder where the legal line is between renting and selling back and forth.
To use a Non-US example of the judiciary looking the other way because the letter of the law is satisfied, but not the intent:
https://www.mei.edu/publications/temporary-marriage-iran-and...
It did not last long.
It wasn't the buying and reselling. It was the editing and digital lock picking.
Went to the Supreme Court, and they got owned. Company was shut down.
IIRC the trouble came down to the notion of retransmission (thus copyright violations). The argument that it was being sent to just one customer was not really accepted by the justices I think.
It was several markets, not just NY. Houston was one because I remember briefly subscribing to Aereo.