This whole thing reads to me as purest wind.
EDIT: At least on a conventional train, I can ride from somewhere that's not at one of the endpoints to somewhere else that isn't; and, of course, I can go to the bathroom.
I read a post last week that compared the situation to the Shinkansen, which was an expensive political show project until they figured out how to get it to population centers.
If your point is they started off with areas they still needed to work out like connection to population centers, then I think you're on the wrong site: every startup we discuss pivots in one way or another to overcome challenges, that's an accepted part of developing something useful. If you don't try you're never going to get to a point when you can find a solution to problems you don't know exist yet.
If there was a hyperloop between the edges of SF and LA, how many minutes do you think it would take before someone worked out how to get passengers the short distance from the station to the city center?
On your other point: how much incentive is there to get people from SF to Mountain View faster? HUGE incentive, is the answer to that question. What's the answer right now? 101 and 280, or a long slow train ride.
EDIT: Also, a Hyperloop that terminated where the PDF proposes just wouldn't -- and probably shouldn't -- get built.
I'm sure we'll see it in built in China in a few years time then. No doubt it will be plagued with problems, maybe a few deaths. It'll be labeled a white elephant for a few years. But in 25 years time when everyone in China is zipping about at over 1000km/h and people in SF and stuck in traffic shouting about the good old days and refusing to build anything new because good isn't perfect, you'll be lamenting the lack.
But I doubt it. And in any event, the idea that we should build a toy project because it offers some improvements to some parts of a current problem for some small number of people is a perfectly defensible one -- on Hacker News. As an actual spending cash sort of idea, it's fairy tale nonsense. You can see how seriously Musk takes it by how serious the proposal actually is w/r/t nuts and bolts -- not at all.
How can they know where the track would run? You want an actual train schedule already?
If it is unacceptable not to have a bathroom, then cars are also unacceptable. Somehow it works for many people anyway.
I wonder whether existing HSR plans had to meet requirements this stringent.
And pitching this fluff as SF -> LA without tackling the last mile -- perhaps the hardest part -- is all a reasonable person needs to know to know it's just waffle.
Amtrak is obviously not a model of efficiency, but it's certainly a valid data point about the scale of operating costs we're talking about.
The $20 ticket is a myth. The only way anyone pays $20 to ride this thing is if the taxpayers take up the other $140 of slack.
The overhead of those workers' wages would scale roughly with ridership. Amtrak ridership is up dramatically this year[0], but it is still 20x smaller than for domestic air travel[1]. They employ nearly 5000 people in mechanical and maintenance roles[2], which is a cost largely independent of ridership.
You can argue the case that Musk's cost estimates are overly optimistic, but Amtrak's operating costs are largely relevant.
[0] http://www.sacbee.com/2013/03/01/5227255/amtrak-ridership-up...
[1] http://www.transtats.bts.gov
[2] http://www.amtrak.com/ccurl/533/3/Amtrak-Mechanical-Services...
The only point I was actually trying to make is the (I hope) uncontroversial one that operating expenses for a transit system are high.
I think (if it gets built!) we'll see very few humans operating or maintaining the hyperloop.
It's never getting built, though. An insurmountable advantage of HSR is that it can serve population centers along its route, which makes ROW acquisition feasible.
I don't think the car company has much to do with things (you can make an argument that a better HSR infrastructure would help Tesla, not hurt it, by reducing its customers need for the long-haul drives that are the weak point of electric cars), but I do think the Hyperloop is best understood as a political maneuver to complicate CA HSR.