HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

10111001

774 karma · joined December 25, 2023

submissionscomments
10111001··on Google will turn off search for schools that reject AI
> Very interesting approach. Basically, you can no longer use Google Search as a way to discover and learn about a subject the old-school way.

If by "interesting" you mean "abusive and coercive."

> I guess the point here is that Google thinks schools need to start using AI, and that all this "no AI in schools" talk is nonsense.

Explain that more please: whose talk is "nonsense"? Google's? Parents'? Schools'?

'Cause it sounds Google is saying this:

> You silly parents and educators, you thought you set educational policy for your students? No, we actually do. Your choices will conform to our business plans of the moment, or we will make your life so painful and difficult that you will "consent" to our demands.

> Did we mention our motto is "don't be evil"? We live our values every day.

10111001··on AI is destroying my CS degree
> I wonder how you'd do without your AI augmentation if you find yourself not being able to use it for whatever reason. I wonder what you retained when the AI is not working... or with a very expensive augmentation that wants more cut from your pay...

Realistically, "AI is not working" is probably not a realistic scenario. He'll just stop working, just like if the network goes down.

The real risk of AI augmentation is to your value as an employee. Maybe the augmentation makes you feel and perform like Iron Man, but if the suit is doing the heavy lifting, and some cheaper guy could wear it and do pretty well, how are you going to keep that fat paycheck? It's not like any of us have tenure.

10111001··on Kalshi and its co-founders face felony charges for violating Utah gambling laws
This is outrageous! They're tech founders! Penny-ante things like "the law" don't apply to them!

Somebody needs to tell Utah it needs to change its laws to adapt to their business plan, ASAP.

10111001··on Oracle files to sell $20B in new stock, bonds to finance AI buildout
> Curious to know why you think ERPs are done. I actually do somewhat agree with you in that their best days are behind them.

> It is going to be incredibly difficult to bill outrageous amounts for armies of consultant to implement or customise the product when agents can do the same for much less, or at-least a 5-10x reduction in headcount for similar complexity of changeset.

> If anyone is in the industry, please feel free to chime in as to what you are seeing on the ground.

I do not deal with ERPs, but my understanding is that one of their big selling points has to do with financial audit compliance. They're big complex, hulking things, but battle-tested an trusted. If you use one, your auditor can just check off the box, but if you use custom software, then the auditor has to audit that too (in order to make sure you get really complex things like computing tax correctly in each jurisdiction correctly).

10111001··on Oracle files to sell $20B in new stock, bonds to finance AI buildout
> - Lanai going back into the hands of the people of Hawaii.

Lol, it's 2026: it'll just go to some other billionaire. Probably Marc Benioff. I heard he likes owning Hawaii.

10111001··on Egoless Mathematics in the AI Era
> Watching Star Trek TNG as a kid, I vividly recall hearing Geordi or Data often say things like "run a level 3 diagnostic on the Worf Barrels" or whatever to the computer and wonder what the heck that would even be....

> Now I think I kind of have an answer. Maybe the level of diagnostic refers to the LLM effort level....

The real answer is that it was gibberish. IIRC, the writers would insert "[tech]" in the scripts, to be later fleshed out into technobabble.

What you say is ret-con at best. A more realistic contemporary interpretation of the "level 3 diagnostic" technobabble, would have been a particular pre-programmed diagnostic procedure (like "run the POST memory checks" on a PC).

10111001··on Egoless Mathematics in the AI Era
> Human pursuits cannot be separated from the humans who pursuit it.

But it's pretty clear you can chuck "human pursuits" in the garbage, in favor of what really matters: intensification of the market system and wealth accumulation for its own sake.

Your technology leader thinks: Humanity? People? Who the fuck cares about that BS? Fuck 'em (or "I'll fuck 'em and make them like it"). I've got stuff to build and money to make.

> In the pursuit of knowledge, what ultimately drives people is what they themselves can understand, and the meaning these understanding provides, both based on their own experience and people whose opinions they value.

It's pretty clear the message we're getting is "what [people] themselves can understand, and the meaning these understanding provides" doesn't matter, and if you care about that you're an sentimental piece of garbage.

10111001··on The future in old computer magazines (1984–2004)
> Sometimes I fear that the vastly wealthy will only remember the social contracts that allowed them to become wealthy are two way contracts after the first few have been eaten.

The only social contract the vastly wealthy will remember is that the plebs must respect their private property rights as a divine right, in return they'll give the plebs the opportunity to work...sometimes.

10111001··on Electrification Could Cut Global Energy Use in Half
> Unlikely. We'd just use the leftover energy for new things.

You mean data centers. Can't ever have enough of those!

10111001··on Anthropic takes steps to block Claude from reverse-engineering video games
> If they didn't want us to use other people's ideas without permission then why did they use other people's ideas without permission to make the ideal tool for using other people's ideas with permission?

