I entirely agree. But if you find yourself in the minority, then I encourage you to objectively consider what's more likely: Are you right, or are most other people right? Or maybe there is no right and wrong (aside from being consistent)?
Sometimes the minority is right. But usually that's not the case.
> See hand washing in the medical profession before it was understood.
Ooookayy. I would not compare any technical decision in this space to that. A bit grandiose. More traditionally one says "10k flies can't be wrong: poop must taste great!".
> If a person can't write down (convincingly) all of the tacit knowledge required to make the same decision, they are not being dishonest.
I agree. As long as they don't claim otherwise. I'm sure you're an expert, with lots of experience. Experience that creates a good judgement, and good intuition. But that also describes the majority of the experts, who, turns out, disagree with you.
>> You'd be surprised. > No, I wouldn't.
Then... you disagree with the "of course", you said.
> mail package version is decreased from 2.8.0 to 2.7.1
What does that mean? A dependency version decrease? If this is a commit on the mail package itself, then what does it mean?
I'm going to assume that's a dependency version change.
"10k flies can't be wrong" is one thing, but "the majority expert opinion in my field is wrong"... is almost always wrong.
Most theories are wrong, even by experts. It's not even embarrassing to be wrong.
But to defend your policy on objective grounds, is like asserting Ruby should be used for all programming. It's Not Even Wrong. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong