as a trade we have gotten lazy and complacent. many of us have figured out how to look the other way while making software that does terrible, terrible things.
we deserve to have our trade destroyed by LLMs.
224 karma · joined January 23, 2023
as a trade we have gotten lazy and complacent. many of us have figured out how to look the other way while making software that does terrible, terrible things.
we deserve to have our trade destroyed by LLMs.
LLMs are a tool, not a means to an end.
Ok I’ll bite on this. I think this reflects an incomplete understanding of what art is, and why humans make it. Sure, with enough prior examples and a bajillion tokens, you can reference the likeness of all the greatest artists who ever lived, and create stunning representations. No doubt magical.
But are these LLM-dreamed works better than what humans make? I dunno man, I think it’s a different class entirely. It’s not right to compare the two and say one is objectively better than the other.
I have come to understand that humans create art from feeling, and those gifted humans use their own personal tastes and sensibilities to transform these feelings into a representation. A human artist can generally express why and how they made what they did. They can explain the meanings and symbolism, with deep personal significance.
Art, and most works dreamed from LLMs, does not come from human feeling. It comes from examples, distilled millions of times over. But the feeling is not there.
LLMs do not understand quality. They do not have good taste. However I do feel that a lot of people don’t care about this. People want shortcuts, and most likely that’s what they’ll get, and what will be incentivized.
Post-LLM era, you can use a shortcut to get a representation of what something could be. However I see a lot of folks shipping that representation straight to prod. By comparison, the mental models created are weaker and have less integrity. You might be able to feel that something is off, but you lack the faculties to express or explain why.
However, using a voice dictation program combined with a usb foot pedal and cursor, I have overcome this impasse in an interesting way.
What was once the Ballmer peak, I should perhaps rename the Pickard Pinnacle. What a time 2B alive.
reading this made me go back to a Douglas Englebart line that has been deep in my head: these tools are for "augmenting human intellect." i think it still holds water in my experience with LLMs. i searched it up and found his paper on the subject (what a surprise, i had no idea this existed).
https://www.dougengelbart.org/pubs/papers/scanned/Doug_Engel...
I get why you made this, given how everything USA related is in chaos these days. It’s in the common consciousness, how rich that guy is and how small we seem in comparison.
I wonder what the opposite of this game might be… where you are a Latino single mom with 4 kids and no lifeline. Trying to decide where to spend the money and the outcomes of those decisions might end up being more exciting than some rich asshole spending $20 on coffee and needing to click a button 666,420 times.
Why did you make this? If it’s supposed to be satire I’m not sure if it’s working towards that goal.
Radical dependency calculation for PMF min/maxing at scale, 20 minute interview with cloud computing 2 nanometer mushroom tentacles. An intense deluge of immersive think-pieces that will forever change how you think about entrepreneurship in the age of LLMs. Increased my dopamine by 69x with 420 seconds of application.
the ceramic ones are awesome because they erase effortlessly and resist the inevitable ghosting and staining that will happen with the cheaper ones. they are super durable and will last a lifetime.
the only downside is they are reallllly heavy and require a more thoughtful installation.
Thanks for sharing this. To add on, I think that teaching is about giving students a mental model for them to abstract away certain complex concepts, then seeing how they assimilate those ideas into their own mental models, which unlocks more curiosity (and the cycle continues).
I'm not sure I understand the OP's product release metaphor. But if I tried to speak in those terms, I would argue that teaching is more like shipping 1000's of products that may take decades to be considered "released." Or maybe it's like being a pre-pre-seed or angel investor... ?
I used to teach at a top-tier design school, which attracted some of the brightest and/or wealthiest students from all over the world. Watching a select few rise into staff roles, start their own companies, and change the world evokes an overwhelming feeling of pride and contentment.
If applying for YC has you this fearful, how do you think being a cofounder of a startup will make you feel?
we still don’t know what problems to solve, but we’re gonna use AI to help us figure that out.
once we do, it’s gonna be huge. this AI stuff is going to change everything!!!
then, you gotta get away from the work - go on a walk, or better yet spend at least 1 hour in nature. enough time to disconnect from the problem. it's so important at this phase to get away from my previous mind-space and to not listen to music, podcasts, or soak in any other ideas. i know if i spend enough time looking at leaves and moss, touching dirt, or talking to my chickens, i will truly activate my background job runner in my brain, which will crunch away at this.
return to the studio, and do this process several times. resist the urge to write code or use a computer to draw UI's or whatever. keep it in your brain, where thoughts are plastic, and utilize my hands to draw and give those intangible thoughts a physical form. i close my eyes and visualize every flow, every click, every read and write to the database.
this happens in a loop, hopefully for several iterations, across multiple days to weeks. starting, re-starting, stopping, iterating. again, stay away from a computer until the iterations start to reveal the real edges of the problem i'm working on. once it feels like i can close my eyes, see the paths, understand the data and its transitions, then (and only then) is it time to write some code.
the trick for the next part is to build out the necessary stuff to implement this rudimentary understanding, using the most minimal code possible. then, i'll make a UI as quickly as possible so my brain can start to have a foothold on the growing system and map the increase in fidelity to my mental model.
most of the systems i have built that start with high-fidelity prototyping end up with a lot of rework. whenever i skip the early phase and necessary day-dreaming, i always end up paying for it in some way. the myth of the systems developer sitting in front of a computer, silent, barely moving and somehow being magically productive on early-phase work doesn't reflect my personal experience. we are all beautiful and unique, and of course we work in different ways - but i have found that shortcuts like early-phase productivity lead to diminishing returns and an altogether less fun systems development experience.
my absolute favorite of the wind farms shown is sheringham, a true ocean rhomboid. i got curious and found the website for the wind farm [1], and here's an aerial view [2]
[1] https://sheringhamshoal.co.uk/about/overview.php
[2] https://sheringhamshoal.co.uk/about/benefits-of-offshore-win...
founder: "it gets easier the bigger you get, right?" reality: "we just trade 1 set of problems for another"
ankane is a true wizard; dude has written so many other fabulous tools like searchkick & chartkick.
hang in there. you can do it. there are no shortcuts. in and through is the only way. you can be better, you can do better, i believe in you. don't give up, there is so much beauty to life, if you know where/how to look at it
you get to decide how u want 2 feel about it. u are in control if you allow yourself 2 be