I had COBRA for many months from my former employer (worked well, very expensive). Then I found an excellent broker in the Atlanta area and got a good HSA plan from Aetna. So far so good, much cheaper, provided we don't have claims.
My guess has always been that COBRA is probably something that's required by law for employers to offer, but there's probably some loophole somewhere that allows them to price it so high that very few people actual take them up on it.
I've bought insurance through Cleveland's COSE (Council of Smaller Enterprises) in the past. Pretty expensive, but really good coverage (I have a family).