The part I'm confused about is the distinction between what the Empire State Building management is doing in this setup and selling someone access.
This is also what ESB would be doing by letting people rent antennas and streaming servers.
Aereo is selling streaming TV service that just happens to use antennas in the backend.
You might say, it's all the same in the end from a technical point of view. And you're right, but the law doesn't care about the technical point of view. From the legal point of view, Aereo is selling TV streaming, and must comply with laws for TV streaming.