HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

9935c101ab17a66

806 karma · joined July 6, 2015

submissionscomments
9935c101ab17a66··on iPhone 14 Pro camera review: A small step, a huge leap
I really appreciate you sharing these. To my eye, there were quite a few where the 14 pro is noticeably better. Take the first one — the pro image is sharper imo, while the pixel photo suffers from very noticeable noise reduction or some other smoothing process.

That said, Im an iPhone user and I very likely have a bias. It would be cool to take a blind quiz to see which I actually prefer and if I do have a bias. I wonder if there’s a web service that easily lets you do this with imgur albums.

9935c101ab17a66··on iPhone 14 Pro camera review: A small step, a huge leap
Speculative and tenuous hand-wringing about distant, unlikely use cases is not a compelling rebuttal. We know 12mp photos look good on 6 inch, high resolution screens. They even look good on desktop computers and TVs.

Why would you view 2D images in a stereoscopic 3D headset designed for video? Do existing photos look bad in current VR headsets because they lack resolution? I haven’t used any of the modern VR headsets but I’m willing to bet that there isn’t a significant difference between a 12mp and “48mp” iPhone 14 pro photo on a VR headset.

You’re also ignoring the context — of course higher resolution is better in isolation, no one would argue otherwise. But it comes with significant trade offs, like the FOUR SECOND capture time and the enormous file sizes.

If you want to print a cropped photo from an iPhone on a large poster (be honest — do you know anyone who currently prints iPhone photos on posters on a regular basis? I’d argue that hardly anyone prints iPhone photos at all nowadays, and especially not at large poster sizes), 12mp vs “48mp” isn’t going to make a difference, it’s going to look bad either way.

Anyone seriously concerned about their ability to print large format posters from cropped images is going to be using a full frame or medium format camera.

We know current iPhone photos look fine on 6inch high PPI displays (displays that already exceed the resolution of the human retina) and when printed at common sizes (4x6, 8.5x11). That’s never going to change. Making the iPhone camera workflow significantly worse for users now is not an acceptable trade off for vague, hypothetical future use- cases.

9935c101ab17a66··on Remix web framework aquired by Shopify
I was curious, so I tracked down some of that public complaining:

https://web.archive.org/web/20220523220631/https://twitter.c...

HN discussion here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31485733

9935c101ab17a66··on Why Tesla removed radar and ultrasonic sensors [video]
Uh, which engineers are you referring to?
9935c101ab17a66··on Why Tesla removed radar and ultrasonic sensors [video]
Somewhat related: I read into the case about a year ago and was shocked at how little coverage there is. There isn’t even a dedicated Wikipedia article — there’s only a one paragraph summary on the general article “Sudden Unintended acceleration” that covers all causes and prominent cases. 89 people died, and Toyota knew about the problem for years! Not only did they not do anything, they hid it. I just don’t get why more people didn’t talk about it. It’s not like it all happened in the distant past — Toyota was fined by Justice dept in 2014!
9935c101ab17a66··on Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches
It’s interesting to consider that your grandfather was probably wrong about somethings being superfluous. Im not saying that as a criticism — but there are probably necessities of modern cars you and I find magnificent and essential (whether we our conscious of them or not) that your grandfather disdained.

Don’t get me wrong, touchscreen gloveboxes are stupid as hell, but as I get older and things change, i find myself wondering if I’m being discerning or closed-minded.

9935c101ab17a66··on SiriSpy – iOS bug allowed apps to eavesdrop on your conversations with Siri
This is a strange way to reason about electronics. A processor is a “physically moving part.”

Hardware !== clunky obvious tactile contraptions

Anyway, I actually have an answer for you, at least for apple portable computers — most new macs come with a sophisticated lid angle sensor used to detect the display angle with high precision. (Previous models used more conventional Hall effect sensors which didn’t live to apples standards for a hardware cut off

Why is it importable to know the precise angle of the display in relation to the top case of the computer? Because you can detect when it’s closed with a high degree of confidence!

> How is the T2 connected to the laptop lid, where does the contact breaks?

So, your comment clearly indicates that you have very little experience with apple products and industrial design and engineer. You also made no effort to look into the matter see if you could find an answer yourself (it took me 4 mins of googling to connect the new LAS to the mic cutoff when computer is closed.

So you made a spurious allegation that apple was lying, when pushed on it, you followed up with an even more nonsensical comment that made your lack of hardware experience more obvious.

And after all of that, rather than having the self-awareness to drop the matter, or at very least, do some of your own research, you instead decide to sign off by accusing apple of misleading their users.

Super weird.

9935c101ab17a66··on Alex Jones told to pay $965M damages to Sandy Hook victims' families
Well, to be frank, it doesn't matter. Some people probably think any kind of damages for defamation are ridiculous. Others probably think this wasn't enough. It doesn't matter though, because you weren't selected to serve on the jury at the trial. You didn't see the evidence, you didn't get to observe jones' conduct, you didn't sit through days and days of testimony about how horrible and traumatic it was for the families of sandy hook to lose their children and then be called 'crisis actors' by Alex Jones repeatedly. His followers were literally harassing the parents in public.

These damages may be above average and the highest ever in a defamation trial, but Alex Jones really took being a defamatory piece of shit to a new level.

9935c101ab17a66··on Obsidian 1.0 – Personal knowledge base app
I'm a HUGE fan of Minimal Theme, and I really appreciate not only all the work you've put in to improve Obsidian, but also your thoughtfulness and skill. Minimal not only looks wonderful, but it has a really great array of options/settings, both through Minimal Theme Settings and Style Settings. I've tried dozens of Obsidian themes, and frankly, nothing else comes close. It's no surprise you were tapped to improve the default theme for 1.0 :).
9935c101ab17a66··on Obsidian 1.0 – Personal knowledge base app
> The app experience is totally ruined now. It's insanity for me to see 1Password 7 to 8 transition level of nonsense again.

I really, really don't think this kind of catastrophizing is appropriate. A lot of your complaints are incredibly minor things, and are resolved through configuration.

> Most extensions don't care and don't render properly. Fckn great, man.

This absolutely has not been my experience and the level of vitriol is completely inappropriate. Extensions are developed by third-parties in their own time, and provided for free. Have you made sure all your 'broken' extensions are up to date? Have you verified they are compatible? Have you checked to see there are issues opened in the extension's git repo? Have you submitted PRs to fix the issues you've come across?

I've been using Obsidian for about a year, and about six months ago, I paid for Catalyst to have access to insider builds and to support development. In that time, Obsidian has gotten significantly better.

9935c101ab17a66··on Tremor – React library to build dashboards fast
First of all, there are at least three comments in this thread that dont really make sense / have strange grammer, are from accounts that have never participated before, and all of the comments seem to share a similar positive sentiment towards the post. I find this very odd.

Moving on:

I'm super, super confused with the structure of the project. It uses tailwind, but with a custom prefix for some reason?

And then there are all these files in `src/lib` like this [one](https://github.com/tremorlabs/tremor/blob/a5c979959bedf558b7...) which contains 500 LOC of just... adding their prefix to existing tailwind classes.

And then we have `colorVariantMapping.ts` which is over 3000 LOC. I just don't get it? Are they reimplementing parts of tailwind specifically for this project? I had a look at the tailwind github repo but I'm not familiar enough with it to be able to appropriately discern what is going on here.

I might be missing something, but I'd love to get a breakdown of the project structure, and information on how it all interconnects.

The components and site are all quite visually appealing, that's definitely a strong point. Unfortunately, the absence of any effort to make the components accessibly is very off-putting. Even a lot of non-accessibility UX standards are ignored (like ESC to close an open dropdown). The project might just be in beta, but accessibility should be part of the development process from the start, and not just an after thought, especially since there are so many great libraries that offer accessible, compliant ui primitives for react that you can then style / customize yourself.

9935c101ab17a66··on Elon Musk moves ahead with Twitter deal in 13D filing
TFW when you start justifying a billionaire's unethical (and possibly criminal!) behaviour by saying 'well, no one was *physically* hurt!'
9935c101ab17a66··on Elon Musk moves ahead with Twitter deal in 13D filing
Your previous comment literally argues it is too early for anyone to make informed judgements about the motivation of the parties involved. And yet, here you are:

> The market turned, the valuation changed, and Musk tried a tactic to renegotiate his position. In the end, he is going to ultimately get what he really wanted, but the value of what he wanted will take a little more time to recover.