Because they're all about what's best for them.

10111001··on Cisco gives engineer unlimited AI tokens to rewrite legacy code
> Legacy code is typically a euphemism for old unmaintained code, no one knows how it works so it can be edited, and it probably doesn't align with current work practices.

Not necessarily. It's the name for the last thing(s) before the new thing, but you can't shut it down because people are using it and/or the new thing actually isn't so great.

10111001··on US Reps Lead Democratic Resolution Opposing A.I. Bubble Bailout for Big Tech
> Most on the left would consider it authoritarian despotism if Trump started "Confiscating" companies. Most on the right would consider it the same if Biden or whomever did the same.

Eh. I disagree. It really depends on the company, the why, and what's done with it afterwards.

If the other party nationalized the big frontier labs or AI data center operators, with the rationale that AI is just too disruptive to privatize the gains and/or the companies are acting recklessly, I wouldn't consider it "authoritarian despotism," and I don't think many others would either: those companies are unpopular across the political spectrum.

There's a certain amount of reflexive opposition to "the other side," in that some people will oppose anything it does, but that's just really dumb, so I wouldn't read too much into it on any particular issue.

Now, if the Democrats confiscated "The Trump Organization" on some flimsy rationale because they really hate Trump, that particular action would be seen as you describe.

> In general, the US has strong opposition to the state unilaterally confiscating companies

Thankfully, things can change.

> and it is the kind of thing seen in Nazi Germany, revolutionary Cuba and Iran, or the Islamic state.

That's a dumb argument. "Confiscating companies" is not the reason those regimes are considered bad. And the fact they did some particular thing is irrelevant. I'm sure they also penalize murder, and your not going to get me to question my opposition to murder by saying "the Nazis had anti-murder laws!"

10111001··on Blockchain intelligence firms link North Korea to $6.3B hack on Binance
> To that sense, it's really just a disagreement on what tradeoffs are acceptable. People who have a utopian view of cryptocurrency are looking at some tradeoffs as preferable to others, it's a different failure mode.

Another way to restate my comment is: cryptocurrency is technically interesting but the tradeoffs it made to focus on certain edge cases mean that for pretty much every use-case, the preexisting technologies are superior and/or cryptocurrency is practically unworkable.

10111001··on Proton's CEO Cancels AI 'Re-Interviews'
Is this Proton as in ProtonMail?
10111001··on Blockchain intelligence firms link North Korea to $6.3B hack on Binance
> Crypto was supposed to be a solution to your government devaluing the rewards of your residual labor in the form of their currency.

> ...

> I'm hoping someone invents a new iteration that's better.

It "solved" inflation by being deflationary (and then you have the massive volatility layered on top of that).

I think it's probably impossible to have a stable currency without some kind of dynamic governance, like a central bank.

10111001··on 'Elite North Korean hackers' blamed for $6.3B Binance hack
Exactly. It turns out a lot of the things in the banking system that cryptocurrency people complain about are actually features, not bugs.

IMHO, cryptocurrency is technically interesting but for pretty much every use-case, the preexisting technologies are superior and/or cryptocurrency is practically unworkable.

10111001··on US Reps Lead Democratic Resolution Opposing A.I. Bubble Bailout for Big Tech
> Some people find authoritarian despotism attractive as long as it targets their perceived enemies

It's not that simple. For instance: a prison sentence is "authoritarian despotism" from the perspective of a murderer subject to it (or his apologists).

10111001··on US Reps Lead Democratic Resolution Opposing A.I. Bubble Bailout for Big Tech
> So, theft. Got it!

> That will make a lot of businesses focus on success here and not somewhere else.

You have a weird definition of theft. We're talking about nationalizing them instead of handing their shareholders a bunch of free money to bail them out. Not getting free money is theft now?

But, more broadly: there's more to the social contract than private property rights. And it's really hard to bring myself to care too much about the private property rights of entities who have shown themselves to not be very respectful of that contract.

10111001··on Binance-hacker-1029 – $5.6B stolen from Binance
> https://www.ynetnews.com/business/article/rjgshsl6fe

You linked an article about a single Israeli criminal getting extradited to stand trial for a crime.

Do you not understand the distinction between "the Israelis" (often used as a shorthand for its government) and "an Israeli"?

IIRC, the North Korean government itself has programs to steal cryptocurrency to fund its government.

10111001··on Binance-hacker-1029 – $5.6B stolen from Binance
> Yeah totally not israeli hackers... it has to be scary kim.

The Israelis don't have any problem acquiring hard currency. North Korea does, and has an established MO of stealing crypto and running online moneymaking scams like ransomware.

10111001··on Zombie stats: Where the numbers AI quotes come from
> I’ve added to my system prompt in perplexity “ignore unreliable sources” and “make sure claims are supported by multiple sources” and that seems to help.

Don't forget to add "don't make mistakes!"

10111001··on If IPv4 were land
> Wow, Japan has a lot

Of course: it's long been a developed country and it's densely populated.

10111001··on If IPv4 were land
The only thing that surprised me was that Canada was so small compared to other Western countries. But I suppose that might be an artifact. The map shows IPv4 proportional to land area, but a "fair" allocation would have IPv4 proportionate to population, not land area, and I'd assume Canada is (overall) less densely populated than most other developed countries.
10111001··on LLM Voice
> This is an interesting corollary to a thing I'm seeing where "devs who thought their job was writing code" are in like existential danger.

I think you're misunderstanding that anxiety. I think this is what's going on:

1. For a lot of people, using technical skills like coding is the part of the job they enjoyed.

2. Closely related to the above point: for a lot of people, technical skills was the part they were good at.

> Technical skills aren't worth shit and never were, except as far as they enable you to engage with other people in ways you and they find valuable. This used to be really far! It made it easy to believe that the technical skills on their own were what was valuable.

> But the engagement was always the valuable thing, generating technical insight was a necessary prerequisite for it. Now anyone with a $20 claude sub can generate technical insight into niche problems, so what's left is everything else. Everything of value.

3. More broadly: if "they" don't find the "technical skills" you provided valuable anymore, why do they need to keep you around? Why not cut your 10-person team down to 3 people (the manager, architect, and technical lead) and fire you and the other 6? Not everyone can re-invent themselves as a product person, even if they had the skills. It's a game of musical chairs.

10111001··on LLM Voice
> I just had one of my posts removed from the front page here which was disheartening because it feels as though what was judged was prose rather than the technical insight in to a niche problem, which seems counterintuitive considering i've always thought of Hacker News being an inclusive place for the technical and engineering skills rather than their level of the english language.

The problem with LLM voice is that it sends the signal that it's a likely waste of effort to try to figure out if there's any "technical insight" there, because more often than not, there isn't.

Maybe it's not fair that you're paying the price for others using LLMs to abuse their readers, but it's the reality that you have to deal with. It's also not fair to expect readers to wade through all that abusive LLM prose in order to find your (assumed) non-abusive post.

Once LLM writing becomes indistinguishable from human writing, it will be really sad. There will just be a collapse of human engagement, and you might as well just talk to your machine because then at least you know what you're getting and aren't being deceived.

10111001··on ‘You Are Done’: The letter sent to King by the F.B.I (2014)
You raise good points, and I think there are actually at least two phenomena here:

1. The liars: people cynically playing up fears of "losing democracy" as a political tactic to support some other political programs. I think this is especially obvious from candidates, activists, political operatives, etc. -- people sophisticated enough and engaged enough to know and think about what they're doing in a serious way.

2. The un-serious people: those you describe. Basically irrational people who believe a jumble of things without exercising the ability to prioritize or disengage the contradictions.

I don't think the boundaries between these phenomena are hard ones (e.g. you can often push un-serious people into liar territory by challenging them to prioritize).

10111001··on I Used AI to Fake a Scientific Paper. Here's What Happened
> in a post-truth world where the internet is full of non-obvious ai-generated mostly-but-not-quite-true information, academic journals should be more important than ever; unfortunately, the companies that run them had already become complacent and negligent long before LLMs came on the scene.

There will have to be institutional adaptation to this, but it will be painful and I think the end-result will be worse that what we had pre-LLM. Things will be much more closed, inaccessible, and based on who you know. The openness of the last ~30 years will end.

10111001··on ‘You Are Done’: The letter sent to King by the F.B.I (2014)
> The very foundation of Democracy is at stake!! …again for like 30 years straight now.

There's a very easy method to tell if someone making that claim is a liar: ask "what major ideological compromise are they making to save democracy?" if the answer is "none" or close to it, they're full of shit.

'Cause if fascism is really our doorstep, you'd think they'd be gunning for the broadest, most indefatigable anti-fascist coalition possible; instead of the narrowest, most pure one they think they can get away with.

10111001··on Why birds can fly over Mount Everest (2020)
> And, 5 million years later, which is the time it took to design this very complicated thing, Mr. R&D came up with a lung system with both an entry point and an exit point, with hollow bones and air-sacs to temporarily store oxygenated air. It was super-efficient compared to any previous lung system and made the best use of the limited oxygen. The animals that received this gift from Mr. R&D were the dinosaurs.

I'd like to know the process by which you evolve from a single-orifice lung system to a dual-orifice lung system in something as complicated as a reptile.

10111001··on Why birds can fly over Mount Everest (2020)
> - why don’t birds get gigantic?

They weren't sauropod gigantic, but there were these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phorusrhacidae:

> Phorusrhacids ranged widely in size, with the smallest members like Psilopterus measuring 1 meter (3.3 ft) tall whereas giants like Devincenzia possibly reached 3 meters (9.8 ft) tall.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →