But that is the rub isn't it, its easy to understand why, from a business perspective, ComCast (nee Xfinity) might think it has the right to limit bandwidth to YouTube while providing full bandwidth to its Video-on-demand service right?
And yet that is exactly the sort of behavior Google argued against in ite neutrality plea arguing that it is about the customer's perspective that is important here, and if the customer wants to get their video from YouTube, their ISP should be prevented from interfering with that, especially if they have a conflict of interest going on.
And guess what, Google has a fecal-load of conflict of interest when you start putting a server on your Google Fiber, that is perhaps an "AppEngine" account they didn't get, or a better email experience than Gmail, or really awesome photo sharing. All things that Google would not get any revenue (advertising or otherwise) if they let that happen.
I expect that we'll eventually get to packet access to the Internet is a city service, like sewer and garbage, and all of this will be moot. But until this is a really poor move on Google's part and entirely hypocritical to their earlier stance. So in that regard I feel the headline is spot on.