Is this not someone making an informed judgement about Musk's motivations?

9935c101ab17a66··on Elon Musk moves ahead with Twitter deal in 13D filing
> You also don’t do that for a company you don’t truly intend to purchase

You can defend Musk all you want, but you simply cannot make the argument that he is a traditional, by-the-books, conservative business man. He's an impulsive, irrational, self-obsessed, risk-taking billionaire who flouts convention, tradition and consensus. His reckless instincts and his willingness to bend or break 'the rules' have worked incredibly well for him in the past. This time he fucked up big-time.

> ...especially when being guided by lawyers that only you and perhaps a dozen other people in the world can afford to engage for representation.

You think Musk is the kind of person who lets lawyers lead him around by the nose, that he is someone with a well-known and well-established reverence for the legal profession and the rule of law? This is absolutely not the case.

> Whatever all this drama was…it’s way too early to make any informed judgement about motivations of the parties involved.

This is hilarious because the first part of your comment is literally you presenting sharing your view Musk's motivation (eg. "He has every intention of buying Twitter because he signed a purchase agreement! People who sign purchase agreements don't not buy the companies they committed to purchasing!").

Anyway, it's definitely not too early to make an informed judgement about the Twitter conflagration. Musk did everything he could to drag this debacle into the spotlight rather than handling it more discretely. He tried to weaponize public opinion for his own aims, and he also (very publicly) made a series of misleading or patently false allegations about Twitter in order to get his way. It's too late to argue that we should approach this with a neutral perspective.

9935c101ab17a66··on Elon Musk moves ahead with Twitter deal in 13D filing
This is purely revisionism / spin. If musk truly did want to buy Twitter but wanted to do so at a discount because the shares were overvalued, you really think this is the plan any sane person would come up with? Waiving due diligence and rapidly signing a purchase agreement that leaves you no outs and no wiggle room? Absolutely not. Musk is a narcissistic, unstable ego maniac but even for him, your retcon'd version of events is laughable.
9935c101ab17a66··on Elon Musk moves ahead with Twitter deal in 13D filing
I mean... maybe? But I highly doubt 'additional costs' would bridge the $34B gap between the figures. You also have to consider the damage accepting the settlement would do to Twitter in the eyes of the markets / shareholders. It would be huge and would likely have an enormous impact on their share price. Also, if Musk did go to trial and then lost, I would hope there is some way he would then be compelled to pay Twitter's legal costs.
9935c101ab17a66··on Software I’m thankful for (2021)
I've been using fish as my primary shell for probably 5-6 years, and it's honestly fucking delightful. I have my own custom theme/prompt, a bunch of custom functions I use on a very regular basis, an extensive config and I use fisher for third party add ons. I've seen a lot of people say things like "oh you can modify ZSH to be like a slightly worse version of fish" and I just don't get why I would bother? I'm already using a non-standard shell...
9935c101ab17a66··on iPhones and action discoverability

  > > Apple Support Youtube Channel? I have to use a competitor's product to learn about the iPhone?
  > This is ridiculous.

  What exactly is ridiculous about expecting a company to provide support on a company's own facilities instead of using third parties?
This is absolutely ridiculous. You don't have to use a competitors product to learn about the iPhone. You can use the Tips app, the iPhone user manual, Apple support documentation, AppleCare over the phone and over chat, or you can even go to an Apple Store for a training session for free.

Alternatively, you can choose to view Apple's tutorial videos on YouTube, which is, without a shadow of a doubt the largest and most commonly used video sharing web service. You argue it should be on the "company's own facilities," and I'm not sure what exactly that means in this case, since Apple does not have a widely-used cross-device video sharing platform.

  Tips.app? You mean that piece of trash that tells me a bunch of useless noise?).
It's so strange to see someone call an app that helps onboard new iOS users a "piece of trash" in a discussion around discoverability in iOS. To make matters worse, it seems like you've never opened Tips.app, because if you had, you'd know that it is actually a great resource for new users (the homepage for Tips.app shows me tutorials like "Navigate your phone" and "What's new in iOS 16", which are not actually 'useless noise'. If you had even bothered to scroll to down one and a half screens on the initial view of Tips.app, you'd see a clear and obvious link to the 'iPhone User Guide'.

Your criticism's aren't compelling because they don't come across as the complaints of a real user making a sincere effort, your comments read like invective written by someone who has significant disdain for Apple as a company.

9935c101ab17a66··on A remarkable kid has died in Newcastle, Utah
> What's weird to me is that somebody would have such a hard time accepting verifiable facts about a gifted outlier who happens to be remarkably young

Where are the verifiable facts? Where are the citations? You may see the story as just a list of 'verifiable facts,' but that's absolutely not what it is.

I'm not saying I think the whole thing is made up, but it isn't simply a collection of attestations that any individual can verify. It is an emotional, evocative lifestyle story published by an outlet that, as far as I can tell, is outright owned by the LDS church. And the author? They have one other story credit.

I don't know enough about the LDS or this particular publication to make a specific claim, but I guarantee this story has been affected by some kind of agenda or policy position. I find it interesting that the first two 'political bloggers' who 'discovered' his writing are Bari Weiss (a contentious figure certainly, but also one who has vehemently criticized formal/higher education in the US) and Hannah Frankman of the:

> ...Foundation for Economic Education, a nonprofit foundation focusing on teaching young people principles of entrepreneurship and economics, and promoting home-schooling.

Interesting. Oh, look at that:

> Frankman, too, was working on a story about Kevin as an unschooling success story when he died.

Listen, this is a feel good story, and it's not my intention to pick it apart, but don't go after people for taking a hard look at something they come across online. Further, it's possible your self-image (a young gifted outlier) impacts your ability to approach this critically (or see why other people would approach this story critically).

P.s.

There are also just weird anecdotes in the story that make me even more skeptical like the claim he bought a tractor at age 11. Okay, maybe it was a cheap, used tractor? No, the article later states:

> Kevin financed a brand new shiny green John Deere tractor for $50,000.

What? No. An 11 year old did not finance a brand new $50,000 John Deere tractor. There may be some kind of explanation wherein his parents financed it using their credit, but he makes the payments yada, yada, yada... but the very fact the following quote is presented without further explanation in the fifth paragraph of the story is telling:

> And, in his spare time, he had the task of grading the road to his farm using the John Deere tractor he bought new for himself for his 11th birthday.

edit: grammar

9935c101ab17a66··on EVGA terminates Nvidia partnership [video]
I really, really don't think this scenario is super common. Shitty, yes, definitely. But super common? Definitely not. You're talking about running GPGPU workloads on a budget, consumer-grade GPU that had a ~5-6 year old chipset when you purchased it. Yah, you can find other people complaining if you Google it, but realistically, how many people do you think this affected?

It sounds like Nvidia was a much better option for you from the start, and I'm surprised anyone purchased a Polaris 10 AMD GPU for GPGPU in 2020.

Conversely, I've had an RX580 that I purchased shortly after launch, and I've had zero issues with it. I've used it in a normal PC, a self-built Hackintosh and an eGPU enclosure that I use with my 2016 MBP in both Windows and macOS.

9935c101ab17a66··on EVGA terminates Nvidia partnership [video]
I love this comment. I get what the parent commenter was trying to say, but selecting toothpaste as the shining example of clear and accessible consumer choice is really funny.
9935c101ab17a66··on Figma Alternatives
On more than one occasion, I’ve had Adobe customer service reps outright lie in attempts to convince me not to cancel creative cloud.

For example, I wanted to cancel my CC subscription, and when I contacted their terrible chat support (fuck Adobe for not letting me cancel it on my own? and they offered me two months free. I said no. They upped it to four months free, and I specially asked if I could cancel after the four free months if I wanted. The Adobe customer service person said “of course, no proven”. Four months later, I try to cancel and guess what? They are saying I agreed to a yearly subscription and I have eight months left. I explain that I specifically asked about that four months ago, and ask him to consult the conversation logs. They insist they don’t keep logs and there is nothing they can do. After some back and forth, the rep SENDS ME a excerpt that supports their argument (the excerpt was taken out of context and was meaningless on its own of course).

I immediately pointed out that they had just confirmed the chat log of the previous conversation did exist, that they were lying, and I wanted to speak to a supervisor. The service person quickly agreed to cancel my sub without penalty, said their supervisor wasn’t available and disconnected.

Single-handedly one of the most under-handed CS experiences I’ve ever had, and I’ve come across countless other stories similar to my own. Adobe is scum.

9935c101ab17a66··on FB feed is 98% suggested pages and barely any friends' posts
The drop in real content is astounding. It used to be the case that I’d never ever come close to the end of the content from people I actually follow when I checked Instagram, and 5-6 years ago I interacted with the app daily. (Note: I deleted my FB account 7 years ago but kept insta).

Now I’m in my early thirties and I maybe open it two or three times a week — I hit the “you’ve run out of content from your friends” message in less than five minutes (and I follow ~400 people). It’s even worse because half of that five minutes is spent scrolling past the INSANE number of ads and suggested posts (most of which are terrible ads as well).

My friends are still actively posting “stories,” but I can’t imagine that will last forever (stories are also littered with ads, it’s insane).

Facebook has been out of ideas for a while, but it wasn’t so apparent until recently since they faced relatively soft competition, and they either acquired popular social media start ups or if they couldn’t, stole from them wholesale (snapchat). They now have a real competitor in TikTok and on the last earnings call it became clear they have no plan for regaining users / organic engagement, so they’ve decided to pump the short term financials by serving everyone a shit load of ads. Facebook’s long term prospects are bleak imo.

9935c101ab17a66··on Ask HN: What are some of the best documentaries you've seen?
It’s received a fair amount of criticism the last few years and in my opinion a lot of it is valid. I would never recommend it to someone who isn’t already familiar with the politics of the several war — at least they’ll be able to have a good chuckle when Foote opens his mouth.
9935c101ab17a66··on Ask HN: What are some of the best documentaries you've seen?
First of all, Foote isn’t a historical, or he wasn’t during filming. He’s a cloying sycophant who egregiously who thinks the civil war wasn’t in fact w war to abolish the institution of slavery. No, Mr Foote (a writer by trade) wants you know the whole thing was just the result of a “failure to compromise.”

Yikes.

9935c101ab17a66··on Ask HN: What happened to vanilla HTML/CSS/JS development?
Both your comments are very helpful, so I’m glad you did :)
9935c101ab17a66··on Ask HN: Is there a spiritual successor to del.icio.us?
Since I started using Raindrop, the developer has added features like permanent snapshots of pages you save, the ability to highlight things on webpages, automatic daily backups, tag autocompletion, and has made significant improvements to the Safari extension and iOS app. I find a lot of the new features useful, as I'm sure most users do. If I wanted a simple bookmarking service, I would use one (or more likely make my own).

> a product that serves a relatively simple and clear-cut need like a bookmark stash

By the same reductionist logic, you could argue that people don't need a bookmarking service at all, they can just save bookmarks in a text file. Simple, clear-cut. No fuss.

9935c101ab17a66··on Why don’t we do email verification in reverse?
Well said. Particularly the point around people not having email set up on an “OS” level. There are a lot of people who already struggle to effectively use modern computers and smartphones, and you’ll run into all kinds of weird edge cases. For example, I previously helped a friend who had just been using the gmail website on their smartphone for years because they had forgot their password but Safaris keychain had saved it so they could auto fill the password.

I’ve encountered countless other scenarios where a user is using software in “non-ideal” way because it works for them or they don’t know any better.

9935c101ab17a66··on Why don’t we do email verification in reverse?
The article has a section on security where they address the problem you describe and several others. Do you find their reasoning unsound?
9935c101ab17a66··on Ask HN: Is there a spiritual successor to del.icio.us?
I second raindrop. It’s not quite perfect, but it’s really good, very affordable, and new features are released regularly.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →