Real world investment doesn't work on a millisecond basis. It doesn't even work on a per-minute basis - at best, it works on a daily basis.
So if we were talking about how the financial markets benefit the real economy, we would say that Alice wants to sell at price X on Tuesday, and Bob wants to buy at price Y on Tuesday. And in that case, the go-between is unnecessary.
Nobody in the real economy needs instant order fulfillment when even regular bank transfers take a day to clear.
I get that more frequent dealings can help with finding "right" prices. It certainly reduces the spread. The problem is that HFT makes market access unequal.
You claim that Alice could have held out for $10.05 if she had wanted to. This is incorrect. Alice most likely does not have the infrastructure in place, and the fixed costs would be far too high for her to participate in that game. So in fact Eve did not provide any kind of useful service to Alice. Eve exploited unequal access to the market for her personal gain.
From a libertarian perspective you may say that's fine, granted. But the argument that Eve provided a service to the real economy is not as clear as you make it seem.
So there is a tradeoff there. HFT reduces spreads and perhaps helps price finding. However, for most market participants form the real economy, intra-day fluctuations dominate the spreads by orders of magnitude anyway, so reducing the spread isn't even that much of a useful service to the real economy - at least not to the extent it happens today. On the other hand, HFT makes access to the market unequal, limiting market competition.
It seems unlikely to me that the current situation is a proper balance within this tradeoff